LTE vs. WiMax, which will win ?# EE - 电子工程
a*u
1 楼
LTE vs. WiMax, which will win ?
It seems that LTE will win even it is a later comer, why ?
It seems that LTE will win even it is a later comer, why ?
J*g
2 楼
you said that LTE will win, maybe you could give some explanation from your
point of view?
【在 a*****u 的大作中提到】
: LTE vs. WiMax, which will win ?
: It seems that LTE will win even it is a later comer, why ?
point of view?
【在 a*****u 的大作中提到】
: LTE vs. WiMax, which will win ?
: It seems that LTE will win even it is a later comer, why ?
t*9
3 楼
verizon will adopt it
your
【在 J*******g 的大作中提到】
: you said that LTE will win, maybe you could give some explanation from your
: point of view?
your
【在 J*******g 的大作中提到】
: you said that LTE will win, maybe you could give some explanation from your
: point of view?
J*g
4 楼
so? verizon does not have the biggest share in US, does it?
【在 t****9 的大作中提到】
: verizon will adopt it
:
: your
【在 t****9 的大作中提到】
: verizon will adopt it
:
: your
D*a
5 楼
but ATT and TMO will natually evolve to LTE as well, since they are already
GSM. so out of the big 4, 3 will be using LTE while sprint is probably on
WiMax
even sprint is doubting its WiMAX deployment.
【在 J*******g 的大作中提到】
: so? verizon does not have the biggest share in US, does it?
GSM. so out of the big 4, 3 will be using LTE while sprint is probably on
WiMax
even sprint is doubting its WiMAX deployment.
【在 J*******g 的大作中提到】
: so? verizon does not have the biggest share in US, does it?
J*g
6 楼
well, I am in no position to back Wimax. I dont care about whether LTE or
Wimax will eventually win, coz the core tech is not that different. My point
in the previous post was that it is not sufficient to merely mention the
Verizon's inclination.
already
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: but ATT and TMO will natually evolve to LTE as well, since they are already
: GSM. so out of the big 4, 3 will be using LTE while sprint is probably on
: WiMax
: even sprint is doubting its WiMAX deployment.
Wimax will eventually win, coz the core tech is not that different. My point
in the previous post was that it is not sufficient to merely mention the
Verizon's inclination.
already
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: but ATT and TMO will natually evolve to LTE as well, since they are already
: GSM. so out of the big 4, 3 will be using LTE while sprint is probably on
: WiMax
: even sprint is doubting its WiMAX deployment.
D*a
7 楼
对end user基本上是没有差别的
选哪个标准是商业角逐的结果
point
【在 J*******g 的大作中提到】
: well, I am in no position to back Wimax. I dont care about whether LTE or
: Wimax will eventually win, coz the core tech is not that different. My point
: in the previous post was that it is not sufficient to merely mention the
: Verizon's inclination.
:
: already
选哪个标准是商业角逐的结果
point
【在 J*******g 的大作中提到】
: well, I am in no position to back Wimax. I dont care about whether LTE or
: Wimax will eventually win, coz the core tech is not that different. My point
: in the previous post was that it is not sufficient to merely mention the
: Verizon's inclination.
:
: already
J*g
8 楼
都想再做一把Qualcomm，看样子没有哪个公司能垄断
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: 对end user基本上是没有差别的
: 选哪个标准是商业角逐的结果
:
: point
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: 对end user基本上是没有差别的
: 选哪个标准是商业角逐的结果
:
: point
t*o
9 楼
这些公司是运营商，贴近终端用户，跟Qualcomm这种源头企业还是不一样的吧？
【在 J*******g 的大作中提到】
: 都想再做一把Qualcomm，看样子没有哪个公司能垄断
【在 J*******g 的大作中提到】
: 都想再做一把Qualcomm，看样子没有哪个公司能垄断
D*a
10 楼
没有，性质不同，一堆是运营商，qualcomm是搞研发和产品的
qualcomm在4g上要lose big了。他家UMB在北美都没人用，不知道日本韩国有没有可能
用。
【在 J*******g 的大作中提到】
: 都想再做一把Qualcomm，看样子没有哪个公司能垄断
qualcomm在4g上要lose big了。他家UMB在北美都没人用，不知道日本韩国有没有可能
用。
【在 J*******g 的大作中提到】
: 都想再做一把Qualcomm，看样子没有哪个公司能垄断
t*o
11 楼
其实，我觉得是很多公司看不惯高通凭借专利垄断漫天要价的结果
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: 没有，性质不同，一堆是运营商，qualcomm是搞研发和产品的
: qualcomm在4g上要lose big了。他家UMB在北美都没人用，不知道日本韩国有没有可能
: 用。
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: 没有，性质不同，一堆是运营商，qualcomm是搞研发和产品的
: qualcomm在4g上要lose big了。他家UMB在北美都没人用，不知道日本韩国有没有可能
: 用。
D*a
12 楼
他家就是靠这个吃饭的，呵呵
【在 t**o 的大作中提到】
: 其实，我觉得是很多公司看不惯高通凭借专利垄断漫天要价的结果
【在 t**o 的大作中提到】
: 其实，我觉得是很多公司看不惯高通凭借专利垄断漫天要价的结果
g*e
13 楼
WiMax is backup by Silicon Valley companies and most of them try so hard to
get into the telecom business without success in the past many years. WiMax
is the only bet. After Clearwire and Sprint separation, Sprint will most
likely go with mainstream operators with LTE. Verizon Wireless already did
because it is the joint venture of Vodafone and Verizon.
