所谓从401K取钱付首付# Living
i*y
1 楼
想做些Backtesting，不知道有什马软件比较好用，能灵活定义测试条件？
我目前知道的有Ninjatrader和AmiBroker。有没有其他更好的？
我目前知道的有Ninjatrader和AmiBroker。有没有其他更好的？
l*x
2 楼
就是loan吧？我登录了401k网站看到似乎也就这一个方法，4.25%的利率。
我记得以前听谁说有没利率的取款方法？忘了。
如果这个就是loan的话，应付一下首付不足，那这个loan会不会在信用记录里面成为我
的债务的一部分？每个月还要还这个loan，那不影响我贷款能力吗？
谢谢！
我记得以前听谁说有没利率的取款方法？忘了。
如果这个就是loan的话，应付一下首付不足，那这个loan会不会在信用记录里面成为我
的债务的一部分？每个月还要还这个loan，那不影响我贷款能力吗？
谢谢！
a*e
3 楼
openquant, wealth-lab, tradestation, etc
really depends on your frequency.
for minute to second level trading,
I found no commercial package really works.
【在 i********y 的大作中提到】
: 想做些Backtesting，不知道有什马软件比较好用，能灵活定义测试条件？
: 我目前知道的有Ninjatrader和AmiBroker。有没有其他更好的？
really depends on your frequency.
for minute to second level trading,
I found no commercial package really works.
【在 i********y 的大作中提到】
: 想做些Backtesting，不知道有什马软件比较好用，能灵活定义测试条件？
: 我目前知道的有Ninjatrader和AmiBroker。有没有其他更好的？
b*p
4 楼
This is the only way. You are borrowing money from yourself. It doesn't
matter whether you are paying interest or not.
This loan doesn't affect your ability to pay other loan because it is your
money. It doesn't show up on your credit report either.
【在 l***x 的大作中提到】
: 就是loan吧？我登录了401k网站看到似乎也就这一个方法，4.25%的利率。
: 我记得以前听谁说有没利率的取款方法？忘了。
: 如果这个就是loan的话，应付一下首付不足，那这个loan会不会在信用记录里面成为我
: 的债务的一部分？每个月还要还这个loan，那不影响我贷款能力吗？
: 谢谢！
matter whether you are paying interest or not.
This loan doesn't affect your ability to pay other loan because it is your
money. It doesn't show up on your credit report either.
【在 l***x 的大作中提到】
: 就是loan吧？我登录了401k网站看到似乎也就这一个方法，4.25%的利率。
: 我记得以前听谁说有没利率的取款方法？忘了。
: 如果这个就是loan的话，应付一下首付不足，那这个loan会不会在信用记录里面成为我
: 的债务的一部分？每个月还要还这个loan，那不影响我贷款能力吗？
: 谢谢！
w*s
5 楼
我有in house second／sub second的。
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: openquant, wealth-lab, tradestation, etc
: really depends on your frequency.
: for minute to second level trading,
: I found no commercial package really works.
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: openquant, wealth-lab, tradestation, etc
: really depends on your frequency.
: for minute to second level trading,
: I found no commercial package really works.
l*o
6 楼
好像利息是付给你自己的， 所以等于没有。
【在 l***x 的大作中提到】
: 就是loan吧？我登录了401k网站看到似乎也就这一个方法，4.25%的利率。
: 我记得以前听谁说有没利率的取款方法？忘了。
: 如果这个就是loan的话，应付一下首付不足，那这个loan会不会在信用记录里面成为我
: 的债务的一部分？每个月还要还这个loan，那不影响我贷款能力吗？
: 谢谢！
【在 l***x 的大作中提到】
: 就是loan吧？我登录了401k网站看到似乎也就这一个方法，4.25%的利率。
: 我记得以前听谁说有没利率的取款方法？忘了。
: 如果这个就是loan的话，应付一下首付不足，那这个loan会不会在信用记录里面成为我
: 的债务的一部分？每个月还要还这个loan，那不影响我贷款能力吗？
: 谢谢！
f*n
7 楼
这个是不是要在NASDAQ或者NYSE租个服务器？好像亚马逊的也凑着。
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: 我有in house second／sub second的。
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: 我有in house second／sub second的。
o*p
8 楼
若401k还钱是从pay check, 付。万一被lender发现，有些lender不作为你的debt, 有
些仍作为你的debt. 虽然信用报告没显示。
些仍作为你的debt. 虽然信用报告没显示。
a*e
9 楼
for these level, backtesting won't work.
