跟律師討論了一下怎麼回復 rfe,雖然覺得他說得是有道理,但還是不太放心,主要是
好害怕被拒了。大家幫提點建議吧-----
1。review只是從近期開始(less than one year), “the record lacks evidence
that the beneficiary has, over a sustained period of time, actually judged
others in his field and performed editorial work"
律師的策略是,讓某位editor 寫信說明,其實他們幾年前就想請我審稿了,只是苦於
沒有合適的稿件。
2。2000-2005年paper的citation遠遠低於進年發的paper, "the beneficiary's
earlier scholarly work published in china between 2000 and 2005 did not
generate the same level of interest within the research community, the
totality of the record does not indicate that the beneficiary's research
contributions have garnered his sustained acclaim over a period of time"
我們打算 argue 2000-2005年是phd 期間,屬於training 階段, publication 當然
會weak 一點。當時得過兩個國內的獎,不知有沒有必要挖掘一下,claim 這兩個獎也
是水平挺高的。但又怕不能自圓其說,因為當時發的paper 確實濫,不能跟現在比,引
用很低