Questions about K22 - 未名空间MITBBS历史存档

o*e2014-11-02 07:11

1 楼

My first submission of k22 scored 27. I think it is perhaps a borderline
score. The paylines of the previous years were 25, 26. I still have a chance
for a re-submission.
I have many naive questions about this k22. Please do not laugh at me...
(1)I have not got the summary of comments yet. Would it be helpful to call
the Scientific Review Administrator and to push him to give me the comments
AFAP?
(2)I have found the names of persons on the meeting roster.Would it be
helpful to go the same conferences of the persons on the roster next year
and let them know me? But of course, I do not know who reviewed my grant.
(3)Should I wait for the payline, or prepare for re-submission now? I would
have to wait for the summary of comments though, I guess.

p*x2014-11-02 07:11

2 楼

同问这个写信是给scientific review adminstrator还是program official比较好

chance
comments

【在 o****e 的大作中提到】

: My first submission of k22 scored 27. I think it is perhaps a borderline
: score. The paylines of the previous years were 25, 26. I still have a chance
: for a re-submission.
: I have many naive questions about this k22. Please do not laugh at me...
: (1)I have not got the summary of comments yet. Would it be helpful to call
: the Scientific Review Administrator and to push him to give me the comments
: AFAP?
: (2)I have found the names of persons on the meeting roster.Would it be
: helpful to go the same conferences of the persons on the roster next year
: and let them know me? But of course, I do not know who reviewed my grant.

c*e2014-11-02 07:11

3 楼

wait till you get your summary report before you contact PO. Be very nice to
your PO! Do not push him/her.
It's always extremely important to network with people. But do not mention
your K22. It is unprofessional, and they probably wouldn't continue the
conversation if you do bring up.
Prepare for your resubmission. In the case where you got a worse score with
your A1 submission, it is still administratively possible to fund your A0,
if they have some margin with their funds.

f*h2014-11-02 07:11

4 楼

Yes, it is always a good practice to continue the resubmission before a long
wait for the final decision. Both submissions will be scored eventually,
and the PO may select A0 or A1 for funding.

to
with
,

【在 c********e 的大作中提到】

: wait till you get your summary report before you contact PO. Be very nice to
: your PO! Do not push him/her.
: It's always extremely important to network with people. But do not mention
: your K22. It is unprofessional, and they probably wouldn't continue the
: conversation if you do bring up.
: Prepare for your resubmission. In the case where you got a worse score with
: your A1 submission, it is still administratively possible to fund your A0,
: if they have some margin with their funds.

o*e2014-11-02 07:11

5 楼

My first submission of k22 scored 27. I think it is perhaps a borderline
score. The paylines of the previous years were 25, 26. I still have a chance
for a re-submission.
I have many naive questions about this k22. Please do not laugh at me...
(1)I have not got the summary of comments yet. Would it be helpful to call
the Scientific Review Administrator and to push him to give me the comments
AFAP?
(2)I have found the names of persons on the meeting roster.Would it be
helpful to go the same conferences of the persons on the roster next year
and let them know me? But of course, I do not know who reviewed my grant.
(3)Should I wait for the payline, or prepare for re-submission now? I would
have to wait for the summary of comments though, I guess.

p*x2014-11-02 07:11

6 楼

同问这个写信是给scientific review adminstrator还是program official比较好

chance
comments

【在 o****e 的大作中提到】

: My first submission of k22 scored 27. I think it is perhaps a borderline
: score. The paylines of the previous years were 25, 26. I still have a chance
: for a re-submission.
: I have many naive questions about this k22. Please do not laugh at me...
: (1)I have not got the summary of comments yet. Would it be helpful to call
: the Scientific Review Administrator and to push him to give me the comments
: AFAP?
: (2)I have found the names of persons on the meeting roster.Would it be
: helpful to go the same conferences of the persons on the roster next year
: and let them know me? But of course, I do not know who reviewed my grant.

c*e2014-11-02 07:11

7 楼

wait till you get your summary report before you contact PO. Be very nice to
your PO! Do not push him/her.
It's always extremely important to network with people. But do not mention
your K22. It is unprofessional, and they probably wouldn't continue the
conversation if you do bring up.
Prepare for your resubmission. In the case where you got a worse score with
your A1 submission, it is still administratively possible to fund your A0,
if they have some margin with their funds.

f*h2014-11-02 07:11

8 楼

Yes, it is always a good practice to continue the resubmission before a long
wait for the final decision. Both submissions will be scored eventually,
and the PO may select A0 or A1 for funding.

to
with
,

【在 c********e 的大作中提到】

: wait till you get your summary report before you contact PO. Be very nice to
: your PO! Do not push him/her.
: It's always extremely important to network with people. But do not mention
: your K22. It is unprofessional, and they probably wouldn't continue the
: conversation if you do bring up.
: Prepare for your resubmission. In the case where you got a worse score with
: your A1 submission, it is still administratively possible to fund your A0,
: if they have some margin with their funds.

q*32014-11-02 07:11

9 楼

问个问题：
K22总共3年，前两年是mentored，后一年是独立的?还是第一年是mentored，后两年是
独立的？
谢谢

chance
comments

【在 o****e 的大作中提到】

: My first submission of k22 scored 27. I think it is perhaps a borderline
: score. The paylines of the previous years were 25, 26. I still have a chance
: for a re-submission.
: I have many naive questions about this k22. Please do not laugh at me...
: (1)I have not got the summary of comments yet. Would it be helpful to call
: the Scientific Review Administrator and to push him to give me the comments
: AFAP?
: (2)I have found the names of persons on the meeting roster.Would it be
: helpful to go the same conferences of the persons on the roster next year
: and let them know me? But of course, I do not know who reviewed my grant.