Because you really have to consider slippage, market impact now.
I don't see how that happen with any simulator.
I mean even IB automatic trading paper account is debatable.
The whole mechanism is still black-box.
You don't know under what condition, your MKT/LMT order will be filled
by your paper account. And I don't think it's reasonable to make
any assumption.
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: 我有in house second／sub second的。
Because you really have to consider slippage, market impact now.
I don't see how that happen with any simulator.
I mean even IB automatic trading paper account is debatable.
The whole mechanism is still black-box.
You don't know under what condition, your MKT/LMT order will be filled
by your paper account. And I don't think it's reasonable to make
any assumption.
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: 我有in house second／sub second的。
l*x
10 楼
谢谢楼上各位，说得非常清楚！
【在 o*****p 的大作中提到】
: 若401k还钱是从pay check, 付。万一被lender发现，有些lender不作为你的debt, 有
: 些仍作为你的debt. 虽然信用报告没显示。
【在 o*****p 的大作中提到】
: 若401k还钱是从pay check, 付。万一被lender发现，有些lender不作为你的debt, 有
: 些仍作为你的debt. 虽然信用报告没显示。
f*n
11 楼
小散什么样的可以？15分钟以上的？
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: for these level, backtesting won't work.
: Because you really have to consider slippage, market impact now.
: I don't see how that happen with any simulator.
: I mean even IB automatic trading paper account is debatable.
: The whole mechanism is still black-box.
: You don't know under what condition, your MKT/LMT order will be filled
: by your paper account. And I don't think it's reasonable to make
: any assumption.
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: for these level, backtesting won't work.
: Because you really have to consider slippage, market impact now.
: I don't see how that happen with any simulator.
: I mean even IB automatic trading paper account is debatable.
: The whole mechanism is still black-box.
: You don't know under what condition, your MKT/LMT order will be filled
: by your paper account. And I don't think it's reasonable to make
: any assumption.
w*s
12 楼
我知道你说的，我只能试图一些模拟来work around，书本读的少，逗是些土办法。
没法真正意义的完全backtesting，但还是很有用的。好机会在现实中总是难fill的。
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: for these level, backtesting won't work.
: Because you really have to consider slippage, market impact now.
: I don't see how that happen with any simulator.
: I mean even IB automatic trading paper account is debatable.
: The whole mechanism is still black-box.
: You don't know under what condition, your MKT/LMT order will be filled
: by your paper account. And I don't think it's reasonable to make
: any assumption.
没法真正意义的完全backtesting，但还是很有用的。好机会在现实中总是难fill的。
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: for these level, backtesting won't work.
: Because you really have to consider slippage, market impact now.
: I don't see how that happen with any simulator.
: I mean even IB automatic trading paper account is debatable.
: The whole mechanism is still black-box.
: You don't know under what condition, your MKT/LMT order will be filled
: by your paper account. And I don't think it's reasonable to make
: any assumption.
a*e
13 楼
depends what you trade,
I guess 2-5 minute will still be relatively ok for top liquid stuff.
【在 f********n 的大作中提到】
: 小散什么样的可以？15分钟以上的？
I guess 2-5 minute will still be relatively ok for top liquid stuff.
【在 f********n 的大作中提到】
: 小散什么样的可以？15分钟以上的？
a*e
14 楼
it's still not bad if it's just opportunity cost,
like I mentioned before, you could be stopped nowhere if you use stp,
and failed to fill if you use stplmt.
not sure, if one of the solution would be stplmt but keeps reducing(for long)
lmt if price gap down beyond the limit.
so, to backtest one minute level strategies, one really needs tick data,
one minute bar won't be sufficient.
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: 我知道你说的，我只能试图一些模拟来work around，书本读的少，逗是些土办法。
: 没法真正意义的完全backtesting，但还是很有用的。好机会在现实中总是难fill的。
like I mentioned before, you could be stopped nowhere if you use stp,
and failed to fill if you use stplmt.
not sure, if one of the solution would be stplmt but keeps reducing(for long)
lmt if price gap down beyond the limit.
so, to backtest one minute level strategies, one really needs tick data,
one minute bar won't be sufficient.
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: 我知道你说的，我只能试图一些模拟来work around，书本读的少，逗是些土办法。
: 没法真正意义的完全backtesting，但还是很有用的。好机会在现实中总是难fill的。
g*u
15 楼
Village Head is a high hand, indeed!
