can Harry be a horcrux too*spoiler*? - 未名空间MITBBS历史存档

国际科技财经博客移民网络热点娱乐民生时事公众号

Redian新闻

>未名空间

>Reader - 书香世家

can Harry be a horcrux too*spoiler*?

can Harry be a horcrux too*spoiler*?# Reader - 书香世家

k*l2005-07-18 07:07

1 楼

Well, I think HP6 is less exciting than previous ones. But still not bad.
There are heated debates on harry a horcrux already. What do you think? I thi
nk there is a chance he is.But it looks like everybody believes you can only k
ill to get rid of Voldermort.I don't know. Maybe that is true. and like Termin
ator 2, harry will decide to sacrifice in the end? I just hope that is not the
only solution if harry is a horcrux. Remember love is the most powerful weapo
n(isn't that like a oneliner fro

t*l2005-07-18 07:07

2 楼

I am not buying it. The whole point of having Horcrux is to preserve part of y
our soul so that you can be immortal. Why waste 1/7 of your soul on some enemy
you have every intention to kill?

【在 k*l 的大作中提到】

: Well, I think HP6 is less exciting than previous ones. But still not bad.
: There are heated debates on harry a horcrux already. What do you think? I thi
: nk there is a chance he is.But it looks like everybody believes you can only k
: ill to get rid of Voldermort.I don't know. Maybe that is true. and like Termin
: ator 2, harry will decide to sacrifice in the end? I just hope that is not the
: only solution if harry is a horcrux. Remember love is the most powerful weapo
: n(isn't that like a oneliner fro

EJ2005-07-18 07:07

3 楼

First of all, I believe Harry Potter will not die. So even if he is a horcrux
(the shape of the scar really is a strong hint) then there has to be a way th
at the horcrux in him can be destroyed without Harry having to die. Maybe the
re is a twist there that the horcrux in him is not longer usable for LV becaus
e it's been turned into good soul part, and LV has to die with the other 6 des
troyed. Maybe. less likely though, he can create a horcrux of himself, then b
e killed or kill himself, t

【在 k*l 的大作中提到】

EJ2005-07-18 07:07

4 楼

Could be that he didn't intend to or doesn't even know? I think it is possibl
e, though i hope not, that Harry has the other horcrux. Remeber, the horcrux r
ing has a lightning shape and so does Harry's scar. And JKR herself has said
that the last word of the book is probably going to be "scar"? Dumbledore did
say that he thought after LV tried to kill Harry, he turned the snake into hi
s last horcrux, but that's just a pure speculation. What if he accidentally l
eft a mark on Harry? They a

【在 t******l 的大作中提到】

: I am not buying it. The whole point of having Horcrux is to preserve part of y
: our soul so that you can be immortal. Why waste 1/7 of your soul on some enemy
: you have every intention to kill?

c*t2005-07-18 07:07

5 楼

No way. J.K.Rowling said herself in book 5... Harry was too "pure in
heart" for the Dark Lord to live in his body. Remember the agony they
both felt when Lord Voldemort possessed Harry for a while? Neither of
them could stand it.
Plus, not all horcruxes have a lighting-shaped scar... That diary of
Tom Riddle's didn't, for example... :)

【在 EJ 的大作中提到】

: Could be that he didn't intend to or doesn't even know? I think it is possibl
: e, though i hope not, that Harry has the other horcrux. Remeber, the horcrux r
: ing has a lightning shape and so does Harry's scar. And JKR herself has said
: that the last word of the book is probably going to be "scar"? Dumbledore did
: say that he thought after LV tried to kill Harry, he turned the snake into hi
: s last horcrux, but that's just a pure speculation. What if he accidentally l
: eft a mark on Harry? They a

EJ2005-07-18 07:07

6 楼

Still think the horcrux has to be a souvenir from killing his victim. Any hor
crux possibly from killing James and Lily and Harry?

【在 c*******t 的大作中提到】

: No way. J.K.Rowling said herself in book 5... Harry was too "pure in
: heart" for the Dark Lord to live in his body. Remember the agony they
: both felt when Lord Voldemort possessed Harry for a while? Neither of
: them could stand it.
: Plus, not all horcruxes have a lighting-shaped scar... That diary of
: Tom Riddle's didn't, for example... :)

f*o2005-07-18 07:07

7 楼

I think in book 6 dumbledore said Voldemort intended to make a horcrux w/
killing Potters, but he failed, so he had to make the last horcrux into his
snake w/ killing the old muggle at the beginning of book4.

