有人专门研究“玛尼玛尼哄”# Joke - 肚皮舞运动
z*e
1 楼
https://np.reddit.com/r/exchristian/comments/7sheqn/when_i_hear_christians_
speaking_in_tongues/dt4ucro/
[–]QTCiceroAtheist 5973 points 1 day ago
I'm a graduate linguistics student and I can assure you that a huge amount
of research has been done into this phenomenon over the past century, mainly
by the Canadian linguist William Samarin.
Not only is no meaningful information communicated by these utterances, even
the very phonetic structure of the utterances proves that they are created
on the spot by the human mind. u/Procrastinationist makes the salient point
that only native phonemes are used in glossolalic utterances, but it gets
even better than that: not only do speakers use only native phonemes, they
use these phonemes in a way which maximises articulatory ease. That is to
say, they always use the most "easiest" combinations of vowels and
consonants for the human speech organs to produce (e.g. there is a strong
preponderance of the vowel A and for the syllable structure consonant-vowel-
consonant-vowel, etc.).
So either it's just a massive, global coincidence that the language of the
Spirit is limited to easier-to-pronounce recombinations of native sounds, or
they're making it up.
speaking_in_tongues/dt4ucro/
[–]QTCiceroAtheist 5973 points 1 day ago
I'm a graduate linguistics student and I can assure you that a huge amount
of research has been done into this phenomenon over the past century, mainly
by the Canadian linguist William Samarin.
Not only is no meaningful information communicated by these utterances, even
the very phonetic structure of the utterances proves that they are created
on the spot by the human mind. u/Procrastinationist makes the salient point
that only native phonemes are used in glossolalic utterances, but it gets
even better than that: not only do speakers use only native phonemes, they
use these phonemes in a way which maximises articulatory ease. That is to
say, they always use the most "easiest" combinations of vowels and
consonants for the human speech organs to produce (e.g. there is a strong
preponderance of the vowel A and for the syllable structure consonant-vowel-
consonant-vowel, etc.).
So either it's just a massive, global coincidence that the language of the
Spirit is limited to easier-to-pronounce recombinations of native sounds, or
they're making it up.
