金三腰里别一个冲锋枪。# Joke - 肚皮舞运动
q*s
1 楼
CS PhD, 论文12篇,一作8篇,引用200,专利1,review 20。
RL 2封不独立(一个导师一个合作者),3封独立(一中国一美国一西班牙)。
准备的时候没怎么上心,都是套模板,有点太乐观了。pp,被0858 noid。
NOID 里被各种质疑,大概意思就是abcdef只满足了def:
- 首先说虽然review了,但是evidence does not establish that his
participation in the widespread peer review process exceeds that of other
researchers or reflects international recognition. 然后这种需要editorial
board或者general chair才行。我确实没做过。review都是找朋友东拼西凑凑够20就强
行上马了。
- 然后说letter of support, do not demonstrate 我"is recognized
internationally as outstanding in the academic field"
- 然后说引用虽然有216,而且最高的引用了105次,但是没有demonstrate how such
numbers of citations reflect that he "is recognized internationally as
outstanding in the academic field" 然后 最后一句 As such, submit Google
Scholar profiles of outstanding researchers in his specific field. 这句话什
么意思?。。
- 然后说虽然有一个专利,但是专利可不是success metric。需要证明这个发明被
widely utilized and shown to be significant to the field。 这个我承认确实
没有啊,不过这要求有点难吧。
- 然后说我虽然在conference present了,但是这也不能说明有贡献。然而highly
cited publications and widely utilized patents 是比较好的客观证据。。。
- 最后总结说虽然满足了3条,这里要注意他说是meets the *plain language* of 3
criteria,但是我在任何一条都不strong, so short of elevating him to the level
of one who is recognized internationally as outstanding in the academic
field.
除了总结,letter里两次提到(review 和 patent说光plain language 满足条件是不行
的。
最后还说alphabet不是google,是google file的,给的确实alphabet的文件,不行。
一个月时间回复。求教板上大神,怎么破啊……我的感觉是我自己准备的也不够仔细,
律师也是套模版。。。现在我怎么提交补充材料?跪谢。。。
RL 2封不独立(一个导师一个合作者),3封独立(一中国一美国一西班牙)。
准备的时候没怎么上心,都是套模板,有点太乐观了。pp,被0858 noid。
NOID 里被各种质疑,大概意思就是abcdef只满足了def:
- 首先说虽然review了,但是evidence does not establish that his
participation in the widespread peer review process exceeds that of other
researchers or reflects international recognition. 然后这种需要editorial
board或者general chair才行。我确实没做过。review都是找朋友东拼西凑凑够20就强
行上马了。
- 然后说letter of support, do not demonstrate 我"is recognized
internationally as outstanding in the academic field"
- 然后说引用虽然有216,而且最高的引用了105次,但是没有demonstrate how such
numbers of citations reflect that he "is recognized internationally as
outstanding in the academic field" 然后 最后一句 As such, submit Google
Scholar profiles of outstanding researchers in his specific field. 这句话什
么意思?。。
- 然后说虽然有一个专利,但是专利可不是success metric。需要证明这个发明被
widely utilized and shown to be significant to the field。 这个我承认确实
没有啊,不过这要求有点难吧。
- 然后说我虽然在conference present了,但是这也不能说明有贡献。然而highly
cited publications and widely utilized patents 是比较好的客观证据。。。
- 最后总结说虽然满足了3条,这里要注意他说是meets the *plain language* of 3
criteria,但是我在任何一条都不strong, so short of elevating him to the level
of one who is recognized internationally as outstanding in the academic
field.
除了总结,letter里两次提到(review 和 patent说光plain language 满足条件是不行
的。
最后还说alphabet不是google,是google file的,给的确实alphabet的文件,不行。
一个月时间回复。求教板上大神,怎么破啊……我的感觉是我自己准备的也不够仔细,
律师也是套模版。。。现在我怎么提交补充材料?跪谢。。。