s*g
2 楼
投本领域top杂志,非CNS。
一个reviewer意见很positive, “Overall this is a very nice paper, with a
very novel message”,另外提了一些小意见。
另一个reviwer意见negative, “Although the manuscript presents some
interesting observations using tools to describe endogenous levels of tagged
pathway components, the data are simply not sufficient to support the
proposed model, and I therefore cannot recommend publication in ***.”
提的意见很picky,完全有点挑刺的感觉。
感觉怎么补数据,第二个reviewer都不会相信了。
迷茫中,老板的意见是补数据,看能不能说服第二个reviewer,我的感觉是基本上没戏
了。不知道版上有没有类似的情况,有没有argue成功的?谢谢。
一个reviewer意见很positive, “Overall this is a very nice paper, with a
very novel message”,另外提了一些小意见。
另一个reviwer意见negative, “Although the manuscript presents some
interesting observations using tools to describe endogenous levels of tagged
pathway components, the data are simply not sufficient to support the
proposed model, and I therefore cannot recommend publication in ***.”
提的意见很picky,完全有点挑刺的感觉。
感觉怎么补数据,第二个reviewer都不会相信了。
迷茫中,老板的意见是补数据,看能不能说服第二个reviewer,我的感觉是基本上没戏
了。不知道版上有没有类似的情况,有没有argue成功的?谢谢。
P*R
4 楼
editor的意见呢?
s*g
6 楼
Editor的意见是“As you will see, they are somewhat divided in their view of
the paper. Reviewer 1 is enthusiastic about the observations, whereas
Reviewer 2's more negative view is I think colored by the technical concerns
he/she has regarding the support for the overall model”,
Editor认为数据是compelling的,但是也考虑到第二个reviewer的意见,所以同意给
revision。
【在 P****R 的大作中提到】
: editor的意见呢?
the paper. Reviewer 1 is enthusiastic about the observations, whereas
Reviewer 2's more negative view is I think colored by the technical concerns
he/she has regarding the support for the overall model”,
Editor认为数据是compelling的,但是也考虑到第二个reviewer的意见,所以同意给
revision。
【在 P****R 的大作中提到】
: editor的意见呢?
c*g
7 楼
NSC如今不少比tsc快么?
P*R
8 楼
那么把反对意见仔细看看,哪个是关键可以让Reviewer 2感到满意?有些吹毛求疵的地
方可以忽略不计。
你老板意思是做一点数据让Reviewer 2满意。这些实验很难吗?
你的model有没有判断性实验结果可以证明?如果有就应该据此同Reviewer 2进行争辩。
of
concerns
【在 s*********g 的大作中提到】
: Editor的意见是“As you will see, they are somewhat divided in their view of
: the paper. Reviewer 1 is enthusiastic about the observations, whereas
: Reviewer 2's more negative view is I think colored by the technical concerns
: he/she has regarding the support for the overall model”,
: Editor认为数据是compelling的,但是也考虑到第二个reviewer的意见,所以同意给
: revision。
方可以忽略不计。
你老板意思是做一点数据让Reviewer 2满意。这些实验很难吗?
你的model有没有判断性实验结果可以证明?如果有就应该据此同Reviewer 2进行争辩。
of
concerns
【在 s*********g 的大作中提到】
: Editor的意见是“As you will see, they are somewhat divided in their view of
: the paper. Reviewer 1 is enthusiastic about the observations, whereas
: Reviewer 2's more negative view is I think colored by the technical concerns
: he/she has regarding the support for the overall model”,
: Editor认为数据是compelling的,但是也考虑到第二个reviewer的意见,所以同意给
: revision。
b*s
10 楼
非生物领域,我感觉逐条回复reviewer2的意见,按你老板要求补充数据和讨论,在编
辑看了reviewer2这么负面的评价以后还给revision,修改后应该还是比较有把握的,
不应该这么就放弃了。我老板对付这种审稿意见特别有经验,editor给了revision的情
况下没有不过关的,response letter很重要
of
concerns
【在 s*********g 的大作中提到】
: Editor的意见是“As you will see, they are somewhat divided in their view of
: the paper. Reviewer 1 is enthusiastic about the observations, whereas
: Reviewer 2's more negative view is I think colored by the technical concerns
: he/she has regarding the support for the overall model”,
: Editor认为数据是compelling的,但是也考虑到第二个reviewer的意见,所以同意给
: revision。
辑看了reviewer2这么负面的评价以后还给revision,修改后应该还是比较有把握的,
不应该这么就放弃了。我老板对付这种审稿意见特别有经验,editor给了revision的情
况下没有不过关的,response letter很重要
of
concerns
【在 s*********g 的大作中提到】
: Editor的意见是“As you will see, they are somewhat divided in their view of
: the paper. Reviewer 1 is enthusiastic about the observations, whereas
: Reviewer 2's more negative view is I think colored by the technical concerns
: he/she has regarding the support for the overall model”,
: Editor认为数据是compelling的,但是也考虑到第二个reviewer的意见,所以同意给
: revision。
相关阅读
求助文章,谢谢genescript公司招聘--可内部推荐动物界最屌的根本不是狮子老虎急征ps高手,检查文章谁给科普下zfn, talen, crispr ddargseveral papers retracted in JCS颜宁:全球著名科学杂志认为:这10个年轻人将让中国成为科技韩和小宝方本质上不一样求千青评估paper help!有多少比例paper的结论是错的?冯新华和颜宁在想什么?POSTDOCTORAL POSITION in Cancer Biology韩春雨的事情有赌盘吗?颜宁最新高清大照已经确认韩春雨是个骗子。天下最牛的面试者!大家可以试试,呵呵 (转载)生物信息学招人要求真高啊,不过工资也高,据说能到5万颜宁当初加“如果结果solid”真是明智啊蛋白质和蛇