claim成了“Published Material in Professional Publications Written By Others About the Alien’s Work in the Academic Field” 这个是不是有问题啊?
【在 U******E 的大作中提到】 : 引用单独列出一条来claim了,claim成什么呀?
p*r
6 楼
谢谢。 有谁用过这些山寨机吗? 质量如何?
【在 z****8 的大作中提到】 : 前几天有人买的S3山寨
p*8
7 楼
lol
Others
【在 j****a 的大作中提到】 : claim成了“Published Material in Professional Publications Written By Others : About the Alien’s Work in the Academic Field” : 这个是不是有问题啊?
以下这些是我律师在petition letter里面列出来的六项. 这个应该算是claim六项了吧 ? 我打算叫他把#5和#6去掉,因为我的得奖还有membership都很弱。单独提出来估计 就是被RFE的结果。 之后把#1和#3合并作为contribution。 这样是不是正确的claim方 式呢? 8 CFR § 204.5(i)(3) provides that in order to demonstrate international recognition as an outstanding researcher in the academic field, an alien must show that he or she satisfies at least two of the criteria listed in that section. Set forth below, and in the exhibits to this letter, is evidence documenting Dr. G's satisfaction of all six of the criteria listed therein: 1. Evidence of Dr. G's Original Scientific or Scholarly Contributions of Major Significance in the Field of XXX 2. Evidence of Dr. G’s authorship of scholarly books or articles (in scholarly peer-reviewed journals with international circulation) in her field 3. Published Material in Professional Publications Written By Others About the Alien’s Work in the Academic Field 4. Evidence of an alien’s participation, on a panel or individually, as the judge of the work of others in the same or allied academic field 5. Documentation of Dr. G’s Membership in Associations in the Academic Field Which Require Outstanding Achievements of Their Members 6. Receipt of nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards for excellence in the field of endeavor
Agree. LZ's lawyer's statement is to treat this citation as a media report. It should not be about all the citations, but only on some citations with long paragraphs to describe LZ himself and/or his work. People have done this before, such as AprilSummer, and a few other IDs with her help. In LZ's case though, the lawyer claimed 6 items, which does not seem to be necessary, and it often calls RFE on the weaker claims.
【在 P*********y 的大作中提到】 : 看起来他好像要把这一条当成媒体报道来claim?
A*n
16 楼
对不起,你可能做的是EB1B,我误以为是EB1A。你的律师写得没有问题。作为EB1B, claim "Published Material in Professional Publications Written By Others About the Alien’s Work in the Academic Field" 是完全正确的。 我该挨板子,你也该打屁股,为什么不说清楚?
【在 A**********n 的大作中提到】 : 对不起,你可能做的是EB1B,我误以为是EB1A。你的律师写得没有问题。作为EB1B, : claim "Published Material in Professional Publications Written By Others : About the Alien’s Work in the Academic Field" 是完全正确的。 : 我该挨板子,你也该打屁股,为什么不说清楚?
A*n
18 楼
(1)在EB1B的6个criteria中有一条“Evidence of published material in professional publications written by others about the alien's work in the academic field”。所以,你律师claim这条没有错。 (2)但claim这条时把citations作为证据是否合适,本人知道nothing。在EB1A中也有 类似criterion,但要求较高,实质上必须是媒体报道,所以显然不能用citations作为 证据进行claim。 (3)你的律师用的是撒网式的策略,claim了所有6个criteria。对于这条,实在没有 证据就用了citations,有点勉强。但是否在EB1B中有别的案例这么claim,还成功了也 说不定。你可以和你的律师交流一下,和/或者等等看这版上有没有EB1B的过来人回你 的贴。
Doesn't sound right, unless all citations have specific discussions on your work in long paragraph. Citation can be mentioned as background in this claim, but definitely not everything. For Published Material, it must be some long discussions about your work at recognized journals/websites/media.
Others
【在 j****a 的大作中提到】 : claim成了“Published Material in Professional Publications Written By Others : About the Alien’s Work in the Academic Field” : 这个是不是有问题啊?
j*a
20 楼
谢谢各位讨论。 Google了一下,这个网站上写的是http://www.greencardapply.com/or/or_qualify.htm 3) Published Material about the Person: To satisfy this criterion, the published material should be at the national or international level. Articles in local newspapers or internal company reports do not qualify. Moreover, standard academic citations do not count as published material about the alien beneficiary. 这里明确写了citations是不算Published Material about the Person。 另外在张大律师的网上写着: •Published material in professional publications written by others about the alien's work (more than merely citing the alien's work). 看来一般的引用应该不能被算在这个里面。这个应该主要指Media Report.
j*a
21 楼
顶一下
【在 j****a 的大作中提到】 : 谢谢各位讨论。 : Google了一下,这个网站上写的是http://www.greencardapply.com/or/or_qualify.htm : 3) Published Material about the Person: To satisfy this criterion, the : published material should be at the national or international level. : Articles in local newspapers or internal company reports do not qualify. : Moreover, standard academic citations do not count as published material : about the alien beneficiary. : 这里明确写了citations是不算Published Material about the Person。 : 另外在张大律师的网上写着: : •Published material in professional publications written by others