s*n
2 楼
不算
我还更奇葩 一篇Science的文章等了两月以为送审 发邮件问编辑说其实两月前已经拒
掉但忘记按send的按钮!
我还更奇葩 一篇Science的文章等了两月以为送审 发邮件问编辑说其实两月前已经拒
掉但忘记按send的按钮!
f*h
4 楼
我的文章被审半年。后来得知AE长期生病,根本没人送审。
g*h
5 楼
reviewer 失联一般都是不想审又不知道怎么推脱,所以干脆不回邮件 ...
k*u
6 楼
体谅一下AE,我一篇文章找了9个REVIEWERS,只有一个愿意REVIEW。。。还的继续找
H*N
9 楼
What journals are you sending your manuscripts? I usually write to the
editor after one month. If I don't hear from them for long, I would
withdraw and send it to a different journal.
editor after one month. If I don't hear from them for long, I would
withdraw and send it to a different journal.
p*l
11 楼
不同的journal速度不一样。
我上学期投了一篇,已经5个月了,一点消息都没有。
我同事,以前投了一篇,也是这个journal,过了一年半还是两年以后才被拒。
我上学期投了一篇,已经5个月了,一点消息都没有。
我同事,以前投了一篇,也是这个journal,过了一年半还是两年以后才被拒。
h*o
15 楼
生活好艰辛, AP的工资付不起房贷,
各位楼主,太像林黛玉了。
haha
各位楼主,太像林黛玉了。
haha
b*r
16 楼
才三个月
之前有一篇文章半年没反应,各种邮件询问N次,9个月后被告知“没有找到合适的
reviewer,让我自己推荐”
于是直接推荐了自己熟悉的同行们。不过投稿到最后发表历经1年8个月
之前有一篇文章半年没反应,各种邮件询问N次,9个月后被告知“没有找到合适的
reviewer,让我自己推荐”
于是直接推荐了自己熟悉的同行们。不过投稿到最后发表历经1年8个月
T*g
17 楼
这真是取决于领域啊。
我最惨的经历是投稿到一个杂志,中间催了很多次都没有消息,2年后最后通牒,说如
果再没消息就撤稿了,……于是后来只好撤稿了。
我最惨的经历是投稿到一个杂志,中间催了很多次都没有消息,2年后最后通牒,说如
果再没消息就撤稿了,……于是后来只好撤稿了。
H*y
20 楼
@HENBEN,刚收到的回复。你看我是否应该撤稿?
三个月整。
We are yet to receive the second reviewer comments. I fully understand your
concern and have now contacted the Reviewer with a reminder e-mail and the
Editor as well.
Though I may not be able to provide you with an estimated time frame on when
the review process will be complete, please be assured that this would be
taken care of.
All of our editors and reviewers are regularly sent reminders to ensure that
papers are dealt with as quickly as possible, and I hope that they will
send you a decision soon.
太过分了,定期发reminder就行了吗?我甚至可以这么说,如果编辑和审稿人有一个出
了意外,就无限期等下去了。应该是但凡审稿人一个月没交差也没来信解释,编辑就应
该自动找下一个。我一个月前催了,他们发现这种情况,如果当时再找个现在都应该审
完了。看信是没找。
我打算撤了。他们即使重新找人,也和我立刻投新杂志差不太多。关键是他们没有重新
找的意思。看这架势起码拖半年的样子。
: Why not? It is your paper, and you have the right to send it
anywhere
you
: want.
【在 H****N 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png)
: Why not? It is your paper, and you have the right to send it anywhere you
: want.
三个月整。
We are yet to receive the second reviewer comments. I fully understand your
concern and have now contacted the Reviewer with a reminder e-mail and the
Editor as well.
Though I may not be able to provide you with an estimated time frame on when
the review process will be complete, please be assured that this would be
taken care of.
All of our editors and reviewers are regularly sent reminders to ensure that
papers are dealt with as quickly as possible, and I hope that they will
send you a decision soon.
太过分了,定期发reminder就行了吗?我甚至可以这么说,如果编辑和审稿人有一个出
了意外,就无限期等下去了。应该是但凡审稿人一个月没交差也没来信解释,编辑就应
该自动找下一个。我一个月前催了,他们发现这种情况,如果当时再找个现在都应该审
完了。看信是没找。
我打算撤了。他们即使重新找人,也和我立刻投新杂志差不太多。关键是他们没有重新
找的意思。看这架势起码拖半年的样子。
: Why not? It is your paper, and you have the right to send it
anywhere
you
: want.
【在 H****N 的大作中提到】
![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png)
: Why not? It is your paper, and you have the right to send it anywhere you
: want.
H*N
21 楼
这种情况,撤没商量吧。对我来说,两个月是上线。
H*N
25 楼
This is why you should always be proactive, instead of just waiting. Give
them at most one week. If still there is no decision, just cut them off, and
don't submit to this journal again. I would also write to their chief
editor to complain.
1
【在 H****y 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png)
: 我估计一两天的事。要不就是reviewer 2刚刚提交了。要不就是新编辑觉得reviewer 1
: 的够据我了。嘿嘿。
them at most one week. If still there is no decision, just cut them off, and
don't submit to this journal again. I would also write to their chief
editor to complain.
1
【在 H****y 的大作中提到】
![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png)
: 我估计一两天的事。要不就是reviewer 2刚刚提交了。要不就是新编辑觉得reviewer 1
: 的够据我了。嘿嘿。
相关阅读
[合集] Liberal Arts Colleges到底是什么样的学校?是不是都很烂?求推荐适用于两天面试、舒服的男皮鞋(国内或美国的牌子皆可)推荐信的问题[合集] 进了teaching school后就没机会回research school了么?关于国内博士找faculty职位申请澳大利亚商学院教职心得(五)[合集] 签了新合同,想跳槽,原来学校要SUE我怎么办?[合集] 请问: 有口头offeroffer选择请大家讨论(请不要转载和全站置顶)想问一下美国的电磁方向NSF status的问题adjunct professor职位[合集] suggestions for informal dinner/lunch with search commi也谈回国到高校发展关于访问学者的请教急问这种情况,关于funding申请和同事关系收取版面费的期刊是对科研人员的严重侮辱,呼吁大家集体抵制这类垃圾期刊!!!!!!!!!!!储能技术领域招聘--中科院宁波材料所二期(工研院)筹建新能源技术研究所推荐信:学生和老师的误区和为老师说两句给同事送小礼品求教