申请postdoc被拒的据信是什么样的# Biology - 生物学
C*4
1 楼
如果某人申请一个postdoc职位，面试后老板觉得这个人不够好，据信是直截了当地说
你不够好，还是别的借口？
能否贴一封据信看看，是什么样的？
你不够好，还是别的借口？
能否贴一封据信看看，是什么样的？
a*q
2 楼
这里有一个很有意思的：
Rejected Rejection
(Contributed by Gretchen F. Stoloff)
Herbert A. Millington
Chair - Search Committee
412A Clarkson Hall
Whitson University
College Hill, MA 34109
Dear Professor Millington,
Thank you for your letter of March 16. After careful
consideration, I regret to inform you that I am unable to accept
your refusal to offer me an assistant professor position in your
department.
This year I have been particularly fortunate in receiving an
unusually large number of rejection letters. With such a varied
and promising field of candidates it is impossible for me to accept
all refusals.
Despite Whitson's outstanding qualifications and previous
experience in rejecting applicants, I find that your rejection does
not meet my needs at this time. Therefore, I will assume the
position of assistant professor in your department this August.
I look forward to seeing you then.
Best of luck in rejecting future applicants.
Sincerely,
Chris L. Jensen
Rejected Rejection
(Contributed by Gretchen F. Stoloff)
Herbert A. Millington
Chair - Search Committee
412A Clarkson Hall
Whitson University
College Hill, MA 34109
Dear Professor Millington,
Thank you for your letter of March 16. After careful
consideration, I regret to inform you that I am unable to accept
your refusal to offer me an assistant professor position in your
department.
This year I have been particularly fortunate in receiving an
unusually large number of rejection letters. With such a varied
and promising field of candidates it is impossible for me to accept
all refusals.
Despite Whitson's outstanding qualifications and previous
experience in rejecting applicants, I find that your rejection does
not meet my needs at this time. Therefore, I will assume the
position of assistant professor in your department this August.
I look forward to seeing you then.
Best of luck in rejecting future applicants.
Sincerely,
Chris L. Jensen
C*4
3 楼
这是拒拒信，而且很粗鲁没礼貌
我想看据信，并且是因为面试者跟其他面试者比不够好而拒的。请问这种情况，据信里
面是直截了当地说你不够好、我们有更好的人选，还是别的理由？
我想看据信，并且是因为面试者跟其他面试者比不够好而拒的。请问这种情况，据信里
面是直截了当地说你不够好、我们有更好的人选，还是别的理由？
a*q
4 楼
那封信是开玩笑的。
正式的拒信差不多都这样（Google的），就是说你很好，但
是我们招了别人，祝你好运。
The Search Committee has reviewed an exceptional number of applications for
this position and we were very impressed with the quality of many of the
applicants. Upon careful review of your application, the committee felt that
your accomplishments to date are truly commendable; however, we are unable
to offer you a position at this time. We trust that you will be able to find
a position that is compatible with your research interests and
accomplishments and we offer our best wishes in your future endeavors
"Thank you for the interest that you expressed in the faculty position. The
Recruitment Committee has given serious consideration to your application.
Yours was one of a number of excellent applications that we received.
However, the Committee has decided to focus on other applicants."
>Dear Colleague:
>Thank you for responding to the advertisement for our faculty position.
Although you did not make the short list for an >interview, we truly
appreciate your interest and the opportunity to review >your resume. The
decision was made particularly difficult because of the >large number of
outstanding applicants. Although we have not reached a >final decision yet,
we want to let you know the status of our search at >this time.
"After reviewing all of the application materials, we have selected to
interview those whose skills, knowledge and
experience more closely meet the needs of the hiring department."
"Thank you very much for your application for a position.The search
committee has now met, and I am sorry to say that we have decided not to
pursue your application further. Both the number and the quality of the
applicants have been very high, and we can interview only a limited number
of people.
I am sorry that we cannot respond more positively, and I wish you success in
your future work."
"Thank you for your interest in a faculty position in our department. Our
recruiting committee has met several times over the past two months and has
completed the review of your file. Over 250 total applications were received
. We have decided to limit our interviews to 4 assistant candidates whose
research focuses most closely complement and extend our current faculty in
the department and across the institution. Unfortunately, we are not
currently able to offer you an interview. I hope that your job search will
be successful."
正式的拒信差不多都这样（Google的），就是说你很好，但
是我们招了别人，祝你好运。
The Search Committee has reviewed an exceptional number of applications for
this position and we were very impressed with the quality of many of the
applicants. Upon careful review of your application, the committee felt that
your accomplishments to date are truly commendable; however, we are unable
to offer you a position at this time. We trust that you will be able to find
a position that is compatible with your research interests and
accomplishments and we offer our best wishes in your future endeavors
"Thank you for the interest that you expressed in the faculty position. The
Recruitment Committee has given serious consideration to your application.
Yours was one of a number of excellent applications that we received.
However, the Committee has decided to focus on other applicants."
>Dear Colleague:
>Thank you for responding to the advertisement for our faculty position.
Although you did not make the short list for an >interview, we truly
appreciate your interest and the opportunity to review >your resume. The
decision was made particularly difficult because of the >large number of
outstanding applicants. Although we have not reached a >final decision yet,
we want to let you know the status of our search at >this time.
"After reviewing all of the application materials, we have selected to
interview those whose skills, knowledge and
experience more closely meet the needs of the hiring department."
