I usually judge someone's investment talent by looking at his/her 3-year compound return rate minimum. I would prefer to look at a 5-year period, because that time frame will probably show some staying power of that person . If he/she is a phony, that person will either have given up or wiped out by then. If that person is good, he/she will most likely be well off already.
So ask yourself, do you have 5 years of investment experience? Are you a millionnaire already? If your answer to either of the question is no, then whatever money you made from the stock market is just pure luck. If your first answer is yes and your second is no, then I'd suggest you give up stock and do sth else.
【在 w****a 的大作中提到】 : 什么时候才不算随机波动呢?
E*w
25 楼
I don't think this is true for day trader. If a day trader makes steady small profits in one year, that should be a solid evidence for his/her performance. Anyway, trading frequency matters, and whether your profit is due to a small number of big gains also matters. But I do agree that the number of years of experience matters in its absolute value as well since one needs to experience a full set of market conditions.
person by . then
【在 s********y 的大作中提到】 : I usually judge someone's investment talent by looking at his/her 3-year : compound return rate minimum. I would prefer to look at a 5-year period, : because that time frame will probably show some staying power of that person : . : If he/she is a phony, that person will either have given up or wiped out by : then. If that person is good, he/she will most likely be well off already. : : So ask yourself, do you have 5 years of investment experience? Are you a : millionnaire already? If your answer to either of the question is no, then : whatever money you made from the stock market is just pure luck. If your
Obviously you don't know anyone who is a trader, and your answers to my questions are most likely 2 nos. hehe Typical newbie mentality. Hehe
【在 E******w 的大作中提到】 : I don't think this is true for day trader. If a day trader makes steady : small profits in one year, that should be a solid evidence for his/her : performance. Anyway, trading frequency matters, and whether your profit is : due to a small number of big gains also matters. But I do agree that the : number of years of experience matters in its absolute value as well since : one needs to experience a full set of market conditions. : : person : by : .
1 million????omg how much money should you use to start the trading to achieve 1 million in 5 years?
person by . then
【在 s********y 的大作中提到】 : I usually judge someone's investment talent by looking at his/her 3-year : compound return rate minimum. I would prefer to look at a 5-year period, : because that time frame will probably show some staying power of that person : . : If he/she is a phony, that person will either have given up or wiped out by : then. If that person is good, he/she will most likely be well off already. : : So ask yourself, do you have 5 years of investment experience? Are you a : millionnaire already? If your answer to either of the question is no, then : whatever money you made from the stock market is just pure luck. If your
E*w
31 楼
I do know a day trader who earned 4 million from scratch. He has been trading for 15 years. Had consistant 45% gain per year for 6 years. The comment I made was given by him. Now what do you think.
【在 s********y 的大作中提到】 : Obviously you don't know anyone who is a trader, and your answers to my : questions are most likely 2 nos. hehe : Typical newbie mentality. Hehe
s*y
32 楼
You don't need a lot of money to start. Because investment is compound return, unlike your salary. Your second half million will be a lot faster than your first half.
【在 w****a 的大作中提到】 : 1 million????omg how much money should you use to start the trading to : achieve 1 million in 5 years? : : person : by : . : then
s*n
33 楼
Gary smith. broken even trader for 19 years. Then, he had only 2 losing months in next 19 years. No record after 2000 but looks like he is still a junk bond guru in 2010 online, so he must still trade well after the big bull bubble burst. (on the contrariety, Tony Oz, a stock trading book writer , became a real estate agent and dare not come back to this bloody market after 2000 bubble) I can say that this guy definitely did not trading for live based on his luck.
person by . then
【在 s********y 的大作中提到】 : I usually judge someone's investment talent by looking at his/her 3-year : compound return rate minimum. I would prefer to look at a 5-year period, : because that time frame will probably show some staying power of that person : . : If he/she is a phony, that person will either have given up or wiped out by : then. If that person is good, he/she will most likely be well off already. : : So ask yourself, do you have 5 years of investment experience? Are you a : millionnaire already? If your answer to either of the question is no, then : whatever money you made from the stock market is just pure luck. If your
s*y
34 楼
1. Try to repeat that yourself and then talk to me. 2. I still think your answers to my questions are 2 nos. hehe
【在 E******w 的大作中提到】 : I do know a day trader who earned 4 million from scratch. He has been : trading for 15 years. Had consistant 45% gain per year for 6 years. The : comment I made was given by him. Now what do you think.
