Redian新闻
>
Rather than后面要用doing还是do?

Rather than后面要用doing还是do?

教育

新概念英语写作社群有同学问到了一个问题:rather than位于句首时,后面应该说do something还是doing something?


正确答案是两个都可以用,为什么会出现这种情况呢?这是因为rather than既可以作为连词理解,也可以当成介词理解。

(1)当rather than作为连词理解时,根据英语“平行结构”的要求,此时rather than前后的单词要保持词性和结构的一致,比如:For exercise, I walk rather than run. 此时rather than前后的单词walk以及run词性保持一致。

又比如BBC在评价最近的查尔斯三世(King Charles III)演讲时有这样的句子:

Another clear message being sent was that Charles was here for the long haul, the throne would be a lifelong commitment for him, for all "the remaining time God grants me". But it was an important, tone-setting speech that was absent of any pomposity, promising to serve rather than to rule.

…promising to serve rather than to rule,这里rather than前后也保持了一致。

在非正式场合中,rather than后面的to也可以省略,比如:He decided to call rather than text.

当rather than作为连词且位于句首时,后面的动词要用原形,比如《韦氏高阶英语词典》有这样的句子:Rather than continue the argument, she walked away. 


可以看到,虽然句子是过去时态,但是rather than后面仍然用动词原形。又比如《柯林斯词典》的例句:Rather than break her appointment and disappoint me, Katie again took the car.

(2)当rather than作为介词理解时,此时它相当于instead of,后面的动词要用现在分词形式,比如上面的韦氏词典同样有一条例句:Rather than using dried herbs, he picked fresh ones from the garden. 

此时rather than理解为介词,句子相当于:Instead of using dried herbs, he picked fresh ones from the garden.

虽然我们可以说rather than do/doing something,但目前rather than doing something更加常见一点。在Google Ngram Viewer上面比较"rather than make"以及"rather than making"的使用频率,可以发现,从上世纪60年代以后,rather than making的使用频率明显超过另一种:


比较"rather than do"以及"rather than doing",也可以看到类似的结果:


另一个容易被用错的短语是as well as,它后面必须用现在分词形式,即as well as doing something,比如:

(1) She negotiates the licences as well as ordering the equipment.

(2) Each week he wrote her three letters, as well as telephoning her.



推荐阅读

如何用两个月时间提升听力水平?

欢迎星标置顶“英文悦读”公众号

微信扫码关注该文公众号作者

戳这里提交新闻线索和高质量文章给我们。
相关阅读
hǎo xiǎng “rua” 🤩Deciphering the HanzisphereThe Art of Butchering5点之后的武汉,哪里最“sán”?[干货] 安慰他人时的有趣英文表达:There there~Summer (and Spring, and Fall) Heat Waves Are the New NormalFrom Baghdad to the Bund: The Family That Built Shanghai#英语学习#Farther和Further有什么区别?看看你能答对这道题吗?牵牛花心理测试,占卜你今夏运势Top20美高直播回顾The Thacher School撒切尔学校专场守住良知“清华大学”英文名前面要不要加the?精选SDE岗位 | Amazon、Thermo Fisher、Schneider Electric等公司发布最新岗位!人民公社的集体经济越来越壮大我也“阳”了开始使用Poplar Triton后端平价买到高级感!IKEA全新 OBEGRÄNSAD系列,全系列都好看!IKEA x OBEGRÄNSAD联名!宜家22年最受瞩目系列开售!Song Yadong: The Man Fighting to Make UFC History如何霸气翻译“I’m not in danger, I'm the danger”?这个回答绝了!Wu Zetian and the Quest for Feminism in All the Wrong PlacesThe Publisher Who Rekindled China’s Curiosity About the World“周末”应该说at the weekend还是on the weekend?China Bans Celebs From Endorsing Tutoring, Tobacco, and Others免费演出|Free Shakespeare on the Common 2022:Much Ado About Nothing这次的快乐是Dollarama给的!2刀一包扭扭搞定万圣节发饰Three times longer than something应该理解为三倍还是四倍?继PlayStation后,这位人工智能大师正在改造流行日本零食把这组大片zoom in后,我们总算知道JLo为什么一直状态在线了China Strengthens Cyber Violence Policing After Teacher’s Deaththe family后面要用is还是are?In 2022, Students Are Struggling to Cope. So Are Their Teachers.学人习语第256期:sort the wheat from the chaff | ​订阅送三重好礼!The Four Key Issues Facing China at the COP27 Climate Summit最美的加州(2):红杉树国家 公园的将军树
logo
联系我们隐私协议©2024 redian.news
Redian新闻
Redian.news刊载任何文章,不代表同意其说法或描述,仅为提供更多信息,也不构成任何建议。文章信息的合法性及真实性由其作者负责,与Redian.news及其运营公司无关。欢迎投稿,如发现稿件侵权,或作者不愿在本网发表文章,请版权拥有者通知本网处理。