Check this one based on CS: http://homes.cs.washington.edu/~mernst/advice/academic-job.html "15 minutes accessible to everyone; 15 minutes accessible to half; and 5-10 minutes that only a few understand. They argue that it is bad if everyone understands your entire talk: you seem too shallow. The problem statement needs to be clear, but the solution need not be (show a few equations); naturally, you do need to show that you nailed the solution. "
They argue that it is bad if everyone understands your entire talk: you seem too shallow. 很有见解
10
【在 f*******h 的大作中提到】 : Check this one based on CS: : http://homes.cs.washington.edu/~mernst/advice/academic-job.html : "15 minutes accessible to everyone; 15 minutes accessible to half; and 5-10 : minutes that only a few understand. They argue that it is bad if everyone : understands your entire talk: you seem too shallow. The problem statement : needs to be clear, but the solution need not be (show a few equations); : naturally, you do need to show that you nailed the solution. "
原文是这样的: I believe the entire talk should be clear and accessible to a bright computer scientist not in your area. This shows that you will be a good teacher, an important criterion that is frequently discussed in hiring meetings. It also shows that you are fully in command of, and can disseminate, your research results. Other people (with whom I disagree) argue that you should split the talk into: 15 minutes accessible to everyone ; 15 minutes accessible to half; and 5-10 minutes that only a few understand . They argue that it is bad if everyone understands your entire talk: you seem too shallow. The problem statement needs to be clear, but the solution need not be (show a few equations); naturally, you do need to show that you nailed the solution. 貌似原文作者不赞成“15 minutes accessible to everyone; 15 minutes accessible to half; and 5-10 minutes that only a few understand. ” 啊
10
【在 f*******h 的大作中提到】 : Check this one based on CS: : http://homes.cs.washington.edu/~mernst/advice/academic-job.html : "15 minutes accessible to everyone; 15 minutes accessible to half; and 5-10 : minutes that only a few understand. They argue that it is bad if everyone : understands your entire talk: you seem too shallow. The problem statement : needs to be clear, but the solution need not be (show a few equations); : naturally, you do need to show that you nailed the solution. "