Opinions on top mgt consulting firms?# Business - 商学院
d*i
1 楼
想问问版上比较熟悉的，对前几的公司各自的优劣的看法。尤其是mck和bcg这两个，对
于背景是fresh ee phd的来说。各种方面的印象都想知道下，能有比较personalized的
书上看不到的感受更好了。Thanks :)
于背景是fresh ee phd的来说。各种方面的印象都想知道下，能有比较personalized的
书上看不到的感受更好了。Thanks :)
j*t
2 楼
BCG claims to have better lifestyle though I highly doubt it
【在 d**i 的大作中提到】
: 想问问版上比较熟悉的，对前几的公司各自的优劣的看法。尤其是mck和bcg这两个，对
: 于背景是fresh ee phd的来说。各种方面的印象都想知道下，能有比较personalized的
: 书上看不到的感受更好了。Thanks :)
【在 d**i 的大作中提到】
: 想问问版上比较熟悉的，对前几的公司各自的优劣的看法。尤其是mck和bcg这两个，对
: 于背景是fresh ee phd的来说。各种方面的印象都想知道下，能有比较personalized的
: 书上看不到的感受更好了。Thanks :)
d*i
3 楼
yah, somehow i get the feeling that bcg people are a bit more low profile
and casual. any other comment on career path, average tenure, exit options,
etc? one thing that's different for sure is the high percentage of apds at
mck, but is it necessarily a good thing to have many people with similar
background around? any thought on that... ?
【在 j*****t 的大作中提到】
: BCG claims to have better lifestyle though I highly doubt it
and casual. any other comment on career path, average tenure, exit options,
etc? one thing that's different for sure is the high percentage of apds at
mck, but is it necessarily a good thing to have many people with similar
background around? any thought on that... ?
【在 j*****t 的大作中提到】
: BCG claims to have better lifestyle though I highly doubt it
m*x
4 楼
1st of all, CRACK THE CASE!
Either one would be fantastic, if you already got the interview invitation,
practice the case as much as you can.
【在 d**i 的大作中提到】
: 想问问版上比较熟悉的，对前几的公司各自的优劣的看法。尤其是mck和bcg这两个，对
: 于背景是fresh ee phd的来说。各种方面的印象都想知道下，能有比较personalized的
: 书上看不到的感受更好了。Thanks :)
Either one would be fantastic, if you already got the interview invitation,
practice the case as much as you can.
【在 d**i 的大作中提到】
: 想问问版上比较熟悉的，对前几的公司各自的优劣的看法。尤其是mck和bcg这两个，对
: 于背景是fresh ee phd的来说。各种方面的印象都想知道下，能有比较personalized的
: 书上看不到的感受更好了。Thanks :)
j*t
5 楼
从career角度来讲，两个差不多吧，都能给你很好的exit option
听说BCG做到partner的时间更长些，也没有McK那么rigorous的up or out policy
这两年的业绩，好像BCG差点，很多时候比不过Bain
APD多有什么不好的？做项目的时候不会所有人都是APD的。而且经过培训的APD用起来
和MBA没什么不同
options,
at
【在 d**i 的大作中提到】
: yah, somehow i get the feeling that bcg people are a bit more low profile
: and casual. any other comment on career path, average tenure, exit options,
: etc? one thing that's different for sure is the high percentage of apds at
: mck, but is it necessarily a good thing to have many people with similar
: background around? any thought on that... ?
听说BCG做到partner的时间更长些，也没有McK那么rigorous的up or out policy
这两年的业绩，好像BCG差点，很多时候比不过Bain
APD多有什么不好的？做项目的时候不会所有人都是APD的。而且经过培训的APD用起来
和MBA没什么不同
options,
at
【在 d**i 的大作中提到】
: yah, somehow i get the feeling that bcg people are a bit more low profile
: and casual. any other comment on career path, average tenure, exit options,
: etc? one thing that's different for sure is the high percentage of apds at
: mck, but is it necessarily a good thing to have many people with similar
: background around? any thought on that... ?
d*i
6 楼
makes sense... 感觉mck的竞争和up or out是比较严一点。所谓apd的多少，我就是想
到底是value variety呢还是background类似的氛围好。不过可能最终也就是value
performance了。
【在 j*****t 的大作中提到】
: 从career角度来讲，两个差不多吧，都能给你很好的exit option
: 听说BCG做到partner的时间更长些，也没有McK那么rigorous的up or out policy
: 这两年的业绩，好像BCG差点，很多时候比不过Bain
: APD多有什么不好的？做项目的时候不会所有人都是APD的。而且经过培训的APD用起来
: 和MBA没什么不同
:
: options,
: at
到底是value variety呢还是background类似的氛围好。不过可能最终也就是value
performance了。
【在 j*****t 的大作中提到】
: 从career角度来讲，两个差不多吧，都能给你很好的exit option
: 听说BCG做到partner的时间更长些，也没有McK那么rigorous的up or out policy
: 这两年的业绩，好像BCG差点，很多时候比不过Bain
: APD多有什么不好的？做项目的时候不会所有人都是APD的。而且经过培训的APD用起来
: 和MBA没什么不同
:
: options,
: at
j*t
7 楼
Let me clarify on the competitiveness part. You don't compete against
people in the same class. It's not like if you become an Engagement Manager
, I cannot. So there is little competition among the Associates on the team
. It's actually a very collaborative environment. You do get a little bit
of peer pressure around the time you are supposed to advance to the next
level. For example, if everyone in your class is EMing and you are not, you
will feel uncomfortable.
As for APDs, like I said
【在 d**i 的大作中提到】
: makes sense... 感觉mck的竞争和up or out是比较严一点。所谓apd的多少，我就是想
: 到底是value variety呢还是background类似的氛围好。不过可能最终也就是value
: performance了。
people in the same class. It's not like if you become an Engagement Manager
, I cannot. So there is little competition among the Associates on the team
. It's actually a very collaborative environment. You do get a little bit
of peer pressure around the time you are supposed to advance to the next
level. For example, if everyone in your class is EMing and you are not, you
will feel uncomfortable.
As for APDs, like I said
【在 d**i 的大作中提到】
: makes sense... 感觉mck的竞争和up or out是比较严一点。所谓apd的多少，我就是想
: 到底是value variety呢还是background类似的氛围好。不过可能最终也就是value
: performance了。
相关阅读
Re: 我想做IT consultant,该读什么学位?Re: what is "pro forma net income"? Also please explain the difference2003 usnews MBA new rank!Re: Leoq请进: UIUC Master of Science in AccountancyRe: 有学MANAGEMENT的PH。D吗？Re: My reason to get CFA.Re: Choosing schoolRe: question about "deferred revenue", thanks.Re: any good pdf book about SAS?CFA requirementsRe: 请问关于CPARe: GMAT (Is 720 high or moderate?)微软的中国盲点(z)Re: what is Guaranteed Investment Contract (GIC) and some more questiRe: 几个商学院面试的问题请教大家感情沟通式现代管理[转载] Re: snowthunder, give me some clueRe: 有关ACCARe: 请有经验的DX帮助：U of IOWA MBA电话interviewRe: 二流商学院的MBA(Chinese)能找到工作吗？