m*1
2 楼
RD 2017/09/01
NOID: 2018/03/29
文章数：22
引用数： 120
Reviews: 30
质疑review 部分:
...the evidence does not establish that his participation in the widespread
peer-review process (a routine process in the field relying on many
scientists) exceeds that of other researchers or reflects international
recognition.
No an editorial board of a prestigious journal or as general chair of a
professional scientific conference.
质疑publication 部分：
It is difficult to determine a published work's importance or influence if
there is little to no evidence that other scholars have relied on researcher
's findings.
you do not demonstrate how the number of citations of his publications
reflects that the beneficiary is recognized internationally as outstanding
in the academic field
质疑contribution 部分：
...Yet this visa classification requires evidence of an outstanding academic
record, i.e., marked by superiority or distinction which goes beyond what
any graduate student or postdoc can claim.
...the beneficiary's record neither distinguishes him from other researchers
nor establishes that he is recognized internationally as outstanding in the
academic field.
结论部分：
The evidence of record show that the beneficiary meets the plain language of
2 regulatory criteria, but it does not show that he is very strong in any
of them. ...is not recognized internationally as outstanding in the academic
field.
公司的F家律师，本人刚刚拿到notice, 毫无应对之法，希望大家给些建议。谢谢！
NOID: 2018/03/29
文章数：22
引用数： 120
Reviews: 30
质疑review 部分:
...the evidence does not establish that his participation in the widespread
peer-review process (a routine process in the field relying on many
scientists) exceeds that of other researchers or reflects international
recognition.
No an editorial board of a prestigious journal or as general chair of a
professional scientific conference.
质疑publication 部分：
It is difficult to determine a published work's importance or influence if
there is little to no evidence that other scholars have relied on researcher
's findings.
you do not demonstrate how the number of citations of his publications
reflects that the beneficiary is recognized internationally as outstanding
in the academic field
质疑contribution 部分：
...Yet this visa classification requires evidence of an outstanding academic
record, i.e., marked by superiority or distinction which goes beyond what
any graduate student or postdoc can claim.
...the beneficiary's record neither distinguishes him from other researchers
nor establishes that he is recognized internationally as outstanding in the
academic field.
结论部分：
The evidence of record show that the beneficiary meets the plain language of
2 regulatory criteria, but it does not show that he is very strong in any
of them. ...is not recognized internationally as outstanding in the academic
field.
公司的F家律师，本人刚刚拿到notice, 毫无应对之法，希望大家给些建议。谢谢！
s*x
3 楼
应该算得
f*x
4 楼
感觉楼主的条件跟我差不多啊，天哪连eb1b都卡的这么严了
U*9
5 楼
what the F? TM的、这么好的条件 eb1b 都NOID. 让人活不活了。
S*e
6 楼
哪位IO
widespread
【在 m********1 的大作中提到】
: RD 2017/09/01
: NOID: 2018/03/29
: 文章数：22
: 引用数： 120
: Reviews: 30
: 质疑review 部分:
: ...the evidence does not establish that his participation in the widespread
: peer-review process (a routine process in the field relying on many
: scientists) exceeds that of other researchers or reflects international
: recognition.
widespread
【在 m********1 的大作中提到】
: RD 2017/09/01
: NOID: 2018/03/29
: 文章数：22
: 引用数： 120
: Reviews: 30
: 质疑review 部分:
: ...the evidence does not establish that his participation in the widespread
: peer-review process (a routine process in the field relying on many
: scientists) exceeds that of other researchers or reflects international
: recognition.
N*i
7 楼
我是新来的，不明白为啥不给RFE， 至于直接给NOID么?
单纯看IO评语，感觉好像是材料写得比较表面，没有深入说具体的影响贡献？
说错了lz不要生气啊，希望lz最终能通过。
单纯看IO评语，感觉好像是材料写得比较表面，没有深入说具体的影响贡献？
说错了lz不要生气啊，希望lz最终能通过。
y*m
8 楼
NOIDs are not necessarily worse than RFEs.
