怎么办呢？ (转载)# Joke - 肚皮舞运动
d*g
1 楼
在版上经常看到帖子说：
发文章的时候，匿名的review/comment 也可以作为证据，证明contribution.
可是有的comments非常简单，这样的只言片语真的有用吗？比如：
This paper is a very good quality publication. It is perfect written and I
will recommend this excellent paper for publishing in xxx.
还有，一般情况下，review说好话，但是也有一些保留，同时也提出一些修改意见，也
就是说：不可能全是好话。比如说：
...This work is interesting and is a good contribution to the subject. I
recommend publication with minor corrections.
然后还说：These results are valid only for limited situations and not easy
to use for engineering purpose.还有一些具体修改的意见，比如图表什么的。这样
的review comments 能用吗？
还有的只是简单说一下：The results appear to be reasonable and the author has
done a good job.
谢谢。
发文章的时候，匿名的review/comment 也可以作为证据，证明contribution.
可是有的comments非常简单，这样的只言片语真的有用吗？比如：
This paper is a very good quality publication. It is perfect written and I
will recommend this excellent paper for publishing in xxx.
还有，一般情况下，review说好话，但是也有一些保留，同时也提出一些修改意见，也
就是说：不可能全是好话。比如说：
...This work is interesting and is a good contribution to the subject. I
recommend publication with minor corrections.
然后还说：These results are valid only for limited situations and not easy
to use for engineering purpose.还有一些具体修改的意见，比如图表什么的。这样
的review comments 能用吗？
还有的只是简单说一下：The results appear to be reasonable and the author has
done a good job.
谢谢。
