Journal paper VS. conference paper？？？# CS - 计算机科学
y*e
1 楼
我的老板没钱，所以写的文章只能往JOURNAL上投。请问一下
IEEE TRANSACTION 这样的 JOURNAL PAPER 是否能与好的
CONFERENCE录取的PAPER有一拼？ 我是说对找工作而言。
IEEE TRANSACTION 这样的 JOURNAL PAPER 是否能与好的
CONFERENCE录取的PAPER有一拼？ 我是说对找工作而言。
a*a
2 楼
As long as your paper has good quality and innovations,
it doesn't matter. You can see bad papers which shouldn't
be admitted in both conferences and journals. In the end,
it's the authors who are ultimately responsible for
what they are doing, and the kind of good/bad payoff
they gain from the work.
If your work can be related to the kind of thing
a company is researching, sure it's useful.
【在 y*******e 的大作中提到】
: 我的老板没钱，所以写的文章只能往JOURNAL上投。请问一下
: IEEE TRANSACTION 这样的 JOURNAL PAPER 是否能与好的
: CONFERENCE录取的PAPER有一拼？ 我是说对找工作而言。
it doesn't matter. You can see bad papers which shouldn't
be admitted in both conferences and journals. In the end,
it's the authors who are ultimately responsible for
what they are doing, and the kind of good/bad payoff
they gain from the work.
If your work can be related to the kind of thing
a company is researching, sure it's useful.
【在 y*******e 的大作中提到】
: 我的老板没钱，所以写的文章只能往JOURNAL上投。请问一下
: IEEE TRANSACTION 这样的 JOURNAL PAPER 是否能与好的
: CONFERENCE录取的PAPER有一拼？ 我是说对找工作而言。
w*g
3 楼
for faculty search, of course journal papers are more attractive
for industry, it really doesn't matter, what matters is your topic
【在 y*******e 的大作中提到】
: 我的老板没钱，所以写的文章只能往JOURNAL上投。请问一下
: IEEE TRANSACTION 这样的 JOURNAL PAPER 是否能与好的
: CONFERENCE录取的PAPER有一拼？ 我是说对找工作而言。
for industry, it really doesn't matter, what matters is your topic
【在 y*******e 的大作中提到】
: 我的老板没钱，所以写的文章只能往JOURNAL上投。请问一下
: IEEE TRANSACTION 这样的 JOURNAL PAPER 是否能与好的
: CONFERENCE录取的PAPER有一拼？ 我是说对找工作而言。
a*x
4 楼
wrong. top conference papers rules.
【在 w********g 的大作中提到】
: for faculty search, of course journal papers are more attractive
: for industry, it really doesn't matter, what matters is your topic
s*o
5 楼
wrong. top conf and top journal rule, together.
ACM/IEEE Trans on Networking == ACM SIGCOM > IEEE INFOCOM
【在 a**x 的大作中提到】
:
: wrong. top conference papers rules.
z*5
6 楼
How many CS people read Transactions?
You are right in that ToN is more respected than INFOCOM.
However, a paper published in ToN only (not with a conference version)
is easier to be forgotten than an INFOCOM paper.
【在 s*****o 的大作中提到】
:
: wrong. top conf and top journal rule, together.
: ACM/IEEE Trans on Networking == ACM SIGCOM > IEEE INFOCOM
m*t
7 楼
That is because the ideas in journal papers are often too,too, out of date.
【在 z**5 的大作中提到】
:
: How many CS people read Transactions?
: You are right in that ToN is more respected than INFOCOM.
: However, a paper published in ToN only (not with a conference version)
: is easier to be forgotten than an INFOCOM paper.
【在 z**5 的大作中提到】
:
: How many CS people read Transactions?
: You are right in that ToN is more respected than INFOCOM.
: However, a paper published in ToN only (not with a conference version)
: is easier to be forgotten than an INFOCOM paper.
w*g
8 楼
right, Nobel laureate Herbert Simon said similar words, he said he
never read journals for ideas
【在 m***t 的大作中提到】
: That is because the ideas in journal papers are often too,too, out of date.
never read journals for ideas
【在 m***t 的大作中提到】
: That is because the ideas in journal papers are often too,too, out of date.
s*o
9 楼
if you are in the field of Human computer interaction,
do you read ACM Trans of HCI (TOCHI) besides
UIST, SIGCHI?
I read all of them, to be honest. every article from TOCHI
If you are in the field of Virtual Environment,
do you read Presence (a famous journal) besides
VIST, ACM CVE etc?
I read all of them, every article from Presence.
If you are in the field of Networking,
do you read ToN, selected area in networking journals, besides
SIGCOMM, infocom?
I read all of them, to be honest.
【在 z**5 的大作中提到】
:
: How many CS people read Transactions?
: You are right in that ToN is more respected than INFOCOM.
: However, a paper published in ToN only (not with a conference version)
: is easier to be forgotten than an INFOCOM paper.
s*o
10 楼
read a bounch of high reputation journals won't hurt you,
guys !
【在 s*****o 的大作中提到】
:
: if you are in the field of Human computer interaction,
: do you read ACM Trans of HCI (TOCHI) besides
: UIST, SIGCHI?
: I read all of them, to be honest. every article from TOCHI
: If you are in the field of Virtual Environment,
: do you read Presence (a famous journal) besides
: VIST, ACM CVE etc?
: I read all of them, every article from Presence.
: If you are in the field of Networking,
guys !
【在 s*****o 的大作中提到】
:
: if you are in the field of Human computer interaction,
: do you read ACM Trans of HCI (TOCHI) besides
: UIST, SIGCHI?
: I read all of them, to be honest. every article from TOCHI
: If you are in the field of Virtual Environment,
: do you read Presence (a famous journal) besides
: VIST, ACM CVE etc?
: I read all of them, every article from Presence.
: If you are in the field of Networking,
m*h
11 楼
Just curious, exactly what area are you in?
【在 s*****o 的大作中提到】
: read a bounch of high reputation journals won't hurt you,
: guys !
【在 s*****o 的大作中提到】
: read a bounch of high reputation journals won't hurt you,
: guys !
s*o
12 楼
I am in the networking area and CSCW
【在 m****h 的大作中提到】
: Just curious, exactly what area are you in?
相关阅读
现在这个领域的前沿技术都有哪些呢？java Class VectorACM Turing Lecture webcastA question when open a .chm filePostDoc Position in UCIrvineQuestion about java appletECCC and ArXivNP如何用MFC连接search engine？问两个低级mobile computing问题如何实现向另一个应用程序（不是自己编的，没有原码）添加功能[推荐]计算机入门好书推荐感觉system 很多paper 都在reinvent wheelHP notebook温度很高，正常吗？Xiaoyun Wang could not attend Crypto 05 due to visa delay自然语言理解前景怎么样？from power spectra to original signalUNIX下的图形界面编程网络论文六个作者是不是太多？求：电子书 (转载)