c*y
2 楼
有哪家保险公司卖这类保险的么？怕有个万一什么的
h*o
3 楼
文章被reject了，但同时说可以revision.
3个reviewer的comments
Reviewer1: In this manuscript the authors used an elegant approach to
determine the effects of XXX in a mouse model of Alzheimer disease. 然后概
括了我们study 的内容。
This is a well conducted study and the data presented are of high quality
and clearly support the authors' conclusions. I believe that the findings
are important and the manuscript is nicely organized and carefully crafted.
I have only two minor suggestions to improve the paper further. 然后提了2个
小问题，而且还是我们自己的typo造成的。
Reviewer 2:同样概括了我们的主要findings。 Despite the fact that the
manuscript contains potential new and interesting information, there are
several points that need to be addressed
然后要一堆额外的数据 主要是想要我们再加一个不同的treatment组 ， 因为这个
study是个long term 的in vivostudy，不可能在增加一个。
Reviewer 3: Overall this is a very interesting and seemingly well-done paper
. The effects of XXX treatment are particularly interesting. It advances
the literature and will be of interest to many although there are some minor
criticisms/comments/questions about the work that can be ignored, addressed
, or refuted. 然后提了一些小建议，改改文字就可以了
现在头疼这第二个reviewer，基本上是不可能重新在做一个long term 的实验增加一个
treatment组了，想问问看这种情况还有希望能revise过去被接收吗？
谢谢
3个reviewer的comments
Reviewer1: In this manuscript the authors used an elegant approach to
determine the effects of XXX in a mouse model of Alzheimer disease. 然后概
括了我们study 的内容。
This is a well conducted study and the data presented are of high quality
and clearly support the authors' conclusions. I believe that the findings
are important and the manuscript is nicely organized and carefully crafted.
I have only two minor suggestions to improve the paper further. 然后提了2个
小问题，而且还是我们自己的typo造成的。
Reviewer 2:同样概括了我们的主要findings。 Despite the fact that the
manuscript contains potential new and interesting information, there are
several points that need to be addressed
然后要一堆额外的数据 主要是想要我们再加一个不同的treatment组 ， 因为这个
study是个long term 的in vivostudy，不可能在增加一个。
Reviewer 3: Overall this is a very interesting and seemingly well-done paper
. The effects of XXX treatment are particularly interesting. It advances
the literature and will be of interest to many although there are some minor
criticisms/comments/questions about the work that can be ignored, addressed
, or refuted. 然后提了一些小建议，改改文字就可以了
现在头疼这第二个reviewer，基本上是不可能重新在做一个long term 的实验增加一个
treatment组了，想问问看这种情况还有希望能revise过去被接收吗？
谢谢
TN
4 楼
平均一天没有一个，很多么？
【在 l*********r 的大作中提到】
: 好像报offer的不少啊
【在 l*********r 的大作中提到】
: 好像报offer的不少啊
h*u
5 楼
概
quality
findings
crafted.
个
Are you able to use review 1 and 3's comments against review2's? so that
you can talk to editor (on the phone) to agree on all the other revisions
except the new treatment experiments.
【在 h*******o 的大作中提到】
: 文章被reject了，但同时说可以revision.
: 3个reviewer的comments
: Reviewer1: In this manuscript the authors used an elegant approach to
: determine the effects of XXX in a mouse model of Alzheimer disease. 然后概
: 括了我们study 的内容。
: This is a well conducted study and the data presented are of high quality
: and clearly support the authors' conclusions. I believe that the findings
: are important and the manuscript is nicely organized and carefully crafted.
: I have only two minor suggestions to improve the paper further. 然后提了2个
: 小问题，而且还是我们自己的typo造成的。
D*a
6 楼
关键是你reject那封信的内容，是怎么说的
现在很多杂志一看到要补实验的comment就reject，但是会明确说如果能回答这些问题
欢迎重新投，其实就是个花招减少received 和 accepted 之间的gap就是了
看你的comment都停positive的，即使2也说了potential new and interesting
information，我觉得挺有希望的。不能做就说明为什么觉得没必要就是了，或者做点
相关实验减少下他的疑虑
现在很多杂志一看到要补实验的comment就reject，但是会明确说如果能回答这些问题
欢迎重新投，其实就是个花招减少received 和 accepted 之间的gap就是了
看你的comment都停positive的，即使2也说了potential new and interesting
information，我觉得挺有希望的。不能做就说明为什么觉得没必要就是了，或者做点
相关实验减少下他的疑虑
相关阅读
谁知道NIBS这次面试的情况？免疫组化求助（对照组）南京大学miRNA理论颠覆转基因安全神话,引世界轰动! 核心提示(转载)paper help, Thanks博后申请中什么叫write fellowship application科学家确定人类第一个玩笑发生在二百万年前大家帮我看一下这两个选择觉得生物学家都应该学习一下吴健雄的精神Question: How to sequence mutant gene?ideas are cheap?学术交流谈论帖anti-goat antibody求推荐Paper help每个细胞都有一样的DNA？与前实验室关系生物试剂公司兼职机会南京大学模式动物研究所招聘教授、副教授Heng Lipgk, EF1A, cmv 三个promotors的强弱顺序是啥样子的?关于phd学生自己申请额外funding