苹果三星官司 - 未名空间MITBBS历史存档

国际科技财经博客移民网络热点娱乐民生时事公众号

Redian新闻

>未名空间

>PDA - 掌中宝

苹果三星官司

苹果三星官司# PDA - 掌中宝

f*52012-08-14 07:08

1 楼

没站在苹果这队的用户，并不是对三星有多麽的支持，这种官司的结果无非是苹果控告
三星违反了几十个专利，最后三星被判违法了几个专利，限期改正。苹果受到牵扯的专
利有很多，但是到底有多少专利是原创的，多少专利是无效的。多用点儿心的用户不会
简单因为专利局给苹果批了专利，或者苹果给出几个令人振奋的PR，就认为苹果原创了
这些专利里的技术。这个案子因为对苹果和三星两家公司利益影响太大，双方都会用到
力尽而竭，所以是洗清苹果专利面目的一个好机会。如果不认真检查这些专利，苹果可
以继续拿着专利大棒任意禁止别人使用本不属于它的技术。

f*52012-08-14 07:08

2 楼

昨天三星开始传唤自己的证人。第一个证人是介绍微软04年发布的Launch Tile，攻击
苹果'381号专利rubber-banding。抛开专利本身不管，案子透露苹果和微软在UI专利方
面有互换协议，并禁止对方克隆产品，这时就可以理解为什么微软要用METRO界面。
第二个证人介绍一个2001年的样品Diamond Touch，用来攻击苹果的'915号专利pinch-
to-zoom，03年该证人给苹果做了演示。证人2005年的后续table cloth技术也用来攻击
'381专利。

【在 f*******5 的大作中提到】

: 没站在苹果这队的用户，并不是对三星有多麽的支持，这种官司的结果无非是苹果控告
: 三星违反了几十个专利，最后三星被判违法了几个专利，限期改正。苹果受到牵扯的专
: 利有很多，但是到底有多少专利是原创的，多少专利是无效的。多用点儿心的用户不会
: 简单因为专利局给苹果批了专利，或者苹果给出几个令人振奋的PR，就认为苹果原创了
: 这些专利里的技术。这个案子因为对苹果和三星两家公司利益影响太大，双方都会用到
: 力尽而竭，所以是洗清苹果专利面目的一个好机会。如果不认真检查这些专利，苹果可
: 以继续拿着专利大棒任意禁止别人使用本不属于它的技术。

h*r2012-08-14 07:08

3 楼

苹果完全就是搞些无关痛痒的破烂专利（还不是他们先想出来的）来遏制竞争。

p*r2012-08-14 07:08

4 楼

Yes, agree. Samsung case is good to HTC, LG,and many other Android phone
manufacturers because they don't have to play the big money for the lawsuit
to deal with those invalid patents.
Just look at the news about the multiple touch technology. It's done by
DimondTouch.
"DiamondTouch's creator, Adam Bogue, told the court that he had demoed the
technology to Apple privately back in 2003, noting that it was also
available to anyone who visited the Mitsubishi Electronic Research
Laboratories' lobby."

u*d2012-08-14 07:08

5 楼

说得好；这才是一个正常人的思维。
那些把某些网站上的图片不加思考的就认为是苹果原创的，只能被苹果剥削。那些图片
有多少是标准，有多少是专利，有多少是别人的专利？如果把标题换一下，那些图片
岂不是也能作为支持新标题的证据？
口口声声说别人轮的，自己不也是轮？

【在 f*******5 的大作中提到】

F*y2012-08-14 07:08

6 楼

even though I don't fan Samsung, I don't like what Apple is doing either.

s*32012-08-14 07:08

7 楼

哎，把棒子们都发送到火星吧
★ Sent from iPhone App: iReader Mitbbs Lite 7.56

d*02012-08-14 07:08

8 楼

超薄笔记本的楔型设计索尼早就搞出来了，苹果偷过来就变成他发明的了。

【在 h*********r 的大作中提到】

: 苹果完全就是搞些无关痛痒的破烂专利（还不是他们先想出来的）来遏制竞争。

p*r2012-08-14 07:08

9 楼

Regardless your fan or hater of Samsung or Apple. You are one of the
consumers. Apple try to maintain its monopoly position, which is bad to all
consumers. More competition, more innovation, and less expensive.

【在 F********y 的大作中提到】

: even though I don't fan Samsung, I don't like what Apple is doing either.

l*x2012-08-14 07:08

10 楼

说这些没用，该轮的还是会继续轮下去

l*a2012-08-14 07:08

11 楼

Apple's dominance, though initially buoyed by its bold tapping into "
unfounded lands", relies largely on its integrated "feel" (design).
When competence comes up and mimics Apple, Apple's estate is under great
test.
Apple has been spoiled way too much, and some people choose to become free
slaves to thoughts that along being ridden by Apple, they can rise. Hugh.
It's in their sleeves and they have rights to their deed.
The Patenting system in the US has proved to be too porous to loopholes
being taken advantage of by Apple lawyers that thwarts not only followers in
the game but also those pioneers who just "forgot" patenting their designs
and features.
The US patenting system needs an overhaul so that companies like Apple would
not stand a chance in getting in the way of people's pursuit of happiness.
Fate of Apple is about to take a turn for a very long time overdue.

c*42012-08-14 07:08

12 楼

re

all

【在 p*********r 的大作中提到】

:
: Regardless your fan or hater of Samsung or Apple. You are one of the
: consumers. Apple try to maintain its monopoly position, which is bad to all
: consumers. More competition, more innovation, and less expensive.