如何鼓励用户参与？ - 未名空间MITBBS历史存档

国际科技财经博客移民网络热点娱乐民生时事公众号

Redian新闻

>未名空间

>StartUp - 创业

如何鼓励用户参与？

如何鼓励用户参与？# StartUp - 创业

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

1 楼

诚恳请大家给评论一下.
对于问答系统(类似百度知道, www.JiansNet.com)来讲, 目前是需要login才能够问问
题或者回答问题的。这个百度知道大概也是这样的。
但，为了鼓励参与，提出问题的时候是否就不需要login, 而回答问题，才应该一定需
要login?
还有就是，是否连回答问题，都不一定需要login?
先谢谢了。

I*y2008-04-23 07:04

2 楼

为什么需要 login?不明白，难道是为了提供会员数？都没必要吧，除非回答问题的人希
望得到credit

【在 b******y 的大作中提到】

: 诚恳请大家给评论一下.
: 对于问答系统(类似百度知道, www.JiansNet.com)来讲, 目前是需要login才能够问问
: 题或者回答问题的。这个百度知道大概也是这样的。
: 但，为了鼓励参与，提出问题的时候是否就不需要login, 而回答问题，才应该一定需
: 要login?
: 还有就是，是否连回答问题，都不一定需要login?
: 先谢谢了。

g*g2008-04-23 07:04

3 楼

You better attract more traffic first. Your site is not sticky now. I won't
visit back after my first look. You also want to do some seo, for example,
make all your questions/answers looks like static link.
http://www.jiansnet.com/question.html?qid=160 is no good. Better like: http://www.jiansnet.com/asldfaldf-alsdkf-alskdfalsdf-alksdfjalskfd.html

【在 b******y 的大作中提到】

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

4 楼

IVYtony and genpichong, Thanks for the comments!

w*e2008-04-23 07:04

5 楼

一点意见，Logo 太土了，看着不像个serious website。

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

6 楼

genpichong, for SEO, I think I can make it like /question/160.html, for
example, instead of question.html?qid=160.
Since some title/question is too long, the url will be very long if all the
keywords are in the title. Also, I don't think it will be good for user to
email the question around as the url is too long.

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

7 楼

Logo is just text. Since I want to save bandwidth, ;-)

【在 w*****e 的大作中提到】

: 一点意见，Logo 太土了，看着不像个serious website。

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

8 楼

人希
You are right, login可以使回答问题的人得到credit. 但，我准备设置个匿名帐号，
这样，如果不愿意login,可以用匿名问问题或者回答。这个idea如何?

【在 I*****y 的大作中提到】

: 为什么需要 login?不明白，难道是为了提供会员数？都没必要吧，除非回答问题的人希
: 望得到credit

w*e2008-04-23 07:04

9 楼

Text can be much better looking. (Color, font ...)

I*y2008-04-23 07:04

10 楼

你的adsense广告占了大半页，看着烦，我也不会帮你点。呵呵

【在 b******y 的大作中提到】

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

11 楼

hehe, 我准备把adsense都去掉...先做人品吧，呵呵

g*g2008-04-23 07:04

12 楼

You really should make a 2-5 Kb logo. It won't cause bandwidth problem for
you as long as you do not used image in large scale. At your current traffic
, you won't use up the bandwidth assigned to you anyway, right? Then, why
not use it. If a small logo image will cause bandwidth problem for you, you
are successed already.

【在 b******y 的大作中提到】

: hehe, 我准备把adsense都去掉...先做人品吧，呵呵

g*g2008-04-23 07:04

13 楼

URL play a very important role in Google if not the most important. People
copy and paste url anyway, long url won't be a problem for you. With java,
you can easily implement the url rules by editing the web.xml. Unlike other
technologies, which may need extra plugin or module.

the

【在 b******y 的大作中提到】

: genpichong, for SEO, I think I can make it like /question/160.html, for
: example, instead of question.html?qid=160.
: Since some title/question is too long, the url will be very long if all the
: keywords are in the title. Also, I don't think it will be good for user to
: email the question around as the url is too long.

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

14 楼

other
Thanks for the suggestion. I will see what I can do.

【在 g********g 的大作中提到】

: URL play a very important role in Google if not the most important. People
: copy and paste url anyway, long url won't be a problem for you. With java,
: you can easily implement the url rules by editing the web.xml. Unlike other
: technologies, which may need extra plugin or module.
:
: the

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

15 楼

You are right. I initially wanted to get some quick bucks ;-)
Okey, I have removed most of the ads. But, thanks a LOT for the suggestion.

【在 I*****y 的大作中提到】

: 你的adsense广告占了大半页，看着烦，我也不会帮你点。呵呵

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

16 楼

traffic
you
I don't have photoshop experience (totally a backend programmer ;-)) But I
will get a decent logo added with external help...

【在 g********g 的大作中提到】

: You really should make a 2-5 Kb logo. It won't cause bandwidth problem for
: you as long as you do not used image in large scale. At your current traffic
: , you won't use up the bandwidth assigned to you anyway, right? Then, why
: not use it. If a small logo image will cause bandwidth problem for you, you
: are successed already.

g*g2008-04-23 07:04

17 楼

I think this is not the key. A site like this should not target to attract a
large percentage of returning users. You should target to attract users
from search engine. So what you should do is to grab a large amount of
questions and answers from the internet using your vertical search engine
skill. Then do a really nice SEO to have google bring you a large amount of
users. If doing well, you may get thousands of free visitors from google per
day. As your questions and answers database grows to

【在 b******y 的大作中提到】

: hehe, 我准备把adsense都去掉...先做人品吧，呵呵

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

18 楼

Very thoughtful comment. Thanks!
The reason why I did the jiansnet domain, is because I couldn't find one
which is both short and meaningful. It is like the parking lot, all the good
ones are taken ;-)
But, anyhow, I like your idea of SEO friendly and making the site ranked as
high as possible on search engines.