【在 EJ 的大作中提到】

: Still think the horcrux has to be a souvenir from killing his victim. Any hor
: crux possibly from killing James and Lily and Harry?

EJ2005-07-18 07:07

8 楼

Dumbledore said Nagini is a pure speculation and made sure Harry understand th
e
difference between these speculations from the ones he is sure about, like the
locket, ring, and diary, etc.

killing Potters, but he failed, so he had to make the last horcrux into his
snake w/ killing the old muggle at the beginning of book4.
...................

【在 f*****o 的大作中提到】

: I think in book 6 dumbledore said Voldemort intended to make a horcrux w/
: killing Potters, but he failed, so he had to make the last horcrux into his
: snake w/ killing the old muggle at the beginning of book4.

f*o2005-07-18 07:07

9 楼

i didn't have such impression from page 506 yah..
Anyway, all are their guess. Maybe Voldemort later though 8 or 9 the most
powerfully magical number.. LOL

【在 EJ 的大作中提到】

: Dumbledore said Nagini is a pure speculation and made sure Harry understand th
: e
: difference between these speculations from the ones he is sure about, like the
: locket, ring, and diary, etc.
:
: killing Potters, but he failed, so he had to make the last horcrux into his
: snake w/ killing the old muggle at the beginning of book4.
: ...................

c*t2005-07-18 07:07

10 楼

Haha, how about this: Lord Voldemort got so scared of his own death
that he decided to create a corcrux with every killing. And poor
Harry spent the rest of his life trying to hunt them down... he
eventually died of old age and dispair.
Even now, I can't see how Harry could finish off four corcruxes
and a Lord Voldemort in a single book...

【在 f*****o 的大作中提到】

: i didn't have such impression from page 506 yah..
: Anyway, all are their guess. Maybe Voldemort later though 8 or 9 the most
: powerfully magical number.. LOL

a*g2005-07-18 07:07

11 楼

yah. I am keeping thinking of what to be in the last installment. just
too much stuff , too many questions to answer in a single book

【在 c*******t 的大作中提到】

: Haha, how about this: Lord Voldemort got so scared of his own death
: that he decided to create a corcrux with every killing. And poor
: Harry spent the rest of his life trying to hunt them down... he
: eventually died of old age and dispair.
: Even now, I can't see how Harry could finish off four corcruxes
: and a Lord Voldemort in a single book...

F*e2005-07-18 07:07

12 楼

hence snape will have to bring extremely useful information in book 7.
for example he gets out from voldmort locations of every horcruxes, or
steals from voldmort some spell or charm to kill voldmort's body and all
horcruxes at the same time.... hoho

【在 c*******t 的大作中提到】

J*n2005-07-18 07:07

13 楼

snape在hp7里死掉是必然的，嘿嘿

【在 F**********e 的大作中提到】

: hence snape will have to bring extremely useful information in book 7.
: for example he gets out from voldmort locations of every horcruxes, or
: steals from voldmort some spell or charm to kill voldmort's body and all
: horcruxes at the same time.... hoho

F*e2005-07-18 07:07

14 楼

re

【在 J****n 的大作中提到】

: snape在hp7里死掉是必然的，嘿嘿

x*n2005-07-18 07:07

15 楼

//nod

【在 J****n 的大作中提到】

: snape在hp7里死掉是必然的，嘿嘿

c*t2005-07-18 07:07

16 楼

Nay... I think it's Harry who's doomed in book 7. :D Snape could be
the next Hogwarts headmaster.

【在 J****n 的大作中提到】

: snape在hp7里死掉是必然的，嘿嘿

t*l2005-07-18 07:07

17 楼

That's a very dark thought you got there. Snape is anything but a good teacher
. God help all Hogwarts students if he becomes headmaster.=)

【在 c*******t 的大作中提到】

: Nay... I think it's Harry who's doomed in book 7. :D Snape could be
: the next Hogwarts headmaster.

F*e2005-07-18 07:07

18 楼

Since McGonagal is not likely to die, I doubt the possibility. And
for Harry I think he's going to be the DADA teacher, hehe.