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: 我知道你说的，我只能试图一些模拟来work around，书本读的少，逗是些土办法。
: 没法真正意义的完全backtesting，但还是很有用的。好机会在现实中总是难fill的。
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: 我知道你说的，我只能试图一些模拟来work around，书本读的少，逗是些土办法。
: 没法真正意义的完全backtesting，但还是很有用的。好机会在现实中总是难fill的。
a*e
16 楼
I think a lot of empirical stuff works better.
Trading has far less fun if it's a pure science.
pure science only exists conceptually.
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: 我知道你说的，我只能试图一些模拟来work around，书本读的少，逗是些土办法。
: 没法真正意义的完全backtesting，但还是很有用的。好机会在现实中总是难fill的。
Trading has far less fun if it's a pure science.
pure science only exists conceptually.
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: 我知道你说的，我只能试图一些模拟来work around，书本读的少，逗是些土办法。
: 没法真正意义的完全backtesting，但还是很有用的。好机会在现实中总是难fill的。
w*s
17 楼
for stop, I think you need to use your own mechanism to stop.
the one you submit to the broker earlier is visible to others and could be
used to trigger..
my stop algorithm is quite complicated and always do much better job than
myself.
long)
的。
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: it's still not bad if it's just opportunity cost,
: like I mentioned before, you could be stopped nowhere if you use stp,
: and failed to fill if you use stplmt.
: not sure, if one of the solution would be stplmt but keeps reducing(for long)
: lmt if price gap down beyond the limit.
: so, to backtest one minute level strategies, one really needs tick data,
: one minute bar won't be sufficient.
the one you submit to the broker earlier is visible to others and could be
used to trigger..
my stop algorithm is quite complicated and always do much better job than
myself.
long)
的。
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: it's still not bad if it's just opportunity cost,
: like I mentioned before, you could be stopped nowhere if you use stp,
: and failed to fill if you use stplmt.
: not sure, if one of the solution would be stplmt but keeps reducing(for long)
: lmt if price gap down beyond the limit.
: so, to backtest one minute level strategies, one really needs tick data,
: one minute bar won't be sufficient.
f*n
18 楼
看不懂，能不能用例子，动画或者录像解释一下？谢谢
long)
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: it's still not bad if it's just opportunity cost,
: like I mentioned before, you could be stopped nowhere if you use stp,
: and failed to fill if you use stplmt.
: not sure, if one of the solution would be stplmt but keeps reducing(for long)
: lmt if price gap down beyond the limit.
: so, to backtest one minute level strategies, one really needs tick data,
: one minute bar won't be sufficient.
long)
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: it's still not bad if it's just opportunity cost,
: like I mentioned before, you could be stopped nowhere if you use stp,
: and failed to fill if you use stplmt.
: not sure, if one of the solution would be stplmt but keeps reducing(for long)
: lmt if price gap down beyond the limit.
: so, to backtest one minute level strategies, one really needs tick data,
: one minute bar won't be sufficient.
a*e
19 楼
stop limit orders are probably candies for market maker.
I felt the same way, but haven't think it through.
I think your are probably right in most case, in a relative
low volatile market, stop by your own instead of submit a
child stop loss order is most likely better.
But for high volatile market, it's a trade-off, depends on
how fast your program is.
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: for stop, I think you need to use your own mechanism to stop.
: the one you submit to the broker earlier is visible to others and could be
: used to trigger..
: my stop algorithm is quite complicated and always do much better job than
: myself.
:
: long)
: 的。
I felt the same way, but haven't think it through.
I think your are probably right in most case, in a relative
low volatile market, stop by your own instead of submit a
child stop loss order is most likely better.
But for high volatile market, it's a trade-off, depends on
how fast your program is.
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: for stop, I think you need to use your own mechanism to stop.
: the one you submit to the broker earlier is visible to others and could be
: used to trigger..
: my stop algorithm is quite complicated and always do much better job than
: myself.
:
: long)
: 的。
w*s
20 楼
yeah.. bad opportunity is easier to fill..
market is always right..
after watch the movie of "source code", whenever I get good stuff not filled
when I was in the queue, I will just think that in another m universe, this
order is filled. and that village head is happily counting money already.
long)
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: it's still not bad if it's just opportunity cost,
: like I mentioned before, you could be stopped nowhere if you use stp,
: and failed to fill if you use stplmt.
: not sure, if one of the solution would be stplmt but keeps reducing(for long)
: lmt if price gap down beyond the limit.
