help needed: pick a camera or camera/lense combo - 未名空间MITBBS历史存档

help needed: pick a camera or camera/lense combo# PhotoGear - 摄影器材

k*d2014-02-20 08:02

1 楼

dear photogear board, please help.
i need to take shot of my son in sports events. the distance is, in lense
term, 200mm - 300mm range in most case. I also like to have a bigger sensor
better image quality all else being equal. The sports events are mostly
indoor with regular light to a bit darker side.
the potential camera + lense combo i have came up with are
Panasonic FZ200 on the low end, but not quite happy on the sensor size.
Sony RX10: focal length not enough unless i go digital zoom/clear image zoom.
Nikon df + 700-200mm 2.8: the lens is way too big in size
I am looking for a good solution (value trade off with performance), not
necessarily the cheapest solution.
thanks in advance

d*e2014-02-20 08:02

2 楼

canon 5d mark 3 + 70-200/f2.8.

J*n2014-02-20 08:02

3 楼

人家Df + 70-200/2.8都嫌大。
5D3比Df只大不小。不过按lz的要求，Df+70-200/2.8似乎更好一些，5D3+XB2也行，感
动牌，高端大气上档次哈~~~

【在 d*****e 的大作中提到】

: canon 5d mark 3 + 70-200/f2.8.

l*82014-02-20 08:02

4 楼

Olympus Stylus 1. up to 300mm with f2.8 lens.

g*a2014-02-20 08:02

5 楼

200在全副上不够长的话，可以考虑 70D+XB2吧

【在 J*********n 的大作中提到】

: 人家Df + 70-200/2.8都嫌大。
: 5D3比Df只大不小。不过按lz的要求，Df+70-200/2.8似乎更好一些，5D3+XB2也行，感
: 动牌，高端大气上档次哈~~~

D*e2014-02-20 08:02

6 楼

想体积小又想长焦，看来这是m43的节奏呀,不过其实M43没啥好长焦头。
E-M5 Or Gx7 + Pan 35-100 /2.8?
APS－C的话
70D＋XXBIS
D7100+XXZP？

sensor
zoom.

【在 k***d 的大作中提到】

: dear photogear board, please help.
: i need to take shot of my son in sports events. the distance is, in lense
: term, 200mm - 300mm range in most case. I also like to have a bigger sensor
: better image quality all else being equal. The sports events are mostly
: indoor with regular light to a bit darker side.
: the potential camera + lense combo i have came up with are
: Panasonic FZ200 on the low end, but not quite happy on the sensor size.
: Sony RX10: focal length not enough unless i go digital zoom/clear image zoom.
: Nikon df + 700-200mm 2.8: the lens is way too big in size
: I am looking for a good solution (value trade off with performance), not

g*a2014-02-20 08:02

7 楼

XXBIS, XXZP 室内可能不够fast

【在 D****e 的大作中提到】

: 想体积小又想长焦，看来这是m43的节奏呀,不过其实M43没啥好长焦头。
: E-M5 Or Gx7 + Pan 35-100 /2.8?
: APS－C的话
: 70D＋XXBIS
: D7100+XXZP？
:
: sensor
: zoom.

y*e2014-02-20 08:02

8 楼

室内室外？
室外的话就是M43了，E-M1 + 75-300mm

sensor
zoom.

【在 k***d 的大作中提到】

: dear photogear board, please help.
: i need to take shot of my son in sports events. the distance is, in lense
: term, 200mm - 300mm range in most case. I also like to have a bigger sensor
: better image quality all else being equal. The sports events are mostly
: indoor with regular light to a bit darker side.
: the potential camera + lense combo i have came up with are
: Panasonic FZ200 on the low end, but not quite happy on the sensor size.
: Sony RX10: focal length not enough unless i go digital zoom/clear image zoom.
: Nikon df + 700-200mm 2.8: the lens is way too big in size
: I am looking for a good solution (value trade off with performance), not

a*t2014-02-20 08:02

9 楼

1dx + 200-400L

D*12014-02-20 08:02

10 楼

D7100 with 70.200 mm f4 VR
Or 70d with 70 200 f4 is
Or Sony a6000 with fe 70 200 f4 OSS
E-m1 or e-m5 with Panasonic 35-100 f2.8 or 100-300mm Olympus 75-300 is ok
too
If don't care about weight go for f2.8 version of Nikon or canon,
Tamron 70 200 VC is good as well

sensor
zoom.

