Re: Anyone know how to write a referee report? Thanks (no contents)# Economics - 经济
c*e
1 楼
needn't be too long.
briefly summarize the paper first,
then give some evaluations.
say, whether the conclusion is robust, whether the assumptions are too
restrive, etc.
(if you are referring a published paper, better not say something like "this
is really garbage...")
finally, if you like, you can mention possible extensions a little bit.
briefly summarize the paper first,
then give some evaluations.
say, whether the conclusion is robust, whether the assumptions are too
restrive, etc.
(if you are referring a published paper, better not say something like "this
is really garbage...")
finally, if you like, you can mention possible extensions a little bit.