There is no real operator willing to try the WiMax in North America anymore.
Besides, there is too much hype in the WiMax, like the claimed dow
get into the telecom business without success in the past many years. WiMax
is the only bet. After Clearwire and Sprint separation, Sprint will most
likely go with mainstream operators with LTE. Verizon Wireless already did
because it is the joint venture of Vodafone and Verizon.
There is no real operator willing to try the WiMax in North America anymore.
Besides, there is too much hype in the WiMax, like the claimed dow
z*n
14 楼
to
WiMax
anymore.
won'
In a conference recently Nokia's Harri Holma
and Antti Toskala gave a presentation about
LTE. Of course Wimax was questioned by the audiance.
Their answer is that Wimax can't beat LTE, but
may be a strong competitor of TDSCDMA in future.
Almost all european operators stick on LTE, which
naturally evolutes from GSM/WCDMA.
【在 g*****e 的大作中提到】
: WiMax is backup by Silicon Valley companies and most of them try so hard to
: get into the telecom business without success in the past many years. WiMax
: is the only bet. After Clearwire and Sprint separation, Sprint will most
: likely go with mainstream operators with LTE. Verizon Wireless already did
: because it is the joint venture of Vodafone and Verizon.
: There is no real operator willing to try the WiMax in North America anymore.
: Besides, there is too much hype in the WiMax, like the claimed dow
D*a
15 楼
WiMax跟TDSCDMA不是一代的，怎么会是competitor？
难道说如果电信取得3g license，会用WiMAx？
【在 z*****n 的大作中提到】
:
: to
: WiMax
: anymore.
: won'
: In a conference recently Nokia's Harri Holma
: and Antti Toskala gave a presentation about
: LTE. Of course Wimax was questioned by the audiance.
: Their answer is that Wimax can't beat LTE, but
: may be a strong competitor of TDSCDMA in future.
难道说如果电信取得3g license，会用WiMAx？
【在 z*****n 的大作中提到】
:
: to
: WiMax
: anymore.
: won'
: In a conference recently Nokia's Harri Holma
: and Antti Toskala gave a presentation about
: LTE. Of course Wimax was questioned by the audiance.
: Their answer is that Wimax can't beat LTE, but
: may be a strong competitor of TDSCDMA in future.
l*k
16 楼
WiMax最近成为3G的标准之一了
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: WiMax跟TDSCDMA不是一代的，怎么会是competitor？
: 难道说如果电信取得3g license，会用WiMAx？
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: WiMax跟TDSCDMA不是一代的，怎么会是competitor？
: 难道说如果电信取得3g license，会用WiMAx？
g*e
17 楼
ITU adoption of WiMax only shows American industry lobbying power, doesn't
necessary mean WiMax is a feasible technology for operators.
Most of the operators still rely 3GPP as main reference point.Operaters need
the full industry chain behind the standard, not just the paper standard.
3GPP2 is going to merge with 3GPP soon which means American is losing the
control over the real 3G standardization process also.
How is WiMax group going to work with 3GPP? It seems that 3GPP is learning
fast from
necessary mean WiMax is a feasible technology for operators.
Most of the operators still rely 3GPP as main reference point.Operaters need
the full industry chain behind the standard, not just the paper standard.
3GPP2 is going to merge with 3GPP soon which means American is losing the
control over the real 3G standardization process also.
How is WiMax group going to work with 3GPP? It seems that 3GPP is learning
fast from
W*e
18 楼
只要Intel把WiMAX做到他家芯片里,WiMAX就有的搞.一般公司现在是两个都搞,当然
Ericsson放弃了WiMAX...
【在 a*****u 的大作中提到】
: LTE vs. WiMax, which will win ?
: It seems that LTE will win even it is a later comer, why ?
Ericsson放弃了WiMAX...
