北大谢灿的文章有错吗？# Biology - 生物学
z*x
1 楼
这是从pubpeer上来的。
http://dx.doi.org/10.1101/094607
Abstract
Qin et al. (A magnetic protein compass, Nature Materials 15, 217-226, 2016)
claim that "MagR is the first known protein that carries an intrinsic
magnetic moment at ambient temperature". We show here that the claim must,
unfortunately, be fundamentally wrong.
---------------------------
A magnetic protein biocompass
Nature Materials (2016) - 16 Comments
doi: 10.1038/nmat4484 issn: 1476-1122 issn: 1476-4660 pubmed: 26569474
Siying Qin , Hang Yin , Celi Yang , Yunfeng Dou , Zhongmin Liu , Peng Zhang
, He Yu , Yulong Huang , Jing Feng , Junfeng Hao , Jia Hao , Lizong Deng ,
Xiyun Yan , Xiaoli Dong , Zhongxian Zhao , Taijiao Jiang , Hong-Wei Wang ,
Shu-Jin Luo , Can Xie
http://dx.doi.org/10.1101/094607
Abstract
Qin et al. (A magnetic protein compass, Nature Materials 15, 217-226, 2016)
claim that "MagR is the first known protein that carries an intrinsic
magnetic moment at ambient temperature". We show here that the claim must,
unfortunately, be fundamentally wrong.
---------------------------
A magnetic protein biocompass
Nature Materials (2016) - 16 Comments
doi: 10.1038/nmat4484 issn: 1476-1122 issn: 1476-4660 pubmed: 26569474
Siying Qin , Hang Yin , Celi Yang , Yunfeng Dou , Zhongmin Liu , Peng Zhang
, He Yu , Yulong Huang , Jing Feng , Junfeng Hao , Jia Hao , Lizong Deng ,
Xiyun Yan , Xiaoli Dong , Zhongxian Zhao , Taijiao Jiang , Hong-Wei Wang ,
Shu-Jin Luo , Can Xie