【在 k***d 的大作中提到】

: dear photogear board, please help.
: i need to take shot of my son in sports events. the distance is, in lense
: term, 200mm - 300mm range in most case. I also like to have a bigger sensor
: better image quality all else being equal. The sports events are mostly
: indoor with regular light to a bit darker side.
: the potential camera + lense combo i have came up with are
: Panasonic FZ200 on the low end, but not quite happy on the sensor size.
: Sony RX10: focal length not enough unless i go digital zoom/clear image zoom.
: Nikon df + 700-200mm 2.8: the lens is way too big in size
: I am looking for a good solution (value trade off with performance), not

D*e2014-02-20 08:02

11 楼

的确，但是他嫌2.8的太大...

【在 g****a 的大作中提到】

: XXBIS, XXZP 室内可能不够fast

p*e2014-02-20 08:02

12 楼

忍的了df组合就能忍5d3组合,已经大到那份儿上了再大点点根本不是事儿.

【在 J*********n 的大作中提到】

: 人家Df + 70-200/2.8都嫌大。
: 5D3比Df只大不小。不过按lz的要求，Df+70-200/2.8似乎更好一些，5D3+XB2也行，感
: 动牌，高端大气上档次哈~~~

w*g2014-02-20 08:02

13 楼

实在嫌单反大的话可以试试em1+75 f1.8 (约合150mm的焦距，因为是1.8的光圈，拍室
内体育应该不错)

sensor
zoom.

【在 k***d 的大作中提到】

: dear photogear board, please help.
: i need to take shot of my son in sports events. the distance is, in lense
: term, 200mm - 300mm range in most case. I also like to have a bigger sensor
: better image quality all else being equal. The sports events are mostly
: indoor with regular light to a bit darker side.
: the potential camera + lense combo i have came up with are
: Panasonic FZ200 on the low end, but not quite happy on the sensor size.
: Sony RX10: focal length not enough unless i go digital zoom/clear image zoom.
: Nikon df + 700-200mm 2.8: the lens is way too big in size
: I am looking for a good solution (value trade off with performance), not

a*l2014-02-20 08:02

14 楼

室内。

【在 a*****t 的大作中提到】

: 1dx + 200-400L

o*p2014-02-20 08:02

15 楼

canon 1dx 70-200f2.8 is mark ii 300f2.8 is mark ii

e*r2014-02-20 08:02

16 楼

赞，反其道而行

【在 a*****t 的大作中提到】

: 1dx + 200-400L

k*d2014-02-20 08:02

17 楼

thanks for the thoughts, how about
Nikon Df with 28-300 f/3.5-5.6G or the 80-400 f/4.5-5.6G? lens being too
cheap to handle the job? what do i lose vs. the f4 or f2.8 lens? not fast
enough? not good for indoor?
thanks!

s*i2014-02-20 08:02

18 楼

最好用手边的器材或找个朋友去照照先试试，比如，对快门要求是多少？光线到底怎么
样？闪光灯让用么？Ｆ4/F2.8就差一档，ＩＳＯ调高一档就补上了。再有就是你要多大
的print? ２００mm照完了回去裁一下图就好了，不一定要３００ｍｍ。

D*e2014-02-20 08:02

19 楼

不只是f的区别，镜头的素质都不一样...如果以后不再买镜头。
在D7100+70-200 2.8
和DF＋28-300 之间我会选择前者。

【在 k***d 的大作中提到】

: thanks for the thoughts, how about
: Nikon Df with 28-300 f/3.5-5.6G or the 80-400 f/4.5-5.6G? lens being too
: cheap to handle the job? what do i lose vs. the f4 or f2.8 lens? not fast
: enough? not good for indoor?
: thanks!