【在 c*******t 的大作中提到】

: Nay... I think it's Harry who's doomed in book 7. :D Snape could be
: the next Hogwarts headmaster.

c*t2005-07-18 07:07

19 楼

No no, I truely think it is a possibility. :) You see, if Snape was
good, and did survive the war with Lord Voldemort, and wish to go
back to Hogwarts, his work against the dark lord would have exceeded
any other Hogwarts teacher's.
And I wouldn't worry about students in Hogwarts... did you know that
Slytherin, not Gryffindor, is the most popular house on the web? :D

【在 t******l 的大作中提到】

: That's a very dark thought you got there. Snape is anything but a good teacher
: . God help all Hogwarts students if he becomes headmaster.=)

c*t2005-07-18 07:07

20 楼

Bummer for Harry, he wanted to be an auror... :)

【在 F**********e 的大作中提到】

: Since McGonagal is not likely to die, I doubt the possibility. And
: for Harry I think he's going to be the DADA teacher, hehe.

f*o2005-07-18 07:07

21 楼

I think Snape will retire with glory then. lol~
about the popular of Slytherin, an interview of Jo is very interesting:
(from http://www.the-leaky-cauldron.org/)
MA: What does it do to you to see a character that you love, for people to express sheer hate -
ES: Or vice versa.
JKR: It amuses me. It honestly amuses me. People have been waxing lyrical [in letters] about Draco Malfoy, and I think that's the only time when it stopped amusing me and started almost worrying me. I'm trying to clearly di

【在 c*******t 的大作中提到】

: No no, I truely think it is a possibility. :) You see, if Snape was
: good, and did survive the war with Lord Voldemort, and wish to go
: back to Hogwarts, his work against the dark lord would have exceeded
: any other Hogwarts teacher's.
: And I wouldn't worry about students in Hogwarts... did you know that
: Slytherin, not Gryffindor, is the most popular house on the web? :D

c*t2005-07-18 07:07

22 楼

I agree with you, this does seem to be the best way to do away
with him. :D
Don't think J.K.could kill him in book 7. The funeral would be
too awkward... with nobody really mourning... :S

【在 f*****o 的大作中提到】

: I think Snape will retire with glory then. lol~
: about the popular of Slytherin, an interview of Jo is very interesting:
: (from http://www.the-leaky-cauldron.org/)
: MA: What does it do to you to see a character that you love, for people to express sheer hate -
: ES: Or vice versa.
: JKR: It amuses me. It honestly amuses me. People have been waxing lyrical [in letters] about Draco Malfoy, and I think that's the only time when it stopped amusing me and started almost worrying me. I'm trying to clearly di

f*o2005-07-18 07:07

23 楼

maybe she will just give an open ending...
like someone said before, it is too hard to use one book to tell all stories,
especially it seems next year Harry won't stay at school. JKR has to move
Harry around a lot, physicially. Just like book 5, there will be many places
Harry had to go and he had never been there before, so that will take time. I
think JKR will have a lot of trouble to tighten things up.
Not matter how the story ends, I just hope there is no more killing besides
Voldermont's ul

【在 c*******t 的大作中提到】

: I agree with you, this does seem to be the best way to do away
: with him. :D
: Don't think J.K.could kill him in book 7. The funeral would be
: too awkward... with nobody really mourning... :S

p*g2005-07-18 07:07

24 楼

This is way too complicated la

horcrux
th
the
becaus
des
b
ho

【在 EJ 的大作中提到】

: First of all, I believe Harry Potter will not die. So even if he is a horcrux
: (the shape of the scar really is a strong hint) then there has to be a way th
: at the horcrux in him can be destroyed without Harry having to die. Maybe the
: re is a twist there that the horcrux in him is not longer usable for LV becaus
: e it's been turned into good soul part, and LV has to die with the other 6 des
: troyed. Maybe. less likely though, he can create a horcrux of himself, then b
: e killed or kill himself, t

k*l2005-07-18 07:07

25 楼

Once read from a HP site. How can love be the most powerful weapon?
Maybe Harry can hug Voldy to death?
haha.

【在 p*******g 的大作中提到】

: This is way too complicated la
:
: horcrux
: th
: the
: becaus
: des
: b
: ho