"Thank you very much for your application for a position.The search
committee has now met, and I am sorry to say that we have decided not to
pursue your application further. Both the number and the quality of the
applicants have been very high, and we can interview only a limited number
of people.
I am sorry that we cannot respond more positively, and I wish you success in
your future work."
"Thank you for your interest in a faculty position in our department. Our
recruiting committee has met several times over the past two months and has
completed the review of your file. Over 250 total applications were received
. We have decided to limit our interviews to 4 assistant candidates whose
research focuses most closely complement and extend our current faculty in
the department and across the institution. Unfortunately, we are not
currently able to offer you an interview. I hope that your job search will
be successful."
a*q
5 楼
当然写点更具体更有人情味的东西常常会感动人的（也是Google的）
I received a rather lengthy rejection letter from a science prof once. It
was about a page long and extremely personalized. There was a lot of you are
great, full of potential, blah blah blah. And reasons why I was rejected
that had nothing to do with me. And there was a lot of I'll do anything I
can do to help you in your career just let me know blah blah blah.
While the rejection letter was highly personalized, full of praise and
encouragement, and obviously the prof took quite a bit of time to write it,
it was still a rejection letter. I guess it was better than a form letter
but there really is nothing good about rejection unless you interview and
decide the position isn't for you in the process.
But having said that, I do remember that personalized rejection letter ,
what it said, and that the prof took time out of his day to compose it. The
science world is a small community and people remember you. I look at that
prof a little bit different because he did take the time out to compose a
personalized letter.
So rejection sucks no matter how you put it. I'm not sure how much
personalized rejections help the people being rejected. But writing
personalized rejection letters might help you when you have to interact with
that person down the road.
I received a rather lengthy rejection letter from a science prof once. It
was about a page long and extremely personalized. There was a lot of you are
great, full of potential, blah blah blah. And reasons why I was rejected
that had nothing to do with me. And there was a lot of I'll do anything I
can do to help you in your career just let me know blah blah blah.
While the rejection letter was highly personalized, full of praise and
encouragement, and obviously the prof took quite a bit of time to write it,
it was still a rejection letter. I guess it was better than a form letter
but there really is nothing good about rejection unless you interview and
decide the position isn't for you in the process.
But having said that, I do remember that personalized rejection letter ,
what it said, and that the prof took time out of his day to compose it. The
science world is a small community and people remember you. I look at that
prof a little bit different because he did take the time out to compose a
personalized letter.
So rejection sucks no matter how you put it. I'm not sure how much
personalized rejections help the people being rejected. But writing
personalized rejection letters might help you when you have to interact with
that person down the road.
w*r
6 楼
有的说没钱了，准备downsize lab，
有的直接就说没有位置了，
有的说刚招了人，到2014年代都不打算招人了，
之类的
有的直接就说没有位置了，
有的说刚招了人，到2014年代都不打算招人了，
之类的
l*1
7 楼
H Medi school one PI replied:
I will run my own business later.
Sorry for i can not offer you.
Regards,
Bla bla bla
PhD MD MBA
NB: pay attention any MBA title PI within H Medi school s/he may run her/his
own business soon later.
【在 w********r 的大作中提到】
: 有的说没钱了，准备downsize lab，
: 有的直接就说没有位置了，
: 有的说刚招了人，到2014年代都不打算招人了，
: 之类的
I will run my own business later.
Sorry for i can not offer you.
Regards,
Bla bla bla
PhD MD MBA
NB: pay attention any MBA title PI within H Medi school s/he may run her/his
own business soon later.
【在 w********r 的大作中提到】
: 有的说没钱了，准备downsize lab，
: 有的直接就说没有位置了，
: 有的说刚招了人，到2014年代都不打算招人了，
: 之类的
g*3
8 楼
好多人如果你不继续询问，大概连回信据你都不会。等你回的时候大概就是:
sorry that this position has been filled. This does not mean that you are
not qualified; just because we found a candidate who is better fit to our
need.
-------------------
不明白问这个问题干什么，第一个回帖的拒拒信其实是个perfect example.比较正式的
职位的拒信大抵如此。还有，没有人拒绝你会直接说你不够好，都是拐弯末角说你不行
而已。意思其实是一样的。
sorry that this position has been filled. This does not mean that you are
not qualified; just because we found a candidate who is better fit to our
need.
-------------------
不明白问这个问题干什么，第一个回帖的拒拒信其实是个perfect example.比较正式的
职位的拒信大抵如此。还有，没有人拒绝你会直接说你不够好，都是拐弯末角说你不行
而已。意思其实是一样的。
相关阅读
John O'Keefe, May-Britt and Edvard Moser几个搞物理的跑去生物界搞搞成像 (转载)“庄小威的论文发表晚于白兹格”这个借口太虚伪了准备做RNA sequencing,需要多少的RNA袁隆平算是转基因大米之父了吧毕业了还回去补实验的有吗？弱问关于光学显微镜的问题10几个氨基酸的peptide能进入活细胞吗？庄小伟这样的也算美女？？说个常识性的事实，庄要是心中没鬼或者没听到什么，为什么投NATURE METHOD有人了解UC Berkeley的Richard Mathies吗求两篇文献History of Neuroscience...不知不觉就到博四了，有点小慌张文献求助,200伪币这次炸药奖，感觉庄很躺枪啊为啥就生物drama多？小威这次没奖的原因，还是 Steve Chu 的圈子罩不到她。也发一个招人信息~bioinformatician【求推荐】qPCR system