一定要教授级别的来问问题才能算到contribution里面么？ - 未名空间MITBBS历史存档

国际科技财经博客移民网络热点娱乐民生时事公众号

Redian新闻

>未名空间

>Immigration - 落地生根

一定要教授级别的来问问题才能算到contribution里面么？

一定要教授级别的来问问题才能算到contribution里面么？# Immigration - 落地生根

w*32011-11-06 07:11

1 楼

请教各位，我现在在怀孕中，9月份预产期，我现在用的医疗保险7月过期，想问问大家
生孩子买什么保险比较好？我现在这个保险只cover 70%费用，请大家推荐一下，另外
想问下小孩出生以后是直接加到我的保险中吗？
完全没有经验，请各位赐教了，谢谢！

p*n2011-11-06 07:11

2 楼

别的地方的学生来问就木有用了吗？

A*n2011-11-06 07:11

3 楼

大大的有用。

【在 p*********n 的大作中提到】

: 别的地方的学生来问就木有用了吗？

p*n2011-11-06 07:11

4 楼

是么？好激动的说！！

【在 A**********n 的大作中提到】

: 大大的有用。

T*y2011-11-06 07:11

5 楼

All the inquiries, from anyone, can be included in the "Other" section, but
not all of them should be mentioned in the PL. If there's anything
significant, you surely can mention; otherwise, just keep quiet. The
principle is to present everything that is significant and downplay (not to
mention, but not to change) the evidences that are not so helpful for your
case.
When every inquiry is included, that "Other" section can give the IO some
impression on how many people have asked for your help and suggestion to
strengthen your international reputation and contribution. Be aware that
this section alone does not replace the hard evidences of citations or
others' applications of your work.

【在 p*********n 的大作中提到】

: 别的地方的学生来问就木有用了吗？

A*n2011-11-06 07:11

6 楼

如果是诺贝尔奖得主：The Nobel winner communicated with me for my
publications......
如果是学生: Many researchers from all over the world communicated with me
for my publications......
区别好像不大。

【在 p*********n 的大作中提到】

: 别的地方的学生来问就木有用了吗？

p*n2011-11-06 07:11

7 楼

多谢提醒！但是怎么define significant呢？比方说有phd学生说，看到你的paper,觉
得很有意思，问几个跟paper有关的问题，这个算significant吗？

but
to

【在 T*******y 的大作中提到】

: All the inquiries, from anyone, can be included in the "Other" section, but
: not all of them should be mentioned in the PL. If there's anything
: significant, you surely can mention; otherwise, just keep quiet. The
: principle is to present everything that is significant and downplay (not to
: mention, but not to change) the evidences that are not so helpful for your
: case.
: When every inquiry is included, that "Other" section can give the IO some
: impression on how many people have asked for your help and suggestion to
: strengthen your international reputation and contribution. Be aware that
: this section alone does not replace the hard evidences of citations or

T*y2011-11-06 07:11

8 楼

Just from the surface, this doesn't seem to sound significant enough.
Did this student cite your paper later on? Could you find his advisor (who
should also be on the authors' list, right?) to write you a reference
letter mentioning that your work has impacted their work a lot? Then
that's your contribution, and this students' email serves as a supporting
evidence, which can be mentioned in the advisor's reference letter.

【在 p*********n 的大作中提到】

: 多谢提醒！但是怎么define significant呢？比方说有phd学生说，看到你的paper,觉
: 得很有意思，问几个跟paper有关的问题，这个算significant吗？
:
: but
: to

p*n2011-11-06 07:11

9 楼

That is very enlightening! Thanks a lot!

letter
your

【在 T*******y 的大作中提到】

: Just from the surface, this doesn't seem to sound significant enough.
: Did this student cite your paper later on? Could you find his advisor (who
: should also be on the authors' list, right?) to write you a reference
: letter mentioning that your work has impacted their work a lot? Then
: that's your contribution, and this students' email serves as a supporting
: evidence, which can be mentioned in the advisor's reference letter.