转载：最爱的人死了（Harry Potter V评论及预测） - 未名空间MITBBS历史存档

转载：最爱的人死了（Harry Potter V评论及预测）# Reader - 书香世家

s*o2003-07-06 07:07

1 楼

BY 贝利亚
我总觉得罗琳创造了那么可爱又超级酷的角色就绝不会轻易饶过他，但也没想到这女人会
在第五集就把我亲爱的Sirius给解决掉。虽然说大结局的壮烈牺牲是留给Dumbledore校长
的，但第五集……似乎也太快了点。
我看到第23章Sirius单臂抱了Harry一下的时候就几乎要肯定Sirius死定了，这温情的暗
示简直是太明显了。但最后看到他真的掉到帷幔后面还是抱着纸巾大哭特哭了一场。
第四集既然已经开始死人，读者当然就会要求更大的感官刺激。随随便便死几个刚出场没
几页，连名字还背不熟的人物当然是不行了。于是，Sirius就在和death eater英勇搏斗
之后，很优雅的死翘翘了。
想来罗琳是喜欢他的，只要看到如下的描述就知道了：
chapter 28:
He was very good looking; his dark hair fell into his eyes with a sort of
casual elegance neither James's nor Harry's could ever have achieved.
chapter 35:
His bod

k*a2003-07-06 07:07

2 楼

看了第四集确实觉得Ron应该喜欢Hermione。不过我以为Hermione会
喜欢Harry因为第四集最后说她吻了Harry的脸颊。当时觉得他俩差
不多成。
我没看第五集，所以无法搞清Hermione到底喜欢谁。不过现在觉得她
和Ron我也挺高兴了。
Sirius太惨了，哎。

【在 s****o 的大作中提到】

: BY 贝利亚
: 我总觉得罗琳创造了那么可爱又超级酷的角色就绝不会轻易饶过他，但也没想到这女人会
: 在第五集就把我亲爱的Sirius给解决掉。虽然说大结局的壮烈牺牲是留给Dumbledore校长
: 的，但第五集……似乎也太快了点。
: 我看到第23章Sirius单臂抱了Harry一下的时候就几乎要肯定Sirius死定了，这温情的暗
: 示简直是太明显了。但最后看到他真的掉到帷幔后面还是抱着纸巾大哭特哭了一场。
: 第四集既然已经开始死人，读者当然就会要求更大的感官刺激。随随便便死几个刚出场没
: 几页，连名字还背不熟的人物当然是不行了。于是，Sirius就在和death eater英勇搏斗
: 之后，很优雅的死翘翘了。
: 想来罗琳是喜欢他的，只要看到如下的描述就知道了：

a*a2003-07-06 07:07

3 楼

Is it written by you? :-) I think I am also in love with Sirius :-) and got a
bit choked up when he "died", although I already knew he was the one half way
through the book... As I replied to another HP post in the Literature board,
his death is too sudden and as many people suggested he was not hit by a
"killing" curse so he may come back in another form (image in the mirror,
spirit, phantom, dream, whatever). JKR will bring him back one way or another
now that there is so much pressure from di

【在 s****o 的大作中提到】

: BY 贝利亚
: 我总觉得罗琳创造了那么可爱又超级酷的角色就绝不会轻易饶过他，但也没想到这女人会
: 在第五集就把我亲爱的Sirius给解决掉。虽然说大结局的壮烈牺牲是留给Dumbledore校长
: 的，但第五集……似乎也太快了点。
: 我看到第23章Sirius单臂抱了Harry一下的时候就几乎要肯定Sirius死定了，这温情的暗
: 示简直是太明显了。但最后看到他真的掉到帷幔后面还是抱着纸巾大哭特哭了一场。
: 第四集既然已经开始死人，读者当然就会要求更大的感官刺激。随随便便死几个刚出场没
: 几页，连名字还背不熟的人物当然是不行了。于是，Sirius就在和death eater英勇搏斗
: 之后，很优雅的死翘翘了。
: 想来罗琳是喜欢他的，只要看到如下的描述就知道了：

or2003-07-06 07:07

4 楼

perhaps snape will end up together with trelawny(sp?), the divination prof;
and lupin with tonks. i liked lupin best of all adult wizards.
and harry'll find ultimate love in moaning martyle..arghhh
one thing for sure, all dead persons including sirius was not going to
resurrect. good fantasy is either sublime, such as the myth type, or as
mundane as real life. "harry potter" is in the latter category. many
messages that rowling managed to pass to readers are realistic: love is the
strongest

