TSC EB1A 140 PP 弱case 被RFE, 求意见和指导# Immigration - 落地生根
k*r
1 楼
先说一下本人背景:肿瘤方向,国内本科学的临床,美国前三十大学博士毕业。现在第
一年博后。一共11篇文章,5篇一作(里面有两篇是中文的)。会议海报13篇。总计
citation是316,大部分来自非一作的文章。一作只有近50个引用。审稿68篇。5篇推荐
信,四篇独立一篇来自自己的导师。四篇独立推荐信中两个人引了我的文章,分别来自
中国和美国。另外两篇没引我的文章,来自日本和美国。
12月26号140/PP的材料寄到tsc,1月8号收到了Officer# XM 1027的RFE。主要的要求补
充以下证据:
1:Translations regarding documents in a Foreign Language
不知道为什么提到中文文章的翻译。我是按照要求有让人翻译title,authors,abstract
和journal这些东西的,还写了certification of translation,并且去找公证员作了
公正。
2:Documentation to establish that the beneficiary will continue to work in
their claimed area of expertise
我提供了Letters from current employers,但主要讲了我现在的工作和薪水什么的,
没讲未来的规划。可能是需要另外写个statement?
3:contributions of major significance in tile field
This criterion has not been met because the evidence submitted does not show
that the beneficiary's contributions are considered to be of major
significance in the field of endeavor. The letters of recommendation and
citation index have indicated the beneficiary's research has had some notice
to the field. All researchers are expected to perform useful research to
advance the field. However, while the majority of research is useful in
promoting and identifying areas for more research, not all of it is of a
major significance to the field. Citations are evidence of useful research.
Research contributing directly to the discovery of a new treatment or cure
would have major significance. The beneficiary's research appears to have
contributed more to the overall knowledge of the field rather than resulting
in a contribution of major significance.
应该是说我的research比较直接的translational application比较少。这个确实是我
的弱项。毕竟自己做的是比较基础的研究。确实没有什么直接转化到临床运用的,没有
patent。原先主要是claim了citation, media report和推荐信。media report还是蛮
多的。
authorship和judge都是meet the criterion。其他的方面也没什么claim。没有什么非
常重要的membership。没有媒体采访受要邀演讲什么的。没有什么大奖。那些小的
membership,奖项怕被说不够significant,都没有写进去。
现在律师告诉我说Officer# XM 1027 RFE后deny的概率很高,建议我withdraw and
refile.但是我查了以下, 发现mitbbs上有几例1027 approve after RFE的。我想求助
大家的意见,特别是过来人的。我这样的case该withdraw吗。考虑到有看到版上说
withdraw后貌似要等3个月才能再
refile。现在前景实在不明了,不知道再等下去又有什么变故。有人了解OI 1027吗?
如果我不withdraw,我该怎样claim significance.
谢谢大家帮忙!祝大家新的一年一帆风顺,心想事成。
一年博后。一共11篇文章,5篇一作(里面有两篇是中文的)。会议海报13篇。总计
citation是316,大部分来自非一作的文章。一作只有近50个引用。审稿68篇。5篇推荐
信,四篇独立一篇来自自己的导师。四篇独立推荐信中两个人引了我的文章,分别来自
中国和美国。另外两篇没引我的文章,来自日本和美国。
12月26号140/PP的材料寄到tsc,1月8号收到了Officer# XM 1027的RFE。主要的要求补
充以下证据:
1:Translations regarding documents in a Foreign Language
不知道为什么提到中文文章的翻译。我是按照要求有让人翻译title,authors,abstract
和journal这些东西的,还写了certification of translation,并且去找公证员作了
公正。
2:Documentation to establish that the beneficiary will continue to work in
their claimed area of expertise
我提供了Letters from current employers,但主要讲了我现在的工作和薪水什么的,
没讲未来的规划。可能是需要另外写个statement?
3:contributions of major significance in tile field
This criterion has not been met because the evidence submitted does not show
that the beneficiary's contributions are considered to be of major
significance in the field of endeavor. The letters of recommendation and
citation index have indicated the beneficiary's research has had some notice
to the field. All researchers are expected to perform useful research to
advance the field. However, while the majority of research is useful in
promoting and identifying areas for more research, not all of it is of a
major significance to the field. Citations are evidence of useful research.
Research contributing directly to the discovery of a new treatment or cure
would have major significance. The beneficiary's research appears to have
contributed more to the overall knowledge of the field rather than resulting
in a contribution of major significance.
应该是说我的research比较直接的translational application比较少。这个确实是我
的弱项。毕竟自己做的是比较基础的研究。确实没有什么直接转化到临床运用的,没有
patent。原先主要是claim了citation, media report和推荐信。media report还是蛮
多的。
authorship和judge都是meet the criterion。其他的方面也没什么claim。没有什么非
常重要的membership。没有媒体采访受要邀演讲什么的。没有什么大奖。那些小的
membership,奖项怕被说不够significant,都没有写进去。
现在律师告诉我说Officer# XM 1027 RFE后deny的概率很高,建议我withdraw and
refile.但是我查了以下, 发现mitbbs上有几例1027 approve after RFE的。我想求助
大家的意见,特别是过来人的。我这样的case该withdraw吗。考虑到有看到版上说
withdraw后貌似要等3个月才能再
refile。现在前景实在不明了,不知道再等下去又有什么变故。有人了解OI 1027吗?
如果我不withdraw,我该怎样claim significance.
谢谢大家帮忙!祝大家新的一年一帆风顺,心想事成。