Lsat题目请教 2006/06-4-6 - 未名空间MITBBS历史存档

Lsat题目请教 2006/06-4-6# Law - 律师事务所

b*g2007-09-16 07:09

1 楼

L2006/6-4-6
The simutaneous and apparently independent development in several
ancient cultures of a myth of creatures who were half human and half horse
parallels the increased use of horses in these cultures. But despite the nob
ility and gentleness traditionally ascribed to the horse, the mythical half-
horse, half-humans were frequently portrayed as violent and savage. Many hum
an cultures use myth to express unconscious thoughts, so these mythical crea
tures obviously reflect people's uncons

S*Y2007-09-16 07:09

2 楼

b

horse
nob
half-
hum
crea
i

【在 b*******g 的大作中提到】

: L2006/6-4-6
: The simutaneous and apparently independent development in several
: ancient cultures of a myth of creatures who were half human and half horse
: parallels the increased use of horses in these cultures. But despite the nob
: ility and gentleness traditionally ascribed to the horse, the mythical half-
: horse, half-humans were frequently portrayed as violent and savage. Many hum
: an cultures use myth to express unconscious thoughts, so these mythical crea
: tures obviously reflect people's uncons

b*s2007-09-16 07:09

3 楼

a?

b*s2007-09-16 07:09

4 楼

这道题我只是觉得bcde肯定都不对才选a的，所以打了个问号嘛。：）现在想想可以大
致这么解释：我觉得中国传说里马确实都是好的，就换成龙来说吧。龙可以看成在鲤鱼
的基础上编出来的，尽管龙和鲤鱼的形象一般是好的，但在西游记里，哪吒的故事里，
龙王不是一般的凶残，坏。这种凶残和坏的描述并不说明老百姓心里害怕鲤鱼，而是对
有权优势的皇宫贵族的害怕。
嘿嘿，希望没有把你搞得更晕。这龙啊鲤鱼啊，都是我现在想的，做题的时候我只能用
排除法。

horse
nob
half-
hum
crea
i

【在 b*******g 的大作中提到】

: L2006/6-4-6
: The simutaneous and apparently independent development in several
: ancient cultures of a myth of creatures who were half human and half horse
: parallels the increased use of horses in these cultures. But despite the nob
: ility and gentleness traditionally ascribed to the horse, the mythical half-
: horse, half-humans were frequently portrayed as violent and savage. Many hum
: an cultures use myth to express unconscious thoughts, so these mythical crea
: tures obviously reflect people's uncons

h*o2007-09-16 07:09

5 楼

I just pass by this board and find this question interesting :)
I think the logic behind the given argument should be:
1. Many human cultures use myth to express unconscious thoughts (given)
2. The myth is linked to horse (not mentioned)
3. So the myth reflect people's unconscious fear of horse (conclusion)
However, the description of the ancient myth in the article actually express
the idea that the myth is linked to half-horse, half-human creature. So the
second statement above cannot stand. S

【在 b*******g 的大作中提到】

: L2006/6-4-6
: The simutaneous and apparently independent development in several
: ancient cultures of a myth of creatures who were half human and half horse
: parallels the increased use of horses in these cultures. But despite the nob
: ility and gentleness traditionally ascribed to the horse, the mythical half-
: horse, half-humans were frequently portrayed as violent and savage. Many hum
: an cultures use myth to express unconscious thoughts, so these mythical crea
: tures obviously reflect people's uncons

D*s2007-09-16 07:09

6 楼

a
half human, half horse, so they don't necessarily fear the horse. Maybe they
were just scared by "human".

horse
nob
half-
hum
crea
i

【在 b*******g 的大作中提到】

: L2006/6-4-6
: The simutaneous and apparently independent development in several
: ancient cultures of a myth of creatures who were half human and half horse
: parallels the increased use of horses in these cultures. But despite the nob
: ility and gentleness traditionally ascribed to the horse, the mythical half-
: horse, half-humans were frequently portrayed as violent and savage. Many hum
: an cultures use myth to express unconscious thoughts, so these mythical crea
: tures obviously reflect people's uncons

S*Y2007-09-16 07:09

7 楼

makes sense...

they

【在 D**********s 的大作中提到】

: a
: half human, half horse, so they don't necessarily fear the horse. Maybe they
: were just scared by "human".
:
: horse
: nob
: half-
: hum
: crea
: i