EB1B doesn't usually get RFE but NOID. USCIS memo states that if the
petitioner submitted enough evidence to meet at least 2 criteria, the
officer should issue NOID for the final merit determination challenge. As it
is easy to meet at least 2 criteria, most EB1Bs get NOID.
EB1B doesn't usually get RFE but NOID. USCIS memo states that if the
petitioner submitted enough evidence to meet at least 2 criteria, the
officer should issue NOID for the final merit determination challenge. As it
is easy to meet at least 2 criteria, most EB1Bs get NOID.
c*n
9 楼
io?
记得有一段时间0214频繁的搞1b
widespread
【在 m********1 的大作中提到】
: RD 2017/09/01
: NOID: 2018/03/29
: 文章数：22
: 引用数： 120
: Reviews: 30
: 质疑review 部分:
: ...the evidence does not establish that his participation in the widespread
: peer-review process (a routine process in the field relying on many
: scientists) exceeds that of other researchers or reflects international
: recognition.
记得有一段时间0214频繁的搞1b
widespread
【在 m********1 的大作中提到】
: RD 2017/09/01
: NOID: 2018/03/29
: 文章数：22
: 引用数： 120
: Reviews: 30
: 质疑review 部分:
: ...the evidence does not establish that his participation in the widespread
: peer-review process (a routine process in the field relying on many
: scientists) exceeds that of other researchers or reflects international
: recognition.
m*1
10 楼
IO 是0858
m*1
11 楼
Fragomen
【在 U*********9 的大作中提到】
: what the F? TM的、这么好的条件 eb1b 都NOID. 让人活不活了。
【在 U*********9 的大作中提到】
: what the F? TM的、这么好的条件 eb1b 都NOID. 让人活不活了。
m*1
12 楼
结论很中肯，谢谢祝福^_^
【在 N*******i 的大作中提到】
: 我是新来的，不明白为啥不给RFE， 至于直接给NOID么?
: 单纯看IO评语，感觉好像是材料写得比较表面，没有深入说具体的影响贡献？
: 说错了lz不要生气啊，希望lz最终能通过。
【在 N*******i 的大作中提到】
: 我是新来的，不明白为啥不给RFE， 至于直接给NOID么?
: 单纯看IO评语，感觉好像是材料写得比较表面，没有深入说具体的影响贡献？
: 说错了lz不要生气啊，希望lz最终能通过。
l*i
13 楼
感觉是挖的不够深，如果是走公司律师的话建议就要自己好好深挖了，包括别人文章引
用中对你的大段引用，高度评价，review部分可以让编辑给你写support letter
建议参考wangran，puma，bigbigbee等前辈的总结文章，一个很好的例子是https://
www.mitbbs.com/article_t/Immigration/32724453.html
总之祝好运！
用中对你的大段引用，高度评价，review部分可以让编辑给你写support letter
建议参考wangran，puma，bigbigbee等前辈的总结文章，一个很好的例子是https://
www.mitbbs.com/article_t/Immigration/32724453.html
总之祝好运！
N*i
14 楼
谢谢解答！
it
【在 y*********m 的大作中提到】
: NOIDs are not necessarily worse than RFEs.
: EB1B doesn't usually get RFE but NOID. USCIS memo states that if the
: petitioner submitted enough evidence to meet at least 2 criteria, the
: officer should issue NOID for the final merit determination challenge. As it
: is easy to meet at least 2 criteria, most EB1Bs get NOID.
it
【在 y*********m 的大作中提到】
: NOIDs are not necessarily worse than RFEs.
: EB1B doesn't usually get RFE but NOID. USCIS memo states that if the
: petitioner submitted enough evidence to meet at least 2 criteria, the
: officer should issue NOID for the final merit determination challenge. As it
: is easy to meet at least 2 criteria, most EB1Bs get NOID.
