Re: [转载] HP5, lah lah lah~ *spoiler* - 未名空间MITBBS历史存档

国际科技财经博客移民网络热点娱乐民生时事公众号

Redian新闻

>未名空间

>Reader - 书香世家

Re: [转载] HP5, lah lah lah~ *spoiler*

Re: [转载] HP5, lah lah lah~ *spoiler*# Reader - 书香世家

or2003-06-23 07:06

1 楼

honestly i thought cho was a placid char, and in 5 she was getting a bit like
moaning maytle, rueful and tearful.
no much progress on plot. and more loose ends were left in the end.
the interesting thing is chars were growing up.
ginny was cool, more assertive and forward.
ron was still childish and clownish.
luna was cute.
eventually there'll be three young couples, imo:
ron & hermoine; harry & ginny; neville & luna.
is this too obvious? jkr might surprise us.

b*r2003-06-23 07:06

2 楼

harry and ginny?? Owww! I would love to see harry and cho instead !

like

【在 or 的大作中提到】

: honestly i thought cho was a placid char, and in 5 she was getting a bit like
: moaning maytle, rueful and tearful.
: no much progress on plot. and more loose ends were left in the end.
: the interesting thing is chars were growing up.
: ginny was cool, more assertive and forward.
: ron was still childish and clownish.
: luna was cute.
: eventually there'll be three young couples, imo:
: ron & hermoine; harry & ginny; neville & luna.
: is this too obvious? jkr might surprise us.

or2003-06-23 07:06

3 楼

Is that only me, who neither liked nor disliked Cho? She was so vague and
shallow, while all Weaslies had strong vivid personality. Cho sobed at every
chance, seeing harry, remembering cedric, losing quiditch. Emotionality was
understandable at such a tender age of 15. But, Cedric had been dead only for
a few months and she started to give eyes to Harry. That was a surprise. And
at the end of book, while Harry and she were in rows, she moved on to another
boy Michael. Still teen dates wer

【在 b***r 的大作中提到】

: harry and ginny?? Owww! I would love to see harry and cho instead !
:
: like

G*a2003-06-23 07:06

4 楼

Well, finished reading the book in 40 hrs... The story is more straightfoward,
much less complicated than book 3 or 4. And think of it, there is actually NOT
much happened in this book.
Cho now is portarited as a totally shallow girl, I don't expect to see her
much in the future books (if there is any). I totally agree with Or with the
mirror issue, anyone with a head will use the mirror instead doing anything
else.
And as for Snape, I could not believe after 4 years' fighting and
misunderstand

【在 or 的大作中提到】

: Is that only me, who neither liked nor disliked Cho? She was so vague and
: shallow, while all Weaslies had strong vivid personality. Cho sobed at every
: chance, seeing harry, remembering cedric, losing quiditch. Emotionality was
: understandable at such a tender age of 15. But, Cedric had been dead only for
: a few months and she started to give eyes to Harry. That was a surprise. And
: at the end of book, while Harry and she were in rows, she moved on to another
: boy Michael. Still teen dates wer

or2003-06-23 07:06

5 楼

5 is the worst. it went no where, filled with loose ends. it really really
should have been tightened up. biggest disappointment is the title - "order
of the phoenix". after through 870 pages we only came to know this was a
sceret organization of wizards; that's it, its function, history, etc etc all
hushed, unsaid.

straightfoward,
NOT
the
was
while
grab
were
loose
were
didn't
and

【在 G*****a 的大作中提到】

: Well, finished reading the book in 40 hrs... The story is more straightfoward,
: much less complicated than book 3 or 4. And think of it, there is actually NOT
: much happened in this book.
: Cho now is portarited as a totally shallow girl, I don't expect to see her
: much in the future books (if there is any). I totally agree with Or with the
: mirror issue, anyone with a head will use the mirror instead doing anything
: else.
: And as for Snape, I could not believe after 4 years' fighting and
: misunderstand