v*a
2 楼
when economists say they are doing science, physists laugh;
when physists say they are genius, mathematicians laugh.
Greed is great.
economics =/= economy
I know some Chicago economics PhDs working for government not doing
"academic" research.
like it or not, people do differentiate others based on school/subject/
money/ etc. Chicago, MIT, Harvard, Stanford, these big 4 ARE snobbish.
like it or not.
LIFE IS LIFE.
when physists say they are genius, mathematicians laugh.
Greed is great.
economics =/= economy
I know some Chicago economics PhDs working for government not doing
"academic" research.
like it or not, people do differentiate others based on school/subject/
money/ etc. Chicago, MIT, Harvard, Stanford, these big 4 ARE snobbish.
like it or not.
LIFE IS LIFE.
r*s
3 楼
No more than old cliche. Check this out:
Hedges, L. V. (1987). How hard is hard science, how soft is soft science?
American Psychologist, 42(2), 443-455.
//don't know what you mean.
These are based on the assumption that all people are after the same
things, which ignored the vast range of individual differences in terms
of preferences and life priority. Not all things are compared against
the criteria economists like.
//hehe, deep.
【在 v******a 的大作中提到】
: when economists say they are doing science, physists laugh;
: when physists say they are genius, mathematicians laugh.
: Greed is great.
: economics =/= economy
: I know some Chicago economics PhDs working for government not doing
: "academic" research.
: like it or not, people do differentiate others based on school/subject/
: money/ etc. Chicago, MIT, Harvard, Stanford, these big 4 ARE snobbish.
: like it or not.
: LIFE IS LIFE.
i*s
4 楼
HOW HARD IS HARD SCIENCE, HOW SOFT IS SOFT SCIENCE? The Empirical
Cumulativeness of Research
Larry V. Hedges (1987, American Psychologist)
People tend to think social sciences are softer science, compared to natural
science, which is more cumulative. The author first differentiates the concept
cumulativeness in the scientific field into two types. One is conceptual or
theoretical cumulativeness, which means in the broadest sense scientific
results are cumulative if empirical laws and theoretical
【在 r******s 的大作中提到】
:
: No more than old cliche. Check this out:
: Hedges, L. V. (1987). How hard is hard science, how soft is soft science?
: American Psychologist, 42(2), 443-455.
: //don't know what you mean.
: These are based on the assumption that all people are after the same
: things, which ignored the vast range of individual differences in terms
: of preferences and life priority. Not all things are compared against
: the criteria economists like.
: //hehe, deep.
Cumulativeness of Research
Larry V. Hedges (1987, American Psychologist)
People tend to think social sciences are softer science, compared to natural
science, which is more cumulative. The author first differentiates the concept
cumulativeness in the scientific field into two types. One is conceptual or
theoretical cumulativeness, which means in the broadest sense scientific
results are cumulative if empirical laws and theoretical
【在 r******s 的大作中提到】
:
: No more than old cliche. Check this out:
: Hedges, L. V. (1987). How hard is hard science, how soft is soft science?
: American Psychologist, 42(2), 443-455.
: //don't know what you mean.
: These are based on the assumption that all people are after the same
: things, which ignored the vast range of individual differences in terms
: of preferences and life priority. Not all things are compared against
: the criteria economists like.
: //hehe, deep.
i*s
5 楼
This is just a summary of the original paper, which is not available online.
The summary is from
http://www.gsia.cmu.edu/andrew/mf4f/work/rm/html/hedges.html, summitted by
Wendy Li.
concept
experimental
used
in
example,
used
sciences,
the
methods
it
【在 i***s 的大作中提到】
: HOW HARD IS HARD SCIENCE, HOW SOFT IS SOFT SCIENCE? The Empirical
: Cumulativeness of Research
: Larry V. Hedges (1987, American Psychologist)
: People tend to think social sciences are softer science, compared to natural
: science, which is more cumulative. The author first differentiates the concept
: cumulativeness in the scientific field into two types. One is conceptual or
: theoretical cumulativeness, which means in the broadest sense scientific
: results are cumulative if empirical laws and theoretical
The summary is from
http://www.gsia.cmu.edu/andrew/mf4f/work/rm/html/hedges.html, summitted by
Wendy Li.
concept
experimental
used
in
example,
used
sciences,
the
methods
it
【在 i***s 的大作中提到】
: HOW HARD IS HARD SCIENCE, HOW SOFT IS SOFT SCIENCE? The Empirical
: Cumulativeness of Research
: Larry V. Hedges (1987, American Psychologist)
: People tend to think social sciences are softer science, compared to natural
: science, which is more cumulative. The author first differentiates the concept
: cumulativeness in the scientific field into two types. One is conceptual or
: theoretical cumulativeness, which means in the broadest sense scientific
: results are cumulative if empirical laws and theoretical
相关阅读
请教panel data: T >> N关于发文章排名问题请教[合集] 中国高等研究院(CIAS或CAAS)正式成立 (转载)转贴：激辩广东模式：广东模式是否该被终结？[合集] 通货膨胀Perloff's microeconomics wanted不仅是引进了一批海归——一位上财研究生的博客日志数据求助[合集] 问个问题：fixed effects model 里面的 multicollinearity搞经济的朋友，这篇文章说的有道理吗？An old Chinese myth[合集] 这里牛人多，请大牛说说怎样才能学好博弈论吧？求备课指导！急！[合集] 中国金融学批判ZT[合集] 外行求教，望达人解惑（关于通货膨胀和热钱）[合集] 近十年来Harvard培养了哪些中国学术强人?用经济学方法看地震局和地方政府在防震救灾中的工作[合集] 发paper的时机和tenure的关系？希望做game theory的朋友多多交流[合集] 武汉大学ＩＡＳ2007-2008申请出国留学成绩ZT[合集] 多说几句