Re: 那个杨小凯,牛啊. - 未名空间MITBBS历史存档

国际科技财经博客移民网络热点娱乐民生时事公众号

Redian新闻

>未名空间

>Thoughts - 思考者

Re: 那个杨小凯,牛啊.

Re: 那个杨小凯,牛啊.# Thoughts - 思考者

o*e2003-05-11 07:05

1 楼

I have read Yang's testimony (2777). I have to say that his though was weak,
his argument was ridiculous, and he was dishonest.
As a phd from Princeton and currently a full professor, it's fair to say he is
NIU. But is he really a BIG NIU? I doubt, especially after I read his
testimony. How could a real Niu guy write such stuff?
I had thought he's a stupid guy. It seems that I was wrong. Maybe he is really
Niu, but when he wrote it, he only used the right part of his brain. It's sad.

w*d2003-05-11 07:05

2 楼

//sigh...
Trust me, nobody tries to fool you... nobody wants to take advantage of you...
I know it is difficult to talk a person into Christian by just one argument,
no matter how correct I feel about my own points. (Don't get confused... I am
not Mr. Yang himself, but I do developed many points pro Christianity by
myself which are quite similar to Mr. Yang's, this is why I quite agree with
Mr.Yang(though I am not quite sure of some of his points/attitudes at
the same time...))
But I do wish suc

【在 o*****e 的大作中提到】

:
: I have read Yang's testimony (2777). I have to say that his though was weak,
: his argument was ridiculous, and he was dishonest.
: As a phd from Princeton and currently a full professor, it's fair to say he is
: NIU. But is he really a BIG NIU? I doubt, especially after I read his
: testimony. How could a real Niu guy write such stuff?
: I had thought he's a stupid guy. It seems that I was wrong. Maybe he is really
: Niu, but when he wrote it, he only used the right part of his brain. It's sad.

o*e2003-05-11 07:05

3 楼

You praised Yang as NIU and you referred to his testimony. later, you said "I
quite agree with Mr.Yang". However, the testimony has full of poor arguments
and lies, which is inconsistent with your priase to him, ever if he is NIU in
academia (though I doubt). OK, let me give you some examples:
1. 上帝存在的最好的证明，一个是教会存在了两千年，世界上任何一个政治组织，任何
一个意识形态，连续不断的存在两千年，这是很难找到的。
How about confucism? I don't think he forgot it when he wrote.
2.
有些宗教,像基督新教，对经济发展，对社会和平--圣经里说的永久和平和公正秩序--起
着促进作用。这有着非常多的证明。
He talked ab

【在 w******d 的大作中提到】

: //sigh...
: Trust me, nobody tries to fool you... nobody wants to take advantage of you...
: I know it is difficult to talk a person into Christian by just one argument,
: no matter how correct I feel about my own points. (Don't get confused... I am
: not Mr. Yang himself, but I do developed many points pro Christianity by
: myself which are quite similar to Mr. Yang's, this is why I quite agree with
: Mr.Yang(though I am not quite sure of some of his points/attitudes at
: the same time...))
: But I do wish suc