It is shockingly stupid to exclude U of Calgary. The list is not rude or arrogant, but simply stupid. Do they really think themselves to be intelligent enough to judge qualities of universities? Why not to exclude Cambridge U as well due to the student who threw his shoes?
Calm down... Because U of Calgary is not good ENOUGH. Imagine if Stanford did exactly the same thing as U of Calgary did, do you believe that Stanford will be thrown off the list. Then again, Stanford would not be so stupid to do as U of Calgary has done. Peace.
【在 h*****n 的大作中提到】 : It is shockingly stupid to exclude U of Calgary. : The list is not rude or arrogant, but simply stupid. Do they really think : themselves to be intelligent enough to judge qualities of universities? : Why not to exclude Cambridge U as well due to the student who threw his : shoes?
【在 h*****n 的大作中提到】 : It is shockingly stupid to exclude U of Calgary. : The list is not rude or arrogant, but simply stupid. Do they really think : themselves to be intelligent enough to judge qualities of universities? : Why not to exclude Cambridge U as well due to the student who threw his : shoes?
f*t
27 楼
嗯 whitera的forcefield真是猛
j*a
28 楼
杀鸡骇猴吧. 剑桥的那个属于学生个人行为,而Calgary则是学校的行为. 两者是有区别 的.
【在 h*****n 的大作中提到】 : It is shockingly stupid to exclude U of Calgary. : The list is not rude or arrogant, but simply stupid. Do they really think : themselves to be intelligent enough to judge qualities of universities? : Why not to exclude Cambridge U as well due to the student who threw his : shoes?
Only grad students there can point out stupidity? Actually, I am the chancellor there. Wanna apply for a job at U of Calgary? Send cv through mitbbs mail, though I do not think you have a chance.
【在 h********0 的大作中提到】 : You must be a graduate student there?
Given your reply, the list is actually more credible to me now. No wonder U of Calgary is off the list, just look how its chancellor behaves :)
?
【在 h*****n 的大作中提到】 : Only grad students there can point out stupidity? : Actually, I am the chancellor there. Wanna apply for a job at U of Calgary? : Send cv through mitbbs mail, though I do not think you have a chance.
w*e
35 楼
不是商科的不敢发言 但生物医学类类似漏掉的牛研究性单位也不少。 这种质量的信息不是在误导大众么?
【在 z****k 的大作中提到】 : 欧洲top5商学院有三个不在里头
o*y
36 楼
For example? Because the list is soooooooo extensive, I am very much in doubt that any `significant` institution has been missed.
【在 o****y 的大作中提到】 : For example? : Because the list is soooooooo extensive, I am very much in doubt that any `significant` institution has been : missed.
c*r
38 楼
Lots of community colleges are in the list, but UC Merced is not, probably because the latter is new and hence is not in the sources used by the Education Ministry.
`significant` institution has been
【在 o****y 的大作中提到】 : For example? : Because the list is soooooooo extensive, I am very much in doubt that any `significant` institution has been : missed.
c*r
39 楼
I feel the list is useless precisely because it is too extensive. It includes tons of two-year community colleges that I very much doubt Chinese parents should send their kids to.
`significant` institution has been
【在 o****y 的大作中提到】 : For example? : Because the list is soooooooo extensive, I am very much in doubt that any `significant` institution has been : missed.
o*y
40 楼
Pardon your language. Please specify at least one institution, which is a top5 business school in EU, but did not show up in the list. The reason I am so serious about this is that I was a member of the committee that recommended the list. I'd like to make sure if there is an omission, we can amend it.
【在 h*****n 的大作中提到】 : Frankly, there is no point (maybe some cents) justifying this list. : Compare this to the list: : http://rankings.ft.com/businessschoolrankings/european-business-school-ranki : ngs : This thread should sink due to the shitty list therein, period. : : `significant` institution has been
c*r
41 楼
Fair enough. I do hope you can help correct the obvious mistake I pointed out above.
country.
【在 o****y 的大作中提到】 : Pardon your language. : Please specify at least one institution, which is a top5 business school in : EU, but did not show up in the list. : The reason I am so serious about this is that I was a member of the : committee that recommended the list. I'd : like to make sure if there is an omission, we can amend it.
o*y
42 楼
Only part of the list. The list was made state by state, country by country.
of
【在 c****r 的大作中提到】 : Fair enough. I do hope you can help correct the obvious mistake I pointed : out above. : : country.
o*y
43 楼
I personally agree that UC Merced should be included.
