上课受到不公平待遇# WaterWorld - 未名水世界
s*a
1 楼
本学期上一门课,是商学院的,课程主要是小组作业,我们组一共6个人,3个美国人,
3个中国人。
课程每星期一次,小组meeting一次,然后大家一起做了2个project,2个presentation
.所以
工作基本上是平均分配,大家共同参与,合作也基本愉快,3个白人关系比较好,3个中
国人关系比较
好,有一个白人一直比较傲慢,大家也都没说什么...
整个学期没有考试,成绩基于project和presentation,我们组的成绩是A. 老师说最后
一节课是
peer evaluation,然后说成绩这样评,“如果小组5个人,有3个人给你评B,而小组成
绩是A,那
么你成绩就是B。如果四个A,而小组成绩是A,那么你成绩是A."当时没有人有异议。
接着成绩出来,我一看傻眼了。我只得了B+,马上打电话给其他几个中国人,说是分别
得了B和B-。
然后大家都说我们几个在打peer review的时候给所有人都是A. 所以我们几个人都非常
意外。现在
明显是几个美国人给我们的evaluation很低,但是他们在学期中并没有提出任何意见,
而所有
evaluation都是匿名的。
我们联系了老师,老师说分数就是这样。版上的同学能不能帮着出出主意,我们应该怎
么办,去找
Dean么?以下是syllabus的评分标准和成绩:
Peer Adjust. B+ (0%)
Final. B+ (0%)
Team Lead. A-(25%)
Proj. Present. A (10%)
Proj. Written. A (45%)
Prog. & Part. A (20%)
Grading:
1. Team Leadership of Class 25%
2. Team Project Presentations 10%
3. Team Project Written Report 45%
4. Team Weekly Progress Report &
Team Participation in Class Activities 20%
As you can see, 100% of your grade is team-based. This work is
completed by a team of several students (see below). Your performance
on the team and projects will be evaluated by me and your team members
(peer evaluations). I have no problem increasing (e.g., for outstanding
performance or leadership) or decreasing (e.g., for social loafing or
non-performance) an individual’s final grade based on your teammates’
evaluations. If you do not deliver to your team, or you do not
participate with your team, or your team does not participate, you will
not do well in the course.
3个中国人。
课程每星期一次,小组meeting一次,然后大家一起做了2个project,2个presentation
.所以
工作基本上是平均分配,大家共同参与,合作也基本愉快,3个白人关系比较好,3个中
国人关系比较
好,有一个白人一直比较傲慢,大家也都没说什么...
整个学期没有考试,成绩基于project和presentation,我们组的成绩是A. 老师说最后
一节课是
peer evaluation,然后说成绩这样评,“如果小组5个人,有3个人给你评B,而小组成
绩是A,那
么你成绩就是B。如果四个A,而小组成绩是A,那么你成绩是A."当时没有人有异议。
接着成绩出来,我一看傻眼了。我只得了B+,马上打电话给其他几个中国人,说是分别
得了B和B-。
然后大家都说我们几个在打peer review的时候给所有人都是A. 所以我们几个人都非常
意外。现在
明显是几个美国人给我们的evaluation很低,但是他们在学期中并没有提出任何意见,
而所有
evaluation都是匿名的。
我们联系了老师,老师说分数就是这样。版上的同学能不能帮着出出主意,我们应该怎
么办,去找
Dean么?以下是syllabus的评分标准和成绩:
Peer Adjust. B+ (0%)
Final. B+ (0%)
Team Lead. A-(25%)
Proj. Present. A (10%)
Proj. Written. A (45%)
Prog. & Part. A (20%)
Grading:
1. Team Leadership of Class 25%
2. Team Project Presentations 10%
3. Team Project Written Report 45%
4. Team Weekly Progress Report &
Team Participation in Class Activities 20%
As you can see, 100% of your grade is team-based. This work is
completed by a team of several students (see below). Your performance
on the team and projects will be evaluated by me and your team members
(peer evaluations). I have no problem increasing (e.g., for outstanding
performance or leadership) or decreasing (e.g., for social loafing or
non-performance) an individual’s final grade based on your teammates’
evaluations. If you do not deliver to your team, or you do not
participate with your team, or your team does not participate, you will
not do well in the course.