【在 s****o 的大作中提到】

: BY 贝利亚
: 我总觉得罗琳创造了那么可爱又超级酷的角色就绝不会轻易饶过他，但也没想到这女人会
: 在第五集就把我亲爱的Sirius给解决掉。虽然说大结局的壮烈牺牲是留给Dumbledore校长
: 的，但第五集……似乎也太快了点。
: 我看到第23章Sirius单臂抱了Harry一下的时候就几乎要肯定Sirius死定了，这温情的暗
: 示简直是太明显了。但最后看到他真的掉到帷幔后面还是抱着纸巾大哭特哭了一场。
: 第四集既然已经开始死人，读者当然就会要求更大的感官刺激。随随便便死几个刚出场没
: 几页，连名字还背不熟的人物当然是不行了。于是，Sirius就在和death eater英勇搏斗
: 之后，很优雅的死翘翘了。
: 想来罗琳是喜欢他的，只要看到如下的描述就知道了：

s*o2003-07-06 07:07

5 楼

hi, this is belail, i'm the author of this little review. sharco is so kindly
to let me use his ID since i just registered and can't reply yet.
my favorite characters list is
Sirius!!!-he is just so cool!!! hard to believe he stay single all these
years, i know...he spent last 10 years in Azkaban, but still, james married
with Lily...
Lupin-i love his calm quiet feeling.
Hermione-always reminds me about Liza Simpson in "the Simpsons".
Dumbledore-he knows everything, he got everything in control,

s*o2003-07-06 07:07

6 楼

this is Belail, i'm using sharco's ID since mine still not activated yet.
Snape will die a heroic death, tortured to death and stay loyal to dumbledore
by the dark lord that sort of stuff.
i never thought about Lupin and tonks...but it seems a good idea if both of
them survived.
how could you so sure that Sirius won't come back? if rowling really want to
really "kill" him, where's the body? the shock will be much greater if the
body was left. that's a hint, he will come back.
don't be so "clever

【在 or 的大作中提到】

: perhaps snape will end up together with trelawny(sp?), the divination prof;
: and lupin with tonks. i liked lupin best of all adult wizards.
: and harry'll find ultimate love in moaning martyle..arghhh
: one thing for sure, all dead persons including sirius was not going to
: resurrect. good fantasy is either sublime, such as the myth type, or as
: mundane as real life. "harry potter" is in the latter category. many
: messages that rowling managed to pass to readers are realistic: love is the
: strongest

l*y2003-07-06 07:07

7 楼

harry'll find ultimate love in moaning martyle? dear god...

的
物性格不够鲜明。我一直期待HP里面会出现一个很有个性的反派次强者，因为幕后大BOSS
的
至
集

【在 or 的大作中提到】

: perhaps snape will end up together with trelawny(sp?), the divination prof;
: and lupin with tonks. i liked lupin best of all adult wizards.
: and harry'll find ultimate love in moaning martyle..arghhh
: one thing for sure, all dead persons including sirius was not going to
: resurrect. good fantasy is either sublime, such as the myth type, or as
: mundane as real life. "harry potter" is in the latter category. many
: messages that rowling managed to pass to readers are realistic: love is the
: strongest

or2003-07-06 07:07

8 楼

gee this was a jest.

prof;
the

【在 l***y 的大作中提到】

: harry'll find ultimate love in moaning martyle? dear god...
:
: 的
: 物性格不够鲜明。我一直期待HP里面会出现一个很有个性的反派次强者，因为幕后大BOSS
: 的
: 至
: 集

or2003-07-06 07:07

9 楼

they were personal speculations and were not clever. feel free to dismiss
them and look for agreeableness elsewhere.

rowling

【在 s****o 的大作中提到】

: this is Belail, i'm using sharco's ID since mine still not activated yet.
: Snape will die a heroic death, tortured to death and stay loyal to dumbledore
: by the dark lord that sort of stuff.
: i never thought about Lupin and tonks...but it seems a good idea if both of
: them survived.
: how could you so sure that Sirius won't come back? if rowling really want to
: really "kill" him, where's the body? the shock will be much greater if the
: body was left. that's a hint, he will come back.
: don't be so "clever