E*w
35 楼
I am new, as I have said in other articles here. I only started half a year ago, and I do not have a big account. But that does not mean I cannot comment on your remark. I just do not give trading advice since I do not have any. But anyway, a trader fights battle on his own. These comments do not mean anything at the end of the day. Fortunately, I can seek advice from that trader I mentioned on MSN since he is a close friend of mine. I myself still lose frequently. I am not going to hide that fact here.
【在 s********y 的大作中提到】 : 1. Try to repeat that yourself and then talk to me. : 2. I still think your answers to my questions are 2 nos. hehe
s*y
36 楼
See my comments to EmMeadow, hehe
writer
【在 s*****n 的大作中提到】 : Gary smith. broken even trader for 19 years. Then, he had only 2 losing : months in next 19 years. No record after 2000 but looks like he is still a : junk bond guru in 2010 online, so he must still trade well after the big : bull bubble burst. (on the contrariety, Tony Oz, a stock trading book writer : , became a real estate agent and dare not come back to this bloody market : after 2000 bubble) : I can say that this guy definitely did not trading for live based on his : luck. : : person
w*a
37 楼
最重要的是什么呢?有没有什么诀窍啊,还有哪些indicator 最重要啊?谢谢指导哈。
【在 s********y 的大作中提到】 : You don't need a lot of money to start. Because investment is compound : return, unlike your salary. Your second half million will be a lot faster : than your first half.
f*d
38 楼
"on the contrariety, Tony Oz, a stock trading book writer , became a real estate agent and dare not come back to this bloody market after 2000 bubble)" can you show me the link?
writer
【在 s*****n 的大作中提到】 : Gary smith. broken even trader for 19 years. Then, he had only 2 losing : months in next 19 years. No record after 2000 but looks like he is still a : junk bond guru in 2010 online, so he must still trade well after the big : bull bubble burst. (on the contrariety, Tony Oz, a stock trading book writer : , became a real estate agent and dare not come back to this bloody market : after 2000 bubble) : I can say that this guy definitely did not trading for live based on his : luck. : : person
t*9
39 楼
我觉得应该用百分比来代替1 million比较靠谱,5年平均年收益少于50%的话真的不适 应炒股
【在 s********y 的大作中提到】 : You don't need a lot of money to start. Because investment is compound : return, unlike your salary. Your second half million will be a lot faster : than your first half.
s*y
40 楼
I think the most important thing to remember is probably patience. Even if you have a great strategy, you won't get rich in the next week or next month . Even if your stock does not move for a year, you need to have the stomach to stay put. Most people here think if they were able to make a 20% return in a few days, they can repeat that again by studying charts and patterns. They won't. But that's the way most people here think how the stock market is played, and that's just stupid.
【在 s********y 的大作中提到】 : I think the most important thing to remember is probably patience. Even if : you have a great strategy, you won't get rich in the next week or next month : . Even if your stock does not move for a year, you need to have the : stomach to stay put. : Most people here think if they were able to make a 20% return in a few days, : they can repeat that again by studying charts and patterns. They won't. : But that's the way most people here think how the stock market is played, : and that's just stupid.
w*n
42 楼
if month 那为啥大牛评价人的时候只看5年能否赚到百万呢?要是第二年开窍,第三年股票不动 弹,5年下来看了你的帖子也只好放弃了。 何况5年赚不到百万有什么关系,哪怕20年从5万赚到百万,赚第二个百万可能只要再多 花4年,第三个百万只要再多花2年多。。。
【在 s********y 的大作中提到】 : I think the most important thing to remember is probably patience. Even if : you have a great strategy, you won't get rich in the next week or next month : . Even if your stock does not move for a year, you need to have the : stomach to stay put. : Most people here think if they were able to make a 20% return in a few days, : they can repeat that again by studying charts and patterns. They won't. : But that's the way most people here think how the stock market is played, : and that's just stupid.
【在 s********y 的大作中提到】 : I think the most important thing to remember is probably patience. Even if : you have a great strategy, you won't get rich in the next week or next month : . Even if your stock does not move for a year, you need to have the : stomach to stay put. : Most people here think if they were able to make a 20% return in a few days, : they can repeat that again by studying charts and patterns. They won't. : But that's the way most people here think how the stock market is played, : and that's just stupid.