都是别人的事情, 我也是其中一个reivewer,觉得人家文章工作不错,就minor了。 但是其中一个reviewer,要求major,提了很多问题,属于常识问题。 然后,作者就做了反击。这是我审稿以来,看到最harsh的反击。 当然,回复还是很有理,有力的。 大家以后可以借鉴一下。 1. This reviewer has provided a rather unfocused paragraph containing only broadly stated criticisms which have little or no constructive value 2. it appears the reviewer did not read our manuscript carefully, and those parts which he/she did read it were well understood. 3. Here is an example of where the reviewer evidently has not read our paper ca
It is doable. We made the travel arrangement this way. My husband took my daughter back and then I go to pick her up. The agent just need to note in the ticket to show the kid has adult accompany.
【在 b******r 的大作中提到】 : It is doable. We made the travel arrangement this way. My husband took my : daughter back and then I go to pick her up. The agent just need to note in : the ticket to show the kid has adult accompany.
m*n
20 楼
大概他们要求editor不要把文章送回到这个reviewer了吧? 反正其他的不说, 最后一点response, 是不通的. English skill与 writing skill是完全两回事.
those
【在 h********r 的大作中提到】 : 都是别人的事情, : 我也是其中一个reivewer,觉得人家文章工作不错,就minor了。 : 但是其中一个reviewer,要求major,提了很多问题,属于常识问题。 : 然后,作者就做了反击。这是我审稿以来,看到最harsh的反击。 : 当然,回复还是很有理,有力的。 : 大家以后可以借鉴一下。 : 1. This reviewer has provided a rather unfocused paragraph containing : only broadly stated criticisms which have little or no constructive value : 2. it appears the reviewer did not read our manuscript carefully, and those : parts which he/she did read it were well understood.
D*a
21 楼
USO
【在 d*******2 的大作中提到】 : 哪只股票是油的?
c*s
22 楼
Book of Eli will make more than double of The spy next door
【在 h********r 的大作中提到】 : 都是别人的事情, : 我也是其中一个reivewer,觉得人家文章工作不错,就minor了。 : 但是其中一个reviewer,要求major,提了很多问题,属于常识问题。 : 然后,作者就做了反击。这是我审稿以来,看到最harsh的反击。 : 当然,回复还是很有理,有力的。 : 大家以后可以借鉴一下。 : 1. This reviewer has provided a rather unfocused paragraph containing : only broadly stated criticisms which have little or no constructive value : 2. it appears the reviewer did not read our manuscript carefully, and those : parts which he/she did read it were well understood.
【在 h********r 的大作中提到】 : 都是别人的事情, : 我也是其中一个reivewer,觉得人家文章工作不错,就minor了。 : 但是其中一个reviewer,要求major,提了很多问题,属于常识问题。 : 然后,作者就做了反击。这是我审稿以来,看到最harsh的反击。 : 当然,回复还是很有理,有力的。 : 大家以后可以借鉴一下。 : 1. This reviewer has provided a rather unfocused paragraph containing : only broadly stated criticisms which have little or no constructive value : 2. it appears the reviewer did not read our manuscript carefully, and those : parts which he/she did read it were well understood.
【在 h********r 的大作中提到】 : 都是别人的事情, : 我也是其中一个reivewer,觉得人家文章工作不错,就minor了。 : 但是其中一个reviewer,要求major,提了很多问题,属于常识问题。 : 然后,作者就做了反击。这是我审稿以来,看到最harsh的反击。 : 当然,回复还是很有理,有力的。 : 大家以后可以借鉴一下。 : 1. This reviewer has provided a rather unfocused paragraph containing : only broadly stated criticisms which have little or no constructive value : 2. it appears the reviewer did not read our manuscript carefully, and those : parts which he/she did read it were well understood.
【在 h********r 的大作中提到】 : 都是别人的事情, : 我也是其中一个reivewer,觉得人家文章工作不错,就minor了。 : 但是其中一个reviewer,要求major,提了很多问题,属于常识问题。 : 然后,作者就做了反击。这是我审稿以来,看到最harsh的反击。 : 当然,回复还是很有理,有力的。 : 大家以后可以借鉴一下。 : 1. This reviewer has provided a rather unfocused paragraph containing : only broadly stated criticisms which have little or no constructive value : 2. it appears the reviewer did not read our manuscript carefully, and those : parts which he/she did read it were well understood.
【在 h********r 的大作中提到】 : 都是别人的事情, : 我也是其中一个reivewer,觉得人家文章工作不错,就minor了。 : 但是其中一个reviewer,要求major,提了很多问题,属于常识问题。 : 然后,作者就做了反击。这是我审稿以来,看到最harsh的反击。 : 当然,回复还是很有理,有力的。 : 大家以后可以借鉴一下。 : 1. This reviewer has provided a rather unfocused paragraph containing : only broadly stated criticisms which have little or no constructive value : 2. it appears the reviewer did not read our manuscript carefully, and those : parts which he/she did read it were well understood.
我前些日子review一个paper,paper写的乱七八糟,abstract第一句就有语法错误。 我写了2页半referee report,然后给据了 然后发现另外一个reviewer,写的是accept with minor revisions 然后写了3句话的comments 于是,我觉得我太mean了。。。
an unqualified person should decline the review invitation professionally. it is like a doctor better kick out a patient rather than start a surgery he has little idea about...