也说在阳台上晒衣服# Living
T*k
1 楼
eb1-b applied 10/2010,
waited almost 11 month, got this RFE
基本情况
1） 理科 Ph.D. 2008 graduate
14 papers (4 first author, Impact factor ~2-3 )
Citation ~70 (40 independent)
6 presentations
2） research scientist in a public traded company 2008-2010
1 paper (first author)
3 patent applications (or pending patent)
No review, no award.
EB-1b application
1) 公司找的律师（in a big local firm）
2) Claims 4 criteria:
Membership (Sigma Xi)
Media report
Original scientific contribution
Publication
RFE response:
1) Membership claim is not met
The officer 没说sigma Xi member 不qualify.
我的材料明明是full member, 他却说我是associate member， 所以不qualify.
2) Media Report is not met
帮我做EB1-B的legal assistant 把我scientific journal 引用 中，提到我名字和工
作的段落，都当成 media report.
这条在申请的时候，我就觉得有问题。我跟律师说这条不成立，不过律师说他们的
strategy 就是多用criteria, USCIS officer 不好全驳倒。
3) Original scientific contribution is okay
4) Publication is not met
The Officer argued that “There is nothing in the record to show that these
journals have international circulation”.
我的材料里有 SJR的journal Ranking， 也有这些journal 的介绍，像jcp, 都有70多
年历史了。
最重要的：我如何demonstrate I was recognized internationally as outstanding through eminence and distinction in the academic field.
我该怎么回答呢？
Some updates( after the application date, 不知有没有用）
1) One more paper published, at least 3 new patents disclosure submitted.
2) The tool I worked on two years ago was launched commercially this year
, some business website reported this tool. 我觉得我可以要到一封信说我是
leading scientist.
谢谢有经验的前辈们不惜吝啬多多指教。
waited almost 11 month, got this RFE
基本情况
1） 理科 Ph.D. 2008 graduate
14 papers (4 first author, Impact factor ~2-3 )
Citation ~70 (40 independent)
6 presentations
2） research scientist in a public traded company 2008-2010
1 paper (first author)
3 patent applications (or pending patent)
No review, no award.
EB-1b application
1) 公司找的律师（in a big local firm）
2) Claims 4 criteria:
Membership (Sigma Xi)
Media report
Original scientific contribution
Publication
RFE response:
1) Membership claim is not met
The officer 没说sigma Xi member 不qualify.
我的材料明明是full member, 他却说我是associate member， 所以不qualify.
2) Media Report is not met
帮我做EB1-B的legal assistant 把我scientific journal 引用 中，提到我名字和工
作的段落，都当成 media report.
这条在申请的时候，我就觉得有问题。我跟律师说这条不成立，不过律师说他们的
strategy 就是多用criteria, USCIS officer 不好全驳倒。
3) Original scientific contribution is okay
4) Publication is not met
The Officer argued that “There is nothing in the record to show that these
journals have international circulation”.
我的材料里有 SJR的journal Ranking， 也有这些journal 的介绍，像jcp, 都有70多
年历史了。
最重要的：我如何demonstrate I was recognized internationally as outstanding through eminence and distinction in the academic field.
我该怎么回答呢？
Some updates( after the application date, 不知有没有用）
1) One more paper published, at least 3 new patents disclosure submitted.
2) The tool I worked on two years ago was launched commercially this year
, some business website reported this tool. 我觉得我可以要到一封信说我是
leading scientist.
谢谢有经验的前辈们不惜吝啬多多指教。