【在 c****r 的大作中提到】 : Fair enough. I do hope you can help correct the obvious mistake I pointed : out above. : : country.
c*r
44 楼
It's just a joke that tons of two-year community colleges are included, but a Ph.D. granting University of California campus is not. So is there anything that can be done about it?
【在 o****y 的大作中提到】 : I personally agree that UC Merced should be included.
o*y
45 楼
Like any project of such scale, there will be issues. I think the best way to communicate is to email 教育部, and bring their attention to this omission. An even better way is to let the school of concern knows this, and let them to contact the education office of Chinese embassy.
but
【在 c****r 的大作中提到】 : It's just a joke that tons of two-year community colleges are included, but : a Ph.D. granting University of California campus is not. : So is there anything that can be done about it?
c*r
46 楼
Since you're part of the project, I think you're better than anybody else to help correct this glaring error. At least you know whom to contact, even if you're not part of the California sub-project. Me emailing 教育部 and getting a reply? And you mentioned that "I'd like to make sure if there is an omission, we can amend it."
【在 o****y 的大作中提到】 : Like any project of such scale, there will be issues. : I think the best way to communicate is to email 教育部, and bring their : attention to this omission. An even : better way is to let the school of concern knows this, and let them to : contact the education office of Chinese : embassy. : : but
o*y
47 楼
I will report this error. However, the more important thing is that WE should be active in finding ways to make the list more suitable to its stated objective, instead of just complaining. After all, some of us DO care about this list.
to help correct this glaring error. At least you know whom to contact. Me emailing 教育部 and getting a reply?
【在 c****r 的大作中提到】 : Since you're part of the project, I think you're better than anybody else to help correct this glaring error. At least you know whom to contact, even if you're not part of the California sub-project. Me emailing 教育部 and getting a reply? : And you mentioned that "I'd like to make sure if there is an omission, we can amend it."
c*r
48 楼
Well, I think I AM helping to make the list better, by pointing out an obvious error. And thank you for participating in this discussion here and promising to report the error.
complaining.
【在 o****y 的大作中提到】 : I will report this error. However, the more important thing is that WE : should be active in finding ways to make : the list more suitable to its stated objective, instead of just complaining. : After all, some of us DO care about : this list. : : to help correct this glaring error. At : least you know whom to contact. Me emailing 教育部 and getting a reply?
c*r
49 楼
And to make the list more suitable for its stated objective (为帮助自费出国 留学人员正确选择国外学习学校), I do suggest to separate those two-year community colleges from four-year colleges. At least those community colleges should be clearly marked.
complaining.
【在 o****y 的大作中提到】 : I will report this error. However, the more important thing is that WE : should be active in finding ways to make : the list more suitable to its stated objective, instead of just complaining. : After all, some of us DO care about : this list. : : to help correct this glaring error. At : least you know whom to contact. Me emailing 教育部 and getting a reply?
o*y
50 楼
I think it is a great idea. Your suggestion was actually under consideration . However, it takes time to further refine the list. One thing is certain, more changes are on the way.
【在 c****r 的大作中提到】 : And to make the list more suitable for its stated objective (为帮助自费出国 : 留学人员正确选择国外学习学校), I do suggest to separate those two-year : community colleges from four-year colleges. At least those community : colleges should be clearly marked. : : complaining.
w*e
51 楼
cold spring harbor laboraory 在NY 生物领域很有名的 www.cshl.edu
`significant` institution has been
【在 o****y 的大作中提到】 : For example? : Because the list is soooooooo extensive, I am very much in doubt that any `significant` institution has been : missed.
I think University of Strathclyde (UK) should be included as well (It's my previous university :)), although the overall ranking is so so according to the RAE 2008, but it is... Top in Scotland and 8th in the UK for Pharmacy; top in Scotland and 12th in UK for Business and management studies; Second in Scotland and 17th for Chemistry; Second in Scotland and 13th in the UK for Law; Second in Scotland and 21st in UK for Electrical and Electronic Engineering. Moreover, it is ranked higher than U. o
【在 o****y 的大作中提到】 : I think it is a great idea. Your suggestion was actually under consideration : . However, it takes time to further : refine the list. One thing is certain, more changes are on the way.