: so, to backtest one minute level strategies, one really needs tick data,
: one minute bar won't be sufficient.
market is always right..
after watch the movie of "source code", whenever I get good stuff not filled
when I was in the queue, I will just think that in another m universe, this
order is filled. and that village head is happily counting money already.
long)
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: it's still not bad if it's just opportunity cost,
: like I mentioned before, you could be stopped nowhere if you use stp,
: and failed to fill if you use stplmt.
: not sure, if one of the solution would be stplmt but keeps reducing(for long)
: lmt if price gap down beyond the limit.
: so, to backtest one minute level strategies, one really needs tick data,
: one minute bar won't be sufficient.
a*e
21 楼
that's a good point,
as I felt I was taken advantage of by market maker more frequent
than I thought.
Regarding ES, the spread is 99.5% one tick.
I really don't know how market makers profit unless majority orders
are from market makers.
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: for stop, I think you need to use your own mechanism to stop.
: the one you submit to the broker earlier is visible to others and could be
: used to trigger..
: my stop algorithm is quite complicated and always do much better job than
: myself.
:
: long)
: 的。
as I felt I was taken advantage of by market maker more frequent
than I thought.
Regarding ES, the spread is 99.5% one tick.
I really don't know how market makers profit unless majority orders
are from market makers.
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: for stop, I think you need to use your own mechanism to stop.
: the one you submit to the broker earlier is visible to others and could be
: used to trigger..
: my stop algorithm is quite complicated and always do much better job than
: myself.
:
: long)
: 的。
a*e
22 楼
is that a good movie?
filled
this
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: yeah.. bad opportunity is easier to fill..
: market is always right..
: after watch the movie of "source code", whenever I get good stuff not filled
: when I was in the queue, I will just think that in another m universe, this
: order is filled. and that village head is happily counting money already.
:
: long)
filled
this
【在 w******s 的大作中提到】
: yeah.. bad opportunity is easier to fill..
: market is always right..
: after watch the movie of "source code", whenever I get good stuff not filled
: when I was in the queue, I will just think that in another m universe, this
: order is filled. and that village head is happily counting money already.
:
: long)
w*s
23 楼
i like it a lot. mind uploading and parrellel universe.. jake did very well
in that movie.
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: is that a good movie?
:
: filled
: this
in that movie.
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: is that a good movie?
:
: filled
: this
i*y
24 楼
多谢，主要是中长线，不需要DT。
我看到往上说不少软件做Backtesting都有bug，几次运行结果不一致，所以想问一下有
没有人这方面有经验
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: openquant, wealth-lab, tradestation, etc
: really depends on your frequency.
: for minute to second level trading,
: I found no commercial package really works.
我看到往上说不少软件做Backtesting都有bug，几次运行结果不一致，所以想问一下有
没有人这方面有经验
【在 a*****e 的大作中提到】
: openquant, wealth-lab, tradestation, etc
: really depends on your frequency.
: for minute to second level trading,
: I found no commercial package really works.
w*s
25 楼
tradestation is pretty good already.
if there is some probability involved, you may not see the same result every
time.
【在 i********y 的大作中提到】
: 多谢，主要是中长线，不需要DT。
: 我看到往上说不少软件做Backtesting都有bug，几次运行结果不一致，所以想问一下有
: 没有人这方面有经验
if there is some probability involved, you may not see the same result every
time.
【在 i********y 的大作中提到】
: 多谢，主要是中长线，不需要DT。
: 我看到往上说不少软件做Backtesting都有bug，几次运行结果不一致，所以想问一下有
: 没有人这方面有经验
相关阅读
attic 有死苍蝇蜜蜂正常吗？如何对付 sensitive smoke detector好奇问一下，家里的水暖系统一般能hold多少水？这个窗帘在哪里买？11约6号以后close的，新的5405出来了没有？这些天有没有什么好的washer和dryer 推荐＊＊＊＊还来得及吗？＊＊＊＊有没有用induction cooktop的？请问,如何说"请勿上门推销"?请帮忙看看这个什么意思？shortsale的房子能比regular sale的房子便宜多少呢？8月份寄的8000rebate现在还没消息请推荐洗碗机，炉子和烤箱家里忽然有很多七星瓢虫是怎么回事？地下室有流水正常吗？东部地区经常有暴风雪，万一停电了，家里有小孩的做啥准备呢什么商店卖一些配件？target的那个家具sale你们搞出free shipping了吗？驚人發現! 洗碗機比手洗省水???heater filter 疑问