m*1
15 楼
感谢建议和链接。
【在 l*****i 的大作中提到】
: 感觉是挖的不够深，如果是走公司律师的话建议就要自己好好深挖了，包括别人文章引
: 用中对你的大段引用，高度评价，review部分可以让编辑给你写support letter
: 建议参考wangran，puma，bigbigbee等前辈的总结文章，一个很好的例子是https://
: www.mitbbs.com/article_t/Immigration/32724453.html
: 总之祝好运！
【在 l*****i 的大作中提到】
: 感觉是挖的不够深，如果是走公司律师的话建议就要自己好好深挖了，包括别人文章引
: 用中对你的大段引用，高度评价，review部分可以让编辑给你写support letter
: 建议参考wangran，puma，bigbigbee等前辈的总结文章，一个很好的例子是https://
: www.mitbbs.com/article_t/Immigration/32724453.html
: 总之祝好运！
d*m
16 楼
good luck
a*8
17 楼
只能说运气不好，一个朋友上周刚刚EB1b NSC PP 直接过； 三项指标都比你差很多；
但是他多了一项专利。
祝福
但是他多了一项专利。
祝福
m*1
18 楼
谢谢
【在 d********m 的大作中提到】
: good luck
【在 d********m 的大作中提到】
: good luck
g*7
19 楼
如果是TSC是躺过呀。
widespread
【在 m********1 的大作中提到】
: RD 2017/09/01
: NOID: 2018/03/29
: 文章数：22
: 引用数： 120
: Reviews: 30
: 质疑review 部分:
: ...the evidence does not establish that his participation in the widespread
: peer-review process (a routine process in the field relying on many
: scientists) exceeds that of other researchers or reflects international
: recognition.
widespread
【在 m********1 的大作中提到】
: RD 2017/09/01
: NOID: 2018/03/29
: 文章数：22
: 引用数： 120
: Reviews: 30
: 质疑review 部分:
: ...the evidence does not establish that his participation in the widespread
: peer-review process (a routine process in the field relying on many
: scientists) exceeds that of other researchers or reflects international
: recognition.
G*C
20 楼
bless！！！深挖一下材料祝顺利通过！！！
m*1
21 楼
谢谢祝福！
【在 a*******8 的大作中提到】
: 只能说运气不好，一个朋友上周刚刚EB1b NSC PP 直接过； 三项指标都比你差很多；
: 但是他多了一项专利。
: 祝福
【在 a*******8 的大作中提到】
: 只能说运气不好，一个朋友上周刚刚EB1b NSC PP 直接过； 三项指标都比你差很多；
: 但是他多了一项专利。
: 祝福
t*f
22 楼
你这个律师回复思路挺独特
请问关于策略的两点，你们有USCIS的官方文本支持吗？如果有，能否发我一份，谢谢！
widespread
【在 m********1 的大作中提到】
: RD 2017/09/01
: NOID: 2018/03/29
: 文章数：22
: 引用数： 120
: Reviews: 30
: 质疑review 部分:
: ...the evidence does not establish that his participation in the widespread
: peer-review process (a routine process in the field relying on many
: scientists) exceeds that of other researchers or reflects international
: recognition.
请问关于策略的两点，你们有USCIS的官方文本支持吗？如果有，能否发我一份，谢谢！
widespread
【在 m********1 的大作中提到】
: RD 2017/09/01
: NOID: 2018/03/29
: 文章数：22
: 引用数： 120
: Reviews: 30
: 质疑review 部分:
: ...the evidence does not establish that his participation in the widespread
: peer-review process (a routine process in the field relying on many
: scientists) exceeds that of other researchers or reflects international
: recognition.
相关阅读
TSC 绿卡等待中,本周五去inforpass，求祝福infopass 归来在File之前纠结要不要PP，真诚求意见Infopass归来【}RD 2016年 7月份】盖楼———— 485战友们，通报一下进度关于ppNSC non-PP EB1A 140 通过SR回复给母亲申请了绿卡，之后保险问题怎么办【2016年11月第15绿】副卡终于绿了485交流群有了绿卡之后是否还需要延H－1B visa？【2016年11月第8,9绿】TSC EB1B 7/22 RD审稿转让：图像处理， CNN有关打电话转tier2被拒。。。OPT期间拿combo卡回国需要告诉学校和HR吗IO会仔细查推荐信是不是独立的吗最近一段时间TSC的140是不是难搞啊？485 RFE received 后状态更新问题case is currently with an adjudicating officer是不是等于什么信息也没有