【在 a*****u 的大作中提到】
: LTE vs. WiMax, which will win ?
: It seems that LTE will win even it is a later comer, why ?
z*n
19 楼
wimax was accepted as a 3G standard recently.
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: WiMax跟TDSCDMA不是一代的，怎么会是competitor？
: 难道说如果电信取得3g license，会用WiMAx？
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: WiMax跟TDSCDMA不是一代的，怎么会是competitor？
: 难道说如果电信取得3g license，会用WiMAx？
D*a
20 楼
没那么简单吧？运营商的投资难道intel给subsidize？
【在 W*****e 的大作中提到】
: 只要Intel把WiMAX做到他家芯片里,WiMAX就有的搞.一般公司现在是两个都搞,当然
: Ericsson放弃了WiMAX...
【在 W*****e 的大作中提到】
: 只要Intel把WiMAX做到他家芯片里,WiMAX就有的搞.一般公司现在是两个都搞,当然
: Ericsson放弃了WiMAX...
W*e
21 楼
可以两套系统并存.比如cellular system用的是licenced band,在unlicenced band就
可以用WiMAX
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: 没那么简单吧？运营商的投资难道intel给subsidize？
可以用WiMAX
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: 没那么简单吧？运营商的投资难道intel给subsidize？
D*a
22 楼
看看google说不定会用在700mhz上
【在 W*****e 的大作中提到】
: 可以两套系统并存.比如cellular system用的是licenced band,在unlicenced band就
: 可以用WiMAX
【在 W*****e 的大作中提到】
: 可以两套系统并存.比如cellular system用的是licenced band,在unlicenced band就
: 可以用WiMAX
t*o
23 楼
Ericsson是老大啊。。。他不支持的话，Wi的发展进程会慢很多
但最后是Wi赢还是LTE，跟技术关系不大，要看谁来主导推动
【在 W*****e 的大作中提到】
: 只要Intel把WiMAX做到他家芯片里,WiMAX就有的搞.一般公司现在是两个都搞,当然
: Ericsson放弃了WiMAX...
但最后是Wi赢还是LTE，跟技术关系不大，要看谁来主导推动
【在 W*****e 的大作中提到】
: 只要Intel把WiMAX做到他家芯片里,WiMAX就有的搞.一般公司现在是两个都搞,当然
: Ericsson放弃了WiMAX...
t*o
24 楼
Google用什么？L还是W？
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: 看看google说不定会用在700mhz上
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: 看看google说不定会用在700mhz上
g*e
25 楼
Google is trying WCDMA in its mountain view lab.
D*a
26 楼
不知道啊，bidding是明年1月开始
【在 t**o 的大作中提到】
: Google用什么？L还是W？
【在 t**o 的大作中提到】
: Google用什么？L还是W？
t*o
27 楼
这个是3G啊，那以后呢
【在 g*****e 的大作中提到】
: Google is trying WCDMA in its mountain view lab.
【在 g*****e 的大作中提到】
: Google is trying WCDMA in its mountain view lab.
W*N
28 楼
Intel gave Sprint quite a chunch, was it like 100million or something?
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: 没那么简单吧？运营商的投资难道intel给subsidize？
【在 D*******a 的大作中提到】
: 没那么简单吧？运营商的投资难道intel给subsidize？
g*e
29 楼
100 Million is probably good enough for around less than 20 sites building,
including all the civic work, equipment and real estate leasing.
including all the civic work, equipment and real estate leasing.
W*N
30 楼
I was doubting that when I wrote. The number that I remembered was more like
1 billion dollars. But don't remember the exact number any more.
,
【在 g*****e 的大作中提到】
: 100 Million is probably good enough for around less than 20 sites building,
: including all the civic work, equipment and real estate leasing.
1 billion dollars. But don't remember the exact number any more.
,
【在 g*****e 的大作中提到】
: 100 Million is probably good enough for around less than 20 sites building,
: including all the civic work, equipment and real estate leasing.
相关阅读
Silicon Photonics方向，求内推【加州理工~~Caltech】：EE MS 这个项目值得去嘛？Java developer Opportunity not requiring work experience求职场发展规划听说湾区华为组建无人车team？电阻网络的单调性问题offer选择有人知道marvell跟rambus里面情况吗rfic 注册RF测试还是Signal Integrity?请出主意U of Washington seattle 哪些专业比较好？有Analog Devices的前辈吗？求内推。Power management IC design engineer opening, 5 yr+ exp.我们公司在招聘硬件设计人员Device Engineer in Intel Dalian (转载)EE 硬件 实习和全职哪个难中兴通讯与美国技术出口管制（三）：美国政府政策和实施细则果子有人自杀了如果苹果狗急跳墙 iphone降价