求flowjo# Biology - 生物学
y*a
1 楼
我的材料是11月底送到TSC的,当初claim了3点,一个是judge,一个是contribution,
还有一个是authorship。
今天收到了RFE,我的judge和authorship都过了,不过contribution需要补材料,说我
的引用少。实际上我引用的数目很多(independent>160),可是呢,有一半是知网的
,他们说,这些文章并没有引用我的(the submitted translation citations from
CNKI does not appear to cite your articles, rather the database was searched
for key words, some of which are used in your articles.)。
非常奇怪的是,他们还说我另外一点media也meet this criterion了,可是我根本没有
申请这一点,我把所有的media的信息都放在contribution上面了。
所以第一部份,我就稀里糊涂地过了3点。
然后在第2步我又被卡住了,我需要补交材料证明我是:
1 Are one of a small percentage who are at the very top of their field, and
2 Have sustained national or international acclaim
他们在RFE里面是这么写的:
Although you have met three of the regulatory criteria, sustained national
or international acclaim has not been documented.主要是说我没有奖,没有专利
,也没有会员。然后非常奇怪的是,接下去又写,我review的经历也不行,只review了
3个manuscript(可是我交上去的证据绝对不仅仅是3篇,具体我也忘记了,十几个
manuscripts还是有的吧,而且我的judge也通过了)。然后又重复我的引用少,所以,
this is not indicative of an individual who has reached the very top of the
field or sustained national or international acclaim.
我应该怎么做呢,求帮助。
还有一个是authorship。
今天收到了RFE,我的judge和authorship都过了,不过contribution需要补材料,说我
的引用少。实际上我引用的数目很多(independent>160),可是呢,有一半是知网的
,他们说,这些文章并没有引用我的(the submitted translation citations from
CNKI does not appear to cite your articles, rather the database was searched
for key words, some of which are used in your articles.)。
非常奇怪的是,他们还说我另外一点media也meet this criterion了,可是我根本没有
申请这一点,我把所有的media的信息都放在contribution上面了。
所以第一部份,我就稀里糊涂地过了3点。
然后在第2步我又被卡住了,我需要补交材料证明我是:
1 Are one of a small percentage who are at the very top of their field, and
2 Have sustained national or international acclaim
他们在RFE里面是这么写的:
Although you have met three of the regulatory criteria, sustained national
or international acclaim has not been documented.主要是说我没有奖,没有专利
,也没有会员。然后非常奇怪的是,接下去又写,我review的经历也不行,只review了
3个manuscript(可是我交上去的证据绝对不仅仅是3篇,具体我也忘记了,十几个
manuscripts还是有的吧,而且我的judge也通过了)。然后又重复我的引用少,所以,
this is not indicative of an individual who has reached the very top of the
field or sustained national or international acclaim.
我应该怎么做呢,求帮助。