【在 g********g 的大作中提到】

: I think this is not the key. A site like this should not target to attract a
: large percentage of returning users. You should target to attract users
: from search engine. So what you should do is to grab a large amount of
: questions and answers from the internet using your vertical search engine
: skill. Then do a really nice SEO to have google bring you a large amount of
: users. If doing well, you may get thousands of free visitors from google per
: day. As your questions and answers database grows to

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

19 楼

genpichong, I have sent you a private message. Much appreciated.

【在 g********g 的大作中提到】

y*u2008-04-23 07:04

20 楼

分类在哪里？如果问答站没有分类，一个一个看问答要累死。

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

21 楼

You are right. I am thinking to do labels. So, each question will be
associated with one or more labels.

【在 y*****u 的大作中提到】

: 分类在哪里？如果问答站没有分类，一个一个看问答要累死。

p*p2008-04-23 07:04

22 楼

地域攻击，校际攻击的话题，是不灭的人气来源。
呵呵//

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

23 楼

Heyhey, that's true!
But, I would rather put some useful information rather than getting some
show going. Because I know when the show ends, nobody will remember it ;-)

【在 p**p 的大作中提到】

: 地域攻击，校际攻击的话题，是不灭的人气来源。
: 呵呵//

s*n2008-04-23 07:04

24 楼

你对这个网站现在有什么样的规划？多长时间到什么样的规模，
如何跟其他类似网站进行区别？没想清楚这些问题，时间一长，
你的热情就很可能会转移到其他地方去了。

【在 b******y 的大作中提到】

:
: Heyhey, that's true!
: But, I would rather put some useful information rather than getting some
: show going. Because I know when the show ends, nobody will remember it ;-)

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

25 楼

Thanks for your question. I do have a problem from time to time, for whether
to keep the site going or not. To be frank, it is hard without profits.
But, I think one thing that keeps me from abandoning it, is I want to do
search. This site could be good for search experiments. Meanwhile, helping
people to find useful info.
To answer your question, here you go.
I plan to do bilingual useful info on the site. Whatever useful for people.
Especially useful info for buddy Chinese. As I am a Chinese,

【在 s******n 的大作中提到】

: 你对这个网站现在有什么样的规划？多长时间到什么样的规模，
: 如何跟其他类似网站进行区别？没想清楚这些问题，时间一长，
: 你的热情就很可能会转移到其他地方去了。

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

26 楼

Also, I don't have a good answer to your question above. I think I will just
keep it going and adjust the direction based on how people would like to
use the site.
So, maybe it will become a Chinese only site. Or, maybe it will be both
English and Chinese. Or, could be a site for all overseas Chinese to look up
some useful info. Bottom line is, I don't really know for sure myself. If
ever I can make the search feature to be as useful as possible, then, I am
satisfied ;-)

【在 s******n 的大作中提到】

s*n2008-04-23 07:04

27 楼

我觉得你应该问自己一个问题：当用户在google或者baidu上输入问题的时候，
什么情况下得到的答案是不好的。你要做的就是把这些别人做的不好的方面
有针对性地解决。否则，你就是只能凭兴趣搞个网站作为练手而已。
你现在维护一个不知名的小网站，真的很难去吸引很多用户来此提问和回答。
即使有好的答案，如果其他大网站也有类似答案，SEO还是很难把你这个网站
放到最前。
举个例子。如果手动搜集一些容易消失的其他网站的资料，汇编在你这里。
比如说论坛上，每天很多人问各种各样的问题，有了回答之后，可能很快
整理版面就被删帖了。问题和答案都消失了，所以google之类的搜索引擎
对于曾经出现过的好答案就会miss。
只有让你的服务有独特的价值，才能生存下去。

just
up

【在 b******y 的大作中提到】

:
: Also, I don't have a good answer to your question above. I think I will just
: keep it going and adjust the direction based on how people would like to
: use the site.
: So, maybe it will become a Chinese only site. Or, maybe it will be both
: English and Chinese. Or, could be a site for all overseas Chinese to look up
: some useful info. Bottom line is, I don't really know for sure myself. If
: ever I can make the search feature to be as useful as possible, then, I am
: satisfied ;-)

I*y2008-04-23 07:04

28 楼

how are you going to compete with the big guys like Baidu 知道 and Yahoo ans
wers?

just
up

【在 b******y 的大作中提到】

b*y2008-04-23 07:04

29 楼

This is one of the best suggestions I have heard!

【在 s******n 的大作中提到】

: 我觉得你应该问自己一个问题：当用户在google或者baidu上输入问题的时候，
: 什么情况下得到的答案是不好的。你要做的就是把这些别人做的不好的方面
: 有针对性地解决。否则，你就是只能凭兴趣搞个网站作为练手而已。
: 你现在维护一个不知名的小网站，真的很难去吸引很多用户来此提问和回答。
: 即使有好的答案，如果其他大网站也有类似答案，SEO还是很难把你这个网站
: 放到最前。
: 举个例子。如果手动搜集一些容易消失的其他网站的资料，汇编在你这里。
: 比如说论坛上，每天很多人问各种各样的问题，有了回答之后，可能很快
: 整理版面就被删帖了。问题和答案都消失了，所以google之类的搜索引擎
: 对于曾经出现过的好答案就会miss。