发信人: happyfly (快乐小苍蝇), 信区: Biology 标 题: 问个Nature Communications投稿的事 发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Mon Sep 17 23:26:11 2018, 美东) 修后再投,很快就送审了,大约一周左右就回到编辑手里(Manuscript under consideration), 在编辑手里停了2-3天,再次送审,大约两周后,状态变为: Manuscript under consideration 这个状态一直没变,现在已经过了两周了。是不是出什么问题了? ====== 汇报一下进展: 9月19日没忍住写信问了编辑,编辑20日回信: Thank you for your message. We have received reviewer reports and I will need to discuss everything with a colleague in order to make a decision on the manuscript. I will be in contact as soon as possible. 26日编辑又回了一封: Thank you for your message. We have received reports from three reviewers, and I am currently trying to contact one of the reviewers for additional feedback. My apologies for the delay with your manuscript. I will be in contact with a decision as soon as possible. 10月10日收到Decision on manuscript xxxxxxx: Your manuscript entitled "xxxx" has now been seen by 3 referees. You will see from their comments below that while they find your work of interest, some important points are raised. We are interested in the possibility of publishing your study in Nature Communications, but would like to consider your response to these concerns in the form of a revised manuscript before we make a final decision on publication. My apologies for the delay in reaching a decision on your manuscript. We have been in contact with reviewers 1 and 3 for further feedback before making a decision. Please not that we were unable to obtain feedback from reviewer 2 and recruited reviewer 4 who has similar expertise. Given the feedback from reviewers, we invite you to revise and resubmit your manuscript, taking into account the points raised. Please also make sure to address remaining concerns of reviewer 4. Please highlight all changes in the manuscript text file. 后面只是一些小问题,谢天谢地不需要补实验了。
我的under consideration后3天就送审了: 23rd February 18 Manuscript under consideration 20th February 18 Editor Assigned 20th February 18 Manuscript submitted 17th February 18 持续一周是好事,要是编辑直接据的话早就据了。现在应该是找审稿人呢。
发信人: happyfly (快乐小苍蝇), 信区: Biology 标 题: 问个Nature Communications投稿的事 发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Mon Sep 17 23:26:11 2018, 美东) 修后再投,很快就送审了,大约一周左右就回到编辑手里(Manuscript under consideration), 在编辑手里停了2-3天,再次送审,大约两周后,状态变为: Manuscript under consideration 这个状态一直没变,现在已经过了两周了。是不是出什么问题了? ====== 汇报一下进展: 9月19日没忍住写信问了编辑,编辑20日回信: Thank you for your message. We have received reviewer reports and I will need to discuss everything with a colleague in order to make a decision on the manuscript. I will be in contact as soon as possible. 26日编辑又回了一封: Thank you for your message. We have received reports from three reviewers, and I am currently trying to contact one of the reviewers for additional feedback. My apologies for the delay with your manuscript. I will be in contact with a decision as soon as possible. 10月10日收到Decision on manuscript xxxxxxx: Your manuscript entitled "xxxx" has now been seen by 3 referees. You will see from their comments below that while they find your work of interest, some important points are raised. We are interested in the possibility of publishing your study in Nature Communications, but would like to consider your response to these concerns in the form of a revised manuscript before we make a final decision on publication. My apologies for the delay in reaching a decision on your manuscript. We have been in contact with reviewers 1 and 3 for further feedback before making a decision. Please not that we were unable to obtain feedback from reviewer 2 and recruited reviewer 4 who has similar expertise. Given the feedback from reviewers, we invite you to revise and resubmit your manuscript, taking into account the points raised. Please also make sure to address remaining concerns of reviewer 4. Please highlight all changes in the manuscript text file. 后面只是一些小问题,谢天谢地不需要补实验了。
我的under consideration后3天就送审了: 23rd February 18 Manuscript under consideration 20th February 18 Editor Assigned 20th February 18 Manuscript submitted 17th February 18 持续一周是好事,要是编辑直接据的话早就据了。现在应该是找审稿人呢。
继续汇报。第二次修改和回答审稿人问题(就一个审稿人提了一个比较重要的问题), 然后我们修改后于10月23日提交。 投稿系统显示送给审稿人10天左右就返给了编辑,结果左等右等也没消息,于是写信问 编辑,今天回信了。看来没啥大问题了,到现在为止,前后折腾了将近10个月。 Dear Dr XX, Thank you for your message regarding your manuscript entitled "XXXXXX ". My apologies for the delay in reaching a decision, I had a few unusually busy weeks. I have discussed the manuscript with my colleagues and I am happy to let you know that we are going to accept it in principle, pending final revisions. We will need to do some checks on the manuscript and I will be in contact with a decision as soon as possible. Kind regards, XXX