Re: 麻黄 (转载) - 未名空间MITBBS历史存档

国际科技财经博客移民网络热点娱乐民生时事公众号

Redian新闻

>未名空间

>ChineseMed - 中医

Re: 麻黄 (转载)

Re: 麻黄 (转载)# ChineseMed - 中医

b*h2009-03-19 07:03

1 楼

【以下文字转载自 Belief 讨论区】
发信人: Ragnorod (Ragnorod), 信区: Belief
标题: Re: 麻黄 (转载)
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Thu Mar 19 20:11:19 2009)
the term is usually active ingredient, or API(active pharmaceutical
ingredient). That is why I am saying if one is not educated in the subject,
it is a waste of time to debate. in traditional chinese medicine,
different herbs are used in combination as supportive to each other to
balance the body, therefore curing diseases. that is probably why they say
there are no active i

c*n2009-03-19 07:03

2 楼

logic is essential to a debate
there is one example of artemisia, can one conclude on all TCM herb
treatments? this method had been proved wrong on 黄连. when there
is no single "dominant factor" (could be the product of multiple
chemical compounds in the herbs), this concept fails.
in TCM, the different herbs are not mixed to suppress / support
each other then make a total effect to the body, but their
effects to the body balance each other. the body status (system state)
matters. this is the sys

【在 b*****h 的大作中提到】

: 【以下文字转载自 Belief 讨论区】
: 发信人: Ragnorod (Ragnorod), 信区: Belief
: 标题: Re: 麻黄 (转载)
: 发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Thu Mar 19 20:11:19 2009)
: the term is usually active ingredient, or API(active pharmaceutical
: ingredient). That is why I am saying if one is not educated in the subject,
: it is a waste of time to debate. in traditional chinese medicine,
: different herbs are used in combination as supportive to each other to
: balance the body, therefore curing diseases. that is probably why they say
: there are no active i

b*h2009-03-19 07:03

3 楼

我不知道你为什么一直拿个稻草人打。没有人说一定是"single" 决定因素。
但很可能是small subset. 至于你说的一万种因素，都有用，非要靠全集，
我当然不同意。事实证明了，很多植株药物有效成分是少数几种。

【在 c****n 的大作中提到】

: logic is essential to a debate
: there is one example of artemisia, can one conclude on all TCM herb
: treatments? this method had been proved wrong on 黄连. when there
: is no single "dominant factor" (could be the product of multiple
: chemical compounds in the herbs), this concept fails.
: in TCM, the different herbs are not mixed to suppress / support
: each other then make a total effect to the body, but their
: effects to the body balance each other. the body status (system